discuss People's opinion on "Top Domains" on NamePros

[simonpan]

There is a "Top Domains" section on Namepros. It supposes to have a minimum resale value of $1000. These domains are submitted by members and some are accepted by Namepros.

Please discuss
What domains on there do people (you) think are truly worth "Top Domains" section and why?
What domains on there do people (you) think are not worth "Top Domains" section and why?

 

[karmaco]

Sounds like you aren’t happy with the mods decisions. I don’t think we should grade others names on a platform that shows up on Google when they haven’t asked us too.

Very few names appear in top section because very few people care about positioning of names on a wholesale forum (it’s trivial imo) and the mods are doing their jobs.

Names put into top section do not automatically sell, no silver bullet as we can clearly see. People who are buying care about the names not the section its listed in.

 

[forge]

Please discuss
What domains on there do people (you) think are truly worth "Top Domains" section and why?
What domains on there do people (you) think are not worth "Top Domains" section and why

@karmaco summed this up very well.

To single out / appraise / criticize names for sale (without the owners' consent) would be unfair at best and (at worst) would likely violate forum rules.

 

[Domain boy]

Sounds like you aren’t happy with the mods decisions. I don’t think we should grade others names on a platform that shows up on Google when they haven’t asked us too.

Very few names appear in top section because very few people care about positioning of names on a wholesale forum (it’s trivial imo) and the mods are doing their jobs.

Names put into top section do not automatically sell, no silver bullet as we can clearly see. People who are buying care about the names not the section its listed in.

You really couldn't have said it better; agree 100%

 

[simonpan]

Sounds like you aren’t happy with the mods decisions. I don’t think we should grade others names on a platform that shows up on Google when they haven’t asked us too.

Very few names appear in top section because very few people care about positioning of names on a wholesale forum (it’s trivial imo) and the mods are doing their jobs.

Names put into top section do not automatically sell, no silver bullet as we can clearly see. People who are buying care about the names not the section its listed in.

Thank you....since you said the top domains section is trivial...Do you suggest we eliminate the section? I think it's quite unfair the top domains section almost allows unlimited bumps compared to other sections