NameSilo

Afternic - Official Thread

SpaceshipSpaceship
Watch

GoDaddy

Top Member
🥇 Best Registrar (2016-2018)
:heavy_check_mark: GoDaddy Staff
Impact
1,267
Hello NamePros!
By popular demand, we have launched a dedicated feedback thread for Afternic, the GoDaddy-owned domain name marketplace.

We have created this thread as a way for you to tell us what works, what doesn't work, and what features you'd like to see at Afternic (please be constructive with your feedback). We're looking forward to hearing from the domain investment community to help us shape the future of Afternic.

We will also be sharing Afternic product updates in this thread.

Please note that this thread is not meant for support. Please email our support team at [email protected] for assistance.
 
16
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
GoDaddyGoDaddy
Got an offer on a domain since yesterday
The lead broker has yet to reach back to the buyer

I can beat that.

I got an offer on the weekend that I responded to in minutes.. and the price has still not been forwarded to the buyer.

This is my major gripe with Afternic - I've potentially got a live buyer with a 4-figure initial offer, and GD is doing everything possible NOT to sell my domain.

Please Lord, deliver unto me an Afternic seller brokerage tool, so that I may get back to making money!!
 
3
•••
1
•••
I can beat that.

I got an offer on the weekend that I responded to in minutes.. and the price has still not been forwarded to the buyer.

This is my major gripe with Afternic - I've potentially got a live buyer with a 4-figure initial offer, and GD is doing everything possible NOT to sell my domain.

Please Lord, deliver unto me an Afternic seller brokerage tool, so that I may get back to making money!!
At least yours has seen the offer
Mine has yet to see it since yesterday , and ask me for a floor price.
Their chat support told me that sales team has a different timing and he can do nothing.
I think that, instead of trying new features , godaddy should fix what they have first.
 
Last edited:
4
•••
7
•••
At least yours has seen the offer

Personally, I don't think either of us is doing too well.

At Afternic, we're both competing in the Special Olympics of Domaining.
 
3
•••
The company doesn't care

I think it's more that as time goes by large companies like this tend to get very top-heavy, and GD executives and middle-management can't code updates or broker domains.
 
1
•••
At least domains recently sold through Afternic are promptly removed from @GoDaddy auctions and the front of site.

Oh wait, they're not!
 
0
•••
I think it's more that as time goes by large companies like this tend to get very top-heavy, and GD executives and middle-management can't code updates or broker domains.
There is an executive class that only cares about margins, and profits, then there is department leaders who have a better understanding of what is going on logistically, and with clients, but they can't seem to get the higher ups to see their side of it, as they are purely focused on profits, and given the price they have paid to buy out the competition they feel they have earned the right to steamroll domainers. This is exactly how domainers feel today, not sure the poor afternic namepros support person has really any say in feedback, but as more sellers feel their needs are being ignored, they will find other options, it always happens, hopefully there is a stand out executive that can get ahead of this situation.
 
0
•••
Have you been able to fix the extreme delay yet? How long will it take for GoDaddy to fix such issues?
Hi @Future Sensors
We're making progress and it's getting quicker. There are several teams working on various stages of the checkout process from the lander to the cart. But - of course, there's still work to do, and we're continuing to tick off items to reduce the load time.

Might be a good idea to have domain owners opt in , opt out like boost. You are simply giving confused inquires more reason to low ball your domain offers if they have no traffic stats. This is a very dangerous game that is being played, and godaddy never even asked the domain holders about this. Even domain appraisals on unpriced domains is a dangerous game, but we keep going deeper down this rabbit hole, it's time domain owners are given some rights on what they choose to share in regards to their domains.
Hi @wwwweb
Experimentation is (or should be) a big part of any company. It's how progress is made, especially in ecommerce. We've tested a lot across GoDaddy, and many of those tests influence what you see today. Like this, which Paul shared at NamesCon in 2022.

"Nicks also provided examples of how the company is testing landing page designs. Based on feedback from the Dan.com team, which GoDaddy acquired this year, the company made a change to the colors of a buy now lander. In testing, this resulted in a whopping 43.5% increase in the number of people clicking the Buy Now button on the domains."

I find it hard to believe showing traffic data of 0 or low number of visits for undeveloped names helps sell them better. Will @GoDaddy keep testing if this is actually holds true over a longer period of time or have they already made the decision to keep showing this traffic data long term? Did they test whether it helped increase sales across all price points or was it different among lower or higher priced domains? Was there any difference in conversion rate increases for domains showing high visits opposed to those with low visits?

In my opinion even with large sample size it is hard to reliably test for these and come to a firm conclusion when it comes to domain sales especially if the experiment was only run for 1 month.
Hi @Janoss
You're right to be surprised, but our testing showed a significant increase in conversion rates vs hiding "zero" values. This was a month-long test across GoDaddy search, and provided statistically significant results.


@GoDaddy

1. I don't have much faith in Godaddy's ability to do proper scientific a/b tests, or anything scientific for that matter. Look at boost and all that claimed up to 10% increase. There is no way it can add anything given the search results offered and even boosted names not showing. I tested it for couple of days and it wouldn't show, e.g., Myrtles.com when searching for singular Myrtle. And for other cases, the boosted names were something like 30th-50th in the list with lots of bs before that.

2. GD should ban its developers from working on "new" features and ways to increase sales until they take care of basics, like shopping cart loading under 10 sec, bugs and issues getting reported automatically to QA/QC team and getting resolved within hours and lots of other things reported in this thread and GD thread.

