Dynadot โ€” .com Transfer

Will Israel attack.... should they?

Spaceship Spaceship
Watch

Should Israel attack Iran's nuclear facility?

  • This poll is still running and the standings may change.
  • Yes

    votes
    28.0%
  • No

    18 
    votes
    72.0%
  • This poll is still running and the standings may change.

Impact
356
OK ... this is going to be a heated one. I'm curious to what my peers feel. I'm an American white male so I'm sure some of you to disagree with me for that reason alone but ho fully there will be more to you position than disdain for America and or Americans.

In 48 hours the Iran reactor will be active and an attack after it is active will release radiation thus harm Israel support in the public eye. Should they, Israel, attack Iran? Iran has clearly stated they wish to get a nuke to "wipe out" the Jewish people.


Will Israel attack Iran's nuclear power facility?

Should Israel attack the Iranian facility?

Should Iran be trusted with having nukes?

Would Iran use their nukes against Israel?

How would you handle the issue if you were Israel, America or Iran?

I will omit my opinion for now. See the pole. :)

NN
 
0
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
.US domains.US domains
"Will Israel attack Iran's nuclear power facility?'
No

"Would Iran use their nukes against Israel?"
No

Most of the talk is just for show. They know if they ever crossed that line, all hell would break loose.
 
1
•••
I really .. really hope not :(
 
0
•••
My vote: no. Israel, from my understanding, couldn't topple Iran. If they tried, they'd likely fold without help from their allies. I'm not saying the ppl of Israel are weak but I doubt their Army could do much against Iran.
 
1
•••
Don't underestimate Israel, they got some of the most high-tech weapons available on earth. That said, don't underestimate Iran neither, they may have or not have weapons but for sure if they're attacked first the odds are high that China and Russia will choose their side. Do we really want to open that can of worms?


One thing I feel quite confident of: Iran won't be the one attacking. They know very well that if they do that, it's them against the rest of the world. So while trying to be a tough guy may be a hobby of their president, it's just trying to impress the other parties involved. He knows very well that Iran is on its own if they'd attack first. If Iran has weapons (and we're not even sure of that) then it's most likely not going to be used unless they are attacked first, in which case they have the right to self-defend.


That brings us to the question: should Iran be trusted with nukes?
OF COURSE.

Look, I'm a pacifist. If there were a way to take all nuclear weapons away then I'd do it immediately. The damage they can do is so big that no nation should have them.

Unfortunately that's a utopic thought. The US has them, Israel has them, North Korea and Iran may have them... So while i am against the existance or use of these weapons, the honesty tells that if the USA and Israel are allowed to have them, they are in no position whatsoever to tell other countries they cannot have those same weapons. I dislike the regime in Iran and I very much disagree with the dictatorship in North Korea. But in the end, if you're possibly going to be attacked, one thing you cannot blame these regimes for is that they wish to self-defend. I don't trust Kim Jung-il or Ahmedinejad with such weapons, but neither do I trust Netanyahu or Obama with them. In an ideal world, nuclear weapons would not exist. But if they do exist, then one nation being allowed to develop them is in no position to tell another nation they're forbidden to do the same (even if that other nation happens to be Iran or North Korea)



I would like to add another question. Who is the biggest threat with those weapons, assuming that they'd all have them?

Well, let's look at this statistically: North Korea invaded 1 country and has refrained from doing it again the last 60 years. Iran never invaded another country. Israel currently occupies parts of other countries (but OK, this started in a self-defense action), the US has invaded so many other countries for totally void reasons that I've lost track. So pardon me for saying that of all nations especially the US has no right to tell other countries what type of weapons they'd have until the day the US dismantles its own nuclear program.

Oh, and by the way, it's about time the US maybe solves its own problems first and stops interfering with internal affairs of other countries who never asked their opinion in the first place. The games they're playing with South Korea are extremely dangerous as well, North Korea is so sealed off of the outside world that nobody knows what exactly is happening in there. Attacking without knowing what exactly you attack isn't really smart ... Hopefully the US thinks twice before acting, and hopefully the UN can calm them down a bit. Remember Iraq, where we still await for the first proof of mass destruction weapons.

Ideally nukes simply don't exist. Unfortunately they do. If one country can have them, they're in no position to forbid another country to have them. And I'm quite sure if there will be fights (which I hope there won't) it won't be Iran to attack first, because they know they are alone against the world if they'd risk that.
 
