Congrats ...
... to your endeavors to continuosly improve as platform, in the following ...
... my opinion (for your team and those who will be interested in reading it) in regards to the redesign, some points may have been mentioned by others already and some members may view some of these points exactly opposite - however, here is my view ...
namePros
- the website has definitely a more contemporary look now
- visually appealing standard font (and icons)
- the "similar threads" section makes sense
- the dark theme option (which looks very good, not all website who have this option implemented look that great with it) and the posibility to change between light mode / dark mode is great
- the permanent displayment of the first (thread creator's) post is definitely a good idea
- a chat function as a thread (why not - it is just an unusual look (much more space, slowed down) but there is actually no disadvantage in it, rather the opposite)
- although a square avatar space (which looked definitely good) has become already more unique these days in the www, I do indeed prefer the round one (as it fits everywhere on the website but mainly because it symbolizes better the powerful potential of our mind)
- ... much more pros, I just don't have time to list them all (as you may know I also have to count tops)
nameCons
- maybe a bit too less visual difference between the different areas (boxes / elements) across the website, they all look a bit too similiar and this can make it difficult in terms of finding the wanted area at first glance, at least (but I assume not only) for new members
- unnecessary complicated post feedback system, a "LIKE" / "DISLIKE" button, a "AGREE" / "PARTLY AGREE" / "DISAGREE" button and a "LOL"* / "ROFL"* / "ROFLOL"* button (* or appropriate emoji buttons) - would make it way easier to understand and use
- no option to save an indiviual color in the color palette ("text color" box) in the editor
- no option to chose the standard font (the "remove formatting" removes all formatting from a (marked) element - so, for instance, keeping an element's color but only removing its font family (to get the standard font) is not possible - this is why the standard font should be listed in the fonts list to chose)
- 3 separate menus for more options in the editor is not necessary (1 menu / click that displays all remaining / additional editing icons would be simpler)
- only 3 "new posts" in the "new posts" box ... is a bit less - instead of displaying only 3 you should display 9 (yes! nine!) and instead of displaying only 5 "popular this week" posts you should display 7 (then there would be 5 "popular this month" threads / 7 "popular this week" threads / 9 "new posts" threads and 5 / 7 / 9 makes a balanced set)
- too large / prominently placed feedback rating element (circle) in the mobile version
- paying members ("Blue / Gold Account" members) should have the option to post their external sales links in a prominently placed box on the website (while "Gold Acount" members should of course be allowed to post them twice the time as "Blue Account" members are allowed to post them (since they pay twice the amount))
- I would prefer some arrow icon instead of the "click to expand ..." in the first post
- in the member's profile in the "about" tab, the informations like "website" / "location" / "skills" / etc., should be displayed at the top (as it was before the redesign) and not at the bottom (as it is now)
- ... of course, all these points are my personal view and just "luxury problems" in some way - however, if you will implement one / some or maybe even all of them with the time and in accordance to other's view, it would be appreciated
... thanks !