information Explosive claim about .xyz and “Swetha”

[Keith]

From Mike Mann on LinkedIn -

“Swetha is just an alias of Dan Negari. The vast majority of those high end .xyz sales are fake. The reason they appear to sell for BIN is because it is too complex and risky to use Afternic as a proxy to negotiate prices with himself.”

If this is true that would be unreal!

 

[Mkt Sales Leads]

This thread is an embarrassment. NP has become such a cesspool.

It's become Namepros Civil War

 

[Joe drake]

VIVRE you should not dislike ,some cultures are different ,no discrimination here ,please we are all equal

 

[bmugford]

You're missing my point. I'm not interested in (the success of) other sellers, I don't care whether those sales are real or not. What I care about is whether or not .xyz domains are valuable.

You may argue that they are valuable based off Swetha's sales. But that's not necessarily true. It could be that Swetha is just a really good salesman (or saleswoman) getting in contact with the right people and giving them the right sales pitch. It could also be a marketing ploy by Generation to promote their extension. We don't know.

What we do now is that one seller is supposedly making more money off .xyz domains than all other sellers combined, which is not only unusual: it's unique! So some healthy skepticism is warranted.

If you want to invest in .xyz-domains that's fine, but I'd advice doing some thorough digging beforehand.

I have pointed out the uniqueness of the situation in the past.

Just to clarify though -

- I own 0 .XYZ.
- I have no interest in .XYZ.
- I am not a fan of Daniel Negari, for a number of reasons.

I am more than willing to took at actual evidence, but what I have seen is basically just speculation.

Many of the claims involve things like "the domain isn't developed", "she won't video chat with me", etc. Those are not compelling arguments to me.

Brad

 

[kor]

What we do now is that one seller is supposedly making more money off .xyz domains than all other sellers combined, which is not only unusual: it's unique! So some healthy skepticism is warranted.

Maybe it's because "that" seller is holding more than 20,000 premium .xyz domain names compared to rest of the sellers?

 

[MKA]

Maybe it's because "that" seller is holding more than 20,000 premium .xyz domain names compared to rest of the sellers?

No, you're misreading the page. There are 10 domains per page, and there are 22,431 pages. That's 224,301 - 224,310 domains. And this is what's so sketchy, because premium .xyz have higher renewal fees (some upwards $1,000/year). Which means that we're looking at tens of millions in renewal fees.

And again, look at the premium domains that others are selling...

How is marino.xyz over than a hundred times more valuable than sale.xyz? Or qr.xyz?

It doesn't take a genius to figure out that something isn't quite right with all this.

 

[Liberty Wolf]

No, you're misreading the page. There are 10 domains per page, and there are 22,431 pages. That's 224,301 - 224,310 domains. And this is what's so sketchy, because premium .xyz have higher renewal fees (some upwards $1,000/year). Which means that we're looking at tens of millions in renewal fees.

And again, look at the premium domains that others are selling...

Show attachment 239944

How is marino.xyz over than a hundred times more valuable than sale.xyz? Or qr.xyz?

It doesn't take a genius to figure out that something isn't quite right with all this.

One of these is not like the others, ill let you guess.

sale.xyz - $3500 renewal
qr.xyz - $3000 renewal
bp.xyz - $3000 renewal
fears.xyz - $750 renewal
marino.xyz - $15 renewal

 

[MKA]

One of these is not like the others, ill let you guess.

sale.xyz - $3500 renewal
qr.xyz - $3000 renewal
bp.xyz - $3000 renewal
fears.xyz - $750 renewal
marino.xyz - $15 renewal

Fair enough. But if Swetha are balancing the prices against the renewal fees, then why are these domains priced as they are?

 

[nametrekker]

The 500 most visited sites on the web
https://moz.com/top500

I was surprised at the number of .me domains in the top 500. More than 25 extensions in the top 500, but no .xyz sites that I saw,

 

[okaydomains]

So many people are hung up on her domains selling for e.g., $80k. We all understand this is peanuts to a VC backed startup, right?

I don't know Swetha, but it's not hard at all for me to believe a startup would buy a great keyword .xyz for that price range.

I sell xyz domains all the time. Not for big numbers like her sales, but people do buy xyz names.

What a strange conspiracy theory.

 

[bmugford]

Fair enough. But if Swetha are balancing the prices against the renewal fees, then why are these domains priced as they are?

So, a lot of these domains are clearly as good or better than many .XYZ registry "premium" domains.

However, I believe @DNGear said she only deals in domains with standard renewals.

One of these sales would pay for an awful lot of standard renewals.

I looked up the archived WHOIS on these, and many have been in her name for years...well before .XYZ introduced "premium" renewals.

.XYZ introducing "premium" renewal fees would tend to help high quality terms that don't carry them.

Brad

 

[MadAboutDomains]

The 500 most visited sites on the web
https://moz.com/top500

I was surprised at the number of .me domains in the top 500. More than 25 extensions in the top 500, but no .xyz sites that I saw,

Cause nobody's using them and certainly nobody trusts them.

 

[TheRockHopper]

Everyone's mind seems made up. You can't convince the other side.

Let's just close the thread.

 

[Keith]

One of these is not like the others, ill let you guess.

sale.xyz - $3500 renewal
qr.xyz - $3000 renewal
bp.xyz - $3000 renewal
fears.xyz - $750 renewal
marino.xyz - $15 renewal

But wait a minute - what about all the money supposedly raised by the companies using .xyz? If you raise millions, $3500 a year in renewal fees is peanuts.