1
•••
Kim had said once that he wanted to blow up the US. He's an insane sack of $hit. No, he shouldn't be trusted with nukes.

Unfortunately that's a utopic thought. The US has them, Israel has them, North Korea and Iran may have them... So while i am against the existance or use of these weapons, the honesty tells that if the USA and Israel are allowed to have them, they are in no position whatsoever to tell other countries they cannot have those same weapons. I dislike the regime in Iran and I very much disagree with the dictatorship in North Korea. But in the end, if you're possibly going to be attacked, one thing you cannot blame these regimes for is that they wish to self-defend. I don't trust Kim Jung-il or Ahmedinejad with such weapons, but neither do I trust Netanyahu or Obama with them. In an ideal world, nuclear weapons would not exist. But if they do exist, then one nation being allowed to develop them is in no position to tell another nation they're forbidden to do the same (even if that other nation happens to be Iran or North Korea)

I would like to add another question. Who is the biggest threat with those weapons, assuming that they'd all have them?
 
0
•••
Umm ok .. some may hate me after this but this is how I feel and.. I will say it..

For me.. I dislike bad people .. It does not matter to me if you are black, white, Christian, Catholic etc etc..

If you are a bad hearted person you are a bad hearted person..

I hate how the world has become..

If you believe in something.. Great :tu: But dont expect others to believe it also and please dont kill them, hurt them cos they think different..

If you follow a certain faith.. thats really nice.. but others may also have their faith..

For me .. I have my own happy views on life and I do NOT expect anyone else to share them

Please .. please .. please .. Dont make this a world of fighting because of race, colour, religion..

Make this an earth of .. accepting eachother for what we are.......
 
1
•••
Kim had said once that he wanted to blow up the US. He's an insane sack of $hit. No, he shouldn't be trusted with nukes.

They just talk that mess for bargaining power/foreign aid/negotiation etc. He's not blowing up anybody.
 
0
•••
This had been a world of dystopia since the beginning of time. Wars had been carried out in the name of deities or of man and his endeavors. I'd hope we would see everlasting peace but that idea is nothing more than an illusion. We all can and won't ever see through the same eyes.

Umm ok .. some may hate me after this but this is how I feel and.. I will say it..

For me.. I dislike bad people .. It does not matter to me if you are black, white, Christian, Catholic etc etc..

If you are a bad hearted person you are a bad hearted person..

I hate how the world has become..

If you believe in something.. Great :tu: But dont expect others to believe it also and please dont kill them, hurt them cos they think different..

If you follow a certain faith.. thats really nice.. but others may also have their faith..

For me .. I have my own happy views on life and I do NOT expect anyone else to share them

Please .. please .. please .. Dont make this a world of fighting because of race, colour, religion..

Make this an earth of .. accepting eachother for what we are.......


---------- Post added at 05:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:22 PM ----------

Perhaps but he doesn't seem to be of sound mind. I wouldn't trust him with a nuke. He's already bitched about us and said he wanted to bomb us. We gotta see a threat for what it is.

They just talk that mess for bargaining power/foreign aid/negotiation etc. He's not blowing up anybody.
 
0
•••
Umm ok .. some may hate me after this but this is how I feel and.. I will say it..

For me.. I dislike bad people .. It does not matter to me if you are black, white, Christian, Catholic etc etc..

If you are a bad hearted person you are a bad hearted person..

I hate how the world has become..

If you believe in something.. Great :tu: But dont expect others to believe it also and please dont kill them, hurt them cos they think different..

If you follow a certain faith.. thats really nice.. but others may also have their faith..

For me .. I have my own happy views on life and I do NOT expect anyone else to share them

Please .. please .. please .. Dont make this a world of fighting because of race, colour, religion..

Make this an earth of .. accepting eachother for what we are.......

In a perfect world maybe.. :P How do you judge a bad person from a good person though??

I hear everyone saying that this country and that country shouldn't have nukes or weapons of mass destruction but then whos going to decide who does not get them and who does get them. Idd rather live in a world of "freedom" with this than a world of dictatorship with a group of 12 people deciding everything. Sure we would be living in harmony but there would be no point in life if you cant believe in what you want to believe.

As for a world without weapons, that's really a perfect world, humans have been using weapons since forever and I don't think we will reach a stage in our evolution were we wont need them.

