JoeKing - can you post the times of the original bids, redacting the names of the bidders other than you and PoorMan (And Halvarez, if he was in that auction. If Halvarez was not in that auction, that would make me even more suspicious.).
Allan, Halvarez (bless his cotton socks) was not in this auction but here you go... bear in mind I left a proxy bid of $20,000...
Auction End Time: 14-Jan-2007 12:15 PST
Bidder Date Bid Amount Comment
joe king 16-Jan-2007 06:55 PST $20,000.00 Completed
joe king 12-Jan-2007 10:24 PST $20,000.00 Bid Placed
poorman 12-Jan-2007 10:24 PST $19,998.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 18:07 PST $18,749.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 18:07 PST $18,499.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 16:50 PST $18,249.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 16:50 PST $17,999.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 16:50 PST $17,749.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 16:50 PST $17,499.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 16:40 PST $17,249.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 16:40 PST $16,999.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 16:40 PST $16,749.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 16:40 PST $16,499.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 16:39 PST $16,249.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 16:39 PST $15,999.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 16:39 PST $15,749.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 16:39 PST $15,499.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:40 PST $15,249.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:40 PST $14,999.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:40 PST $14,250.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:40 PST $14,000.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:39 PST $13,250.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:39 PST $13,000.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:39 PST $12,450.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:39 PST $12,200.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:15 PST $11,950.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:15 PST $11,700.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:10 PST $10,250.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:10 PST $10,000.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:10 PST $7,995.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:10 PST $7,895.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $6,101.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $6,001.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $5,101.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $5,001.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $4,100.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $4,000.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $2,600.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $2,500.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $1,550.00 Bid Placed
poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:09 PST $1,500.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 11:50 PST $1,050.00 Bid Placed
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:50 PST $1,000.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 11:49 PST $925.00 Bid Placed
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:49 PST $900.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 11:49 PST $825.00 Bid Placed
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:49 PST $800.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 11:48 PST $725.00 Bid Placed
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:48 PST $700.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 11:48 PST $525.00 Bid Placed
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:48 PST $500.00 Bid Placed
joe king 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $330.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $320.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $100.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $100.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $80.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $64.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $61.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $61.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
poorman 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
XXXXX 11-Jan-2007 11:44 PST $60.00 Initial Bid
Essentially a two-horse race from the early stages ensuring the proxy bid was achieved before I could reduce my bid - then nothing for two days...probably booking his Caribbean holiday on those days...
Poorman's last incremental bid could have dangerously short changed Snapnames of $1 - either his maths wasn't so good or he wanted to inject some form of realism.
It all looks perfectly natural to me - who could possibly believe that there would be shill bidding under Snapnames' roof?
Am I being cynical if I say that judging by the size of poorman's incremental bids he looked determined to win the bid at all costs? Surely he wasn't just determined to get to within a whisker away from the 'unknown' proxy bid? Surely not at Snapnames?
With the babyblogs.com auction, poorman seems similarly determined to win with a bold initial bid (
http://www.namepros.com/domain-name-discussion/182874-bayblogs-com-live-auction-at-snapnames.html) but not as overzealous as in the dubaiproperty.com bid - maybe due to a lower proxy bid of$1,000 - not to say he was privy to that sort of information, of course.
Again, am I being cynical or was poorman 'clever' enough to change his bid to end in 999 (poorman 11-Jan-2007 14:40 PST $14,999.00 Bid Placed) early on enough to not look too suspicious but also early on enough to ensure he didn't accidentally win - there's nothing worse than winning an auction you don't intend to win.
Elementary my dear.
Joe,
Did poorman ever contact you in response to your request to Deb? Deb seems to know too much though. :]
Deb never did get back to me despite assuring me that they knew poorman. They also said poorman would contact me - nearly three years later, I am still waiting...