So in theory, the renewals wouldn’t be a hindrance to these startups.

I’d much rather own Sale or any 2L vs Marino…

 

[tonyk2000]

For the record, "XYZ.COM LLC" also operates the following:

.audio
.auto
.autos
.baby
.beauty
.boats
.car
.cars
.christmas
.college
.diet
.flowers
.game
.guitars
.hair
.homes
.hosting
.lat
.lol
.makeup
.mom
.monster
.motorcycles
.pics
.protection
.quest
.rent
.security
.skin
.storage
.theatre
.tickets
.yachts

Source: https://www.iana.org/domains/root/db

So, folks who appreciate their marketing efforts might want to consider investing in the above TLDs as well. And those who don't might want to avoid all the above TLDs together. Just imho.

In any case, Mike Mann is one of the industry pioneers (~30 years around), so he has a lot of experience and intuition.

P.S. extra ref.: The Dunning–Kruger effect

 

[hotcoffee]

Hey Astner, I do get what you are saying and understand your suspicions.... I am not trying to argue, just sharing my opinion.

Maybe I am wrong, but I am choosing to be optimistic and believe that Swetha is for real and making the sales. She is doing something right that is helping her make the sales....

and like I said.... maybe Swetha is connected to people who know people and get intros to those in need of domain names.

I am making assumptions about her way of doing business... and what may be the *thing* that gives her an edge, to get that sale.

Maybe, she is studying the markets, business, financial, startup sectors, trade venues.... etc. Swetha may be finding niches, startups, and people that are getting ready to do something....

Somehow, she is finding opportunities where she can sell her domains. Much like a reporter who gets the scoop before someone else does....

 

[HotKey]

It is clear some minds were made up long before xyz started selling. At its core, this is not about healthy skepticism.

 

[otismo]

Time to Think Outside the Blocks, Gentlemen...

This thread was a most interesting read -

Thank You All !

You have been distracted by XYZ

I follow Lottery.com ticker symbol LTRY

The company owns lottery.com AND sports.com

( for which they paid six million - if you believe... )

Their share price CRASHED to eight cents a share

they have fifty million shares issued and outstanding

so this gives them a market cap of Four Million

Deflation has arrived, and the Dot Com Bubble

has only just begun to burst - so I am OUT, Gentlemen !

Cheers !

 

[MadAboutDomains]

Time to Think Outside the Blocks, Gentlemen...

Show attachment 240099
This thread was a most interesting read -

Thank You All !

You have been distracted by XYZ

I follow Lottery.com ticker symbol LTRY

The company owns lottery.com AND sports.com

( for which they paid six million - if you believe... )

Their share price CRASHED to eight cents a share

they have fifty million shares issued and outstanding

so this gives them a market cap of Four Million

Deflation has arrived, and the Dot Com Bubble

has only just begun to burst - so I am OUT, Gentlemen !

Cheers !

The dot com bubble has started to burst? Lol

 

[yb1313]

I think Mike Mann's claim is true, based on my domaining knowledge/intuition from time in this business, and thanks to being able to think outside the box.
First and foremost, the circumstantial evidence highly suggests many of swetha's .xyz sales are fake: too many sites are undeveloped, exorbitant successful buy-now sales, and other patterns. Secondly, mr. Mann is an industry veteran who knows what he's talking about, partly because (IMHO and others' opinion too) - he too inflates his sales figures and knows well how this stuff works (oh, the irony. But that's a subject of its own) - and of course neither "swetha" nor mr. Negari came forward to disprove this (unfortunately it appears to be too big of a hole to turn back from now, but let's hope there's still a fair way).

The importance of this information is high, because many domainers rely on reported sale data in their purchasing and renewals of xyz and other domains. Thus, the domaining community should be thankful for such discussions and always look into these things. It's serious stuff.
Therefore, domainers wishing to end this thread in any way are not only doing injustice to free speech, but to themselves too. Are you too emotionally and/or financially invested in that extension to want to beleive otherwise?

 

[Mkt Sales Leads]

I think Mike Mann's claim is true, based on my domaining knowledge/intuition from time in this business, and thanks to being able to think outside the box.
First and foremost, the circumstantial evidence highly suggests many of swetha's .xyz sales are fake: too many sites are undeveloped, exorbitant successful buy-now sales, and other patterns. Secondly, mr. Mann is an industry veteran who knows what he's talking about, partly because (IMHO and others' opinion too) - he too inflates his sales figures and knows well how this stuff works (oh, the irony. But that's a subject of its own) - and of course neither "swetha" nor mr. Negari came forward to disprove this (unfortunately it appears to be too big of a hole to turn back from now, but let's hope there's still a fair way).

The importance of this information is high, because many domainers rely on reported sale data in their purchasing and renewals of xyz and other domains. Thus, the domaining community should be thankful for such discussions and always look into these things. It's serious stuff.
Therefore, domainers wishing to end this thread in any way are not only doing injustice to free speech, but to themselves too. Are you too emotionally and/or financially invested in that extension to want to beleive otherwise?

What happens if she starts selling her dictionary word .Pro names (check her site)?
Will that raise suspicions and accusations of collusion against the registry that owns the .pro extention?

Or will it be all ok, so long as she sells her .pros no higher than the 7-9k range (as they're currently priced)?

You could use the same 'it smells fishy' argument for anyone selling large volumes of names for big numbers, ranging from .com to .ai, to .top