I am not questioning the staggering ROI for many domain name sales. (Market growth/appreciation is another issue.) Even a $500 sale of a domain that had an investment outlay of ,say, $21 in reg and renewal fees over the past 3 yrs is a whopping profit. In that context, I am fine w/ his pronouncement. On the other hand, the statement could be misleading because it trains it's sights on the shining successes that are enjoyed by a limited % of domain name marketers who are dipping into a pool containing a limited number of names. Their success does not equate or, necessarily, transfer over to the vast majority of domainers and it does not apply to the vast majority of domain names which represent a negative return on investment. I equate my chances of having a windfall profit that is "unfathomable" in scope with doubling up between rolls on a craps table during my 20 roll streak and, than, landing on the number. The potential for riches is, indeed, unfathomable but the odds hitting a $5,000,000 pay day are, also unfathomable without spending 5,000,000 or more to get there. They are as slim as the odds of me spending $1,000,000 for a domain and, than, being able to sit on it for 5 years or, for however long, it would take me to sell the domain for $6,000,000 to realizel a $5,000,000 ROI.
I am not disputing that "thar is gold in them thar hills." I am cautioning that "all that glitters is *not* gold."
Sitting down and eating dinner at the same table that the Rockefellers are dining at, does not make you a Rockefeller. You can imagine yourself to have the success of a Rick Schwatz and ,even, sit at his banquet table during a a convention. This, however, does not mean that you are going to enjoy the same level of success or see the same ROI that Rick Schwarz has enjoyed- the level of success that he, no doubt, is referenceing in his comment.
That being said, move over and hand me the dice. I will continue playing the "yoleven" but will place most of my bets on the 6's and 8's. Lower payouts, better odds and realistic expectations.