Yeah sorry but your straw man argument is not going to work. No one said for anyone to disclose their financials, and no one was just talking about you. Yes if one is starting threads, that imply "Man I am kicking butt with ***extension, it's unbelievable" Or I am regging a ton of names in an extension or niche but can't provide any other details. There is a lot of room for disinformation, unfounded hype. While one might not be looking to sell their names to those reading, those people especially newbies might start regging a bunch of names based on false or misleading information. They then might pay someone for an appraisal, so while the person did not make a direct sale they might make money indirectly. Does anyone have to list every sale? Heck no, but someone should have a couple sales they can point to that helps to validate their position.