3. The traffic, backlink etc. info can be confusing and can hurt the sales. At least, people should be able to opt out. Also, what if you don't have the lander of a name? So you will put just zero for a name that has great traffic? It seems just like another tactic to force people to use Afternic landers. You've got good traffic name, but it is pointing elsewhere? Tough. We will just tell buyers it doesn't have any traffic.
Hi @Recons.Com
We have a team of dedicated analysts that help us run true statistically significant experiments across the whole of GoDaddy. Like many other companies, including many in the domain industry, we test to increase conversion rates to directly help domain name sellers.

Displaying "zero" values proved to be the winner here. But, I understand your perspective and skepticism. Increasing our transparency around experimentation will hopefully help there.

@GoDaddy, @Paul Nicks, @Joe Styler

The community has spoken: many of us don’t want the “insights” feature.

If doing away with it entirely isn’t feasible, how about these suggestions:

1.) As others have mentioned above, allow sellers to opt in or out of the insights feature. This gives flexibility to those who value the insights and those who don't want them shown.

2.) Display insights only when the metrics are favorable, similar to how domain value estimates appear when the BIN price is below GoDaddy’s estimated value. This approach positions insights solely as a selling point (RTB) to encourage purchases, rather than a potential deterrent or dissuading factor that could diminish the perceived value of a domain in buyers’ minds.

Implementing either—or both—would be a win-win for everyone involved.
Thanks for your feedback, @Vivere. Experimentation at GoDaddy is nothing new. Plenty of previous experiments have positively contributed to what you see across GoDaddy today. The ultimate goal of experiments like this is to increase the conversion rate of your domain names, helping you to sell more.

At least domains recently sold through Afternic are promptly removed from @GoDaddy auctions and the front of site.

Oh wait, they're not!
Hi @411domains, please provide an example via DM where you see this scenario happening, and we'll happily look into it.
 
0
•••
Where’s the traffic data from?

Checked my names that have traffic and it says 0 visitors on the reg path data.
 
4
•••
1
•••
"Nicks also provided examples of how the company is testing landing page designs. Based on feedback from the Dan.com team, which GoDaddy acquired this year, the company made a change to the colors of a buy now lander. In testing, this resulted in a whopping 43.5% increase in the number of people clicking the Buy Now button on the domains."


I have run hundreds of A/B & MVT for companies like Dell & eBay in the past.

If a change in color leads to 43% increase in buy now clicks, you're doing something wrong in your analysis. Or your test analysts are fooling you guys with numbers. Won't comment further on this.
 
10
•••
I have run hundreds of A/B & MVT for companies like Dell & eBay in the past.

If a change in color leads to 43% increase in buy now clicks, you're doing something wrong in your analysis. Or your test analysts are fooling you guys with numbers. Won't comment further on this.

I also worked at a direct marketing company who ran multivariate and A/B split testing. You can see significant increases for little changes such as button color. Although I will agree when you see increases of the size mentioned, retesting is required and it usually happens at the very early stages of building the form (meaning the form was complete crap prior).
 
2
•••
Hello!
I sold the domain via Afternic's Fast Transfer network on October 24! That's over a month ago!
Transaction status is "Transfer Complete"
I still haven't received the payment!
I wrote a letter to the support service 2 weeks ago and no one answers me, as there is no answer to the correspondence in the topic about selling this domain on the Afternic website.

This is a very bad service. I hope you will solve the problem as soon as possible, because this is not my first sale and usually the payment was fast.
But now there has been no payment for over a month and no one answers my messages!
Who should I discuss this issue with to get the payment fast?
Thank you!
 
7
•••
Hi @411domains, please provide an example via DM where you see this scenario happening, and we'll happily look into it.

@GoDaddy, I'm sorry, but Godaddy/Afternic has teams of "experts" on the payroll and I am not one of them.

You have access to all the same publicly reported data that we do and more.

I realize this may sound exhausting, but I think you or someone on the team can do a few simple searches and gather your own examples.
 
4
•••
The product is not ready !!! They are still testing !!

1732673246968.png


.
 
Last edited:
0
•••
At least domains recently sold through Afternic are promptly removed from @GoDaddy auctions and the front of site.

Oh wait, they're not!
@GoDaddy @Afternic This is very important, the domain name I auctioned or acquired cannot be listed on Afternic, which is really bad!
 
0
•••
Hello!
I sold the domain via Afternic's Fast Transfer network on October 24! That's over a month ago!
Transaction status is "Transfer Complete"
I still haven't received the payment!
I wrote a letter to the support service 2 weeks ago and no one answers me, as there is no answer to the correspondence in the topic about selling this domain on the Afternic website.

This is a very bad service. I hope you will solve the problem as soon as possible, because this is not my first sale and usually the payment was fast.
But now there has been no payment for over a month and no one answers my messages!
Who should I discuss this issue with to get the payment fast?
Thank you!
You can choose online communication on the service interface, which usually makes it a little faster. The objective chaos seems to be getting better
 
0
•••
1
•••
The company doesn't care

Yeah, sure seems that way.

Their response was essentially an emphatic NO, wrapped in corporate-speak.

It just sucks because many of us still rely on Afternic/GoDaddy. We can't afford to ignore the issues or stay silent, even when it seems futile. We need Afternic/GoDaddy to work.
 
0
•••
Dynadot — .com TransferDynadot — .com Transfer
CatchedCatched

We're social

Escrow.com
Spaceship
Rexus Domain
CryptoExchange.com
Domain Recover
CatchDoms
DomainEasy — Live Options
DomDB
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back