I don't condone in killing anyone but it seems to be other peoples methods, one persons terrorist is another persons freedom fighter.
 
1
•••
Where some ppl see a cold-blooded, heartless killer, others see a hero. It sucks but that's the way this sick world is.

In a perfect world maybe.. :P How do you judge a bad person from a good person though??

I don't condone in killing anyone but it seems to be other peoples methods, one persons terrorist is another persons freedom fighter.
 
0
•••
Where some ppl see a cold-blooded, heartless killer, others see a hero. It sucks but that's the way this sick world is.

Not this sick world, but humans as a species :P
 
0
•••
In a perfect world maybe.. :P How do you judge a bad person from a good person though??

I.
##

If you believe something and wish to blow yourself up then fine.. Just dont take anyone else with you
 
0
•••
Very true but still, it's stupidity and harrowing to some and it'd make you a martyr and the pride of your religion to others. What we view as bad is considered good and vice-versa all throughout the world.

##

If you believe something and wish to blow yourself up then fine.. Just dont take anyone else with you
 
0
•••
I'm not so concerned that Iran will use the nukes as much I see some radical group getting a hold of them. Also I would imagine Iran would extort the rest of the world with threats of nuking someone. I think Iran would sell or give a small nuke or dirty bomb to a terrorist group and we all know they would use the weapon. Also if Iran has a nuke it will cause many other countries to react in various ways no one could predict

As for the Israeli army .... I understand their small forces and ops are among the best. They are not geared for a war of attrition or even prolonged engagement. But I think every citizen serves in the army at some point.

I think they will strike .... I don't know why but I just have a feeling they are going to. I for sure don't want to see Iran with nukes but on the other hand I think as soon as all countries can break their ties and dependencies on oil the planet will be a better place. If you think the great kitty litter box is crazy now just wait until we tell oil producing countries ... heh we don't need your oil any more.

Nuclear energy is clean and virtually limitless but if the entire planet is running nuclear power then we have a whole new monster in the waste or byproducts.

And what about safety and maintenance? Is Iran developed enough to manage nuke tech?

@ Mellow ..... Bad peeps suck! If you hurt others you have no place in my world. >:(

NN
 
1
•••
I don't think Israel would attack or Iran would attack. It's a loose loose situation and both know it well.
 
0
•••
Umm ok .. some may hate me after this but this is how I feel and.. I will say it..

For me.. I dislike bad people .. It does not matter to me if you are black, white, Christian, Catholic etc etc..

If you are a bad hearted person you are a bad hearted person..

I hate how the world has become..

If you believe in something.. Great :tu: But dont expect others to believe it also and please dont kill them, hurt them cos they think different..

If you follow a certain faith.. thats really nice.. but others may also have their faith..

For me .. I have my own happy views on life and I do NOT expect anyone else to share them

Please .. please .. please .. Dont make this a world of fighting because of race, colour, religion..

Make this an earth of .. accepting eachother for what we are.......

MM, i love you for that post!!!

Why do you think someone would hate you for this posting [headshake]

:hearts::gl:
Cheers

Liquid

P.S: a lot of Iranians i know hate actually "ach ma djing didad"...of course they are here in the states, if they wouldn't they would be dead by now(remember just a bit over a year ago?)

So Gerrit, you are basically saying a government what kills their own people in a heartbeat(n.korea, iran) is allowed to have nukes, heck if they don't care about their own people what do you think about them carrying about other countries?? [headshake again]
 
0
•••
All the more reasons why that nut-job Kim shouldn't be allowed to possess nukes.

So Gerrit, you are basically saying a government what kills their own people in a heartbeat(n.korea, iran) is allowed to have nukes, heck if they don't care about their own people what do you think about them carrying about other countries?? [headshake again]
 
1
•••
All the more reasons why that nut-job Kim shouldn't be allowed to possess nukes.

Just repped you for that comment, thx:)

Cheers

Liquid
 
0
•••
Thanks :)

But isn't it true? Saddam killed thousands of HIS OWN PEOPLE, just testing weapons. It's no surprise we didn't find any WMD in Iraq: Saddam used 'em on his own ppl! Imagine the hell the Koreans (and the rest of us) would see if Kim got hold of a nuke.

Just repped you for that comment, thx:)

Cheers

Liquid
 
0
•••
Domain Recover
DomainEasy โ€” Zero Commission
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the pageโ€™s height.
Back