offers Is this a good offer?

[dakine1]

received an offer today for refillr dot com from a pretty large company. They used the godaddy apprasial of 1,645. What do you guys think? Was going to counter at 2k but think it might be worth more.....

 

[creataweb]

If the offer was made thru GD then I would definitely counter higher.

 

[NonHipster]

It seems like your domain name is worth much more than the appraisal.

 

[dakine1]

If the offer was made thru GD then I would definitely counter higher.

the offer was made direct to me via email

 

[creataweb]

the offer was made direct to me via email

I'd counter anyway unless you desperately need the money now and don't want to hold the name for years.

 

[Bob Hawkes]

I suspect if they offered that they are willing to go higher since they sought you out. I would probably counter higher but not hugely higher. I note that the .org and .io are both available for hand registration, so should they be the kind of organization either of those would fit then that might be relevant, or not.

I have not carefully analyzed sales with one letter different than a common word. I expect the brandable marketplaces have sold many but they do not disclose individual sales.

Depending on how ideal you think the name is as a fit to them I would probably counter $2400 to $4000.

But I am not expert on this!

Bob

 

[NickB]

If they are a "fairly large" company what do they want this name for?

If it for a new brand/product, an ad campaign etc Then you can ask for a fair bit more

Do some research into them and counter accordingly - if any of the above counter 10k + (as long as their revenue justifies it) otherwise if you need the money or you feel it is maybe for their own brand protection counter circa 3k

just my opinion

 

[Bannen]

First, tell them that automated appraisals are meaningless. Each uses a one-size-fits-all group of metrics, which don't make sense especially for brandable names like this, names that have missing or added letters. And also tell them that each auto appraisal service makes up its own metrics, so each one gives a different valuation (Estibot says 'less than $100' for this one). Tell them to throw out the meaningless auto appraisals, and 'then we can start with what this domain is worth, to both the seller and the buyer'.

I receive offers that commonly quote automated appraisals and I always lead in with the above info.

Good luck

Hey, you've been a member since 2013, and only have two posts, both today; can't anybody shut you up?

 

[Bob Hawkes]

I respect the view of @Bannen (he is a 10 star member - wow - so must do lots right!) but if you follow that route I would be very careful in your communication to not come off as condescending or talking down to them. The company probably realizes the limitations of robotic worth estimates, but they decided it was a starting point for negotiations.

I would simply say something like "Automated estimates of worth have limited precision in some cases and I feel that a broad look at measures suggests a higher worth for this name." I would not trot out more but be prepared if you get into a negotiation with comparable sales that sold for much more than GD valuation.

I suspect that Paul Nicks NamesCon message that 90% of time sales are within $2000 of the GD GoValue will have found an audience broader than just the domain community.

I am not surprised that Estibot has <100 - any misspelled brandable I find they have very low unless it is really short or made up of two common words.

Bob

 

[Windoms]

If nothing works then know that $1600 is a good price for this name.

 

[Ategy]

In my opinion this domain isn't even worth anything close to what they are offering .. so congrats on the interest and potential sale!

However .. there are HUGE holding costs for portfolios filled with such names that likely get far fewer offers and sales than typical real language domains, so don't feel bad asking for more than it's actually worth.

If you know they are a big company then they likely aren't going to leave negotiations for a bit more. In fact .. if indeed a big company then they've already likely applied far more than $1645 in terms of time just to decide on that name.

If they really are a big company I wouldn't think it wrong to counter $3-5k .. possibly more depending on how sure you are they need it. But always remember that there is a small risk of losing the sale.

Also check to see if they own a trademark on it ... that being said, as long as you aren't advertising or using it in the same way you are likely safe (although it is unique enough to possibly get a bad decision by a bad UDRP panellist) .. I wouldn't risk going too much higher than 3-4k in that case.

Good luck with it!

 

[Kate]

Domain registered since 2013. Assuming you are the original registrant, how many offers/inquiries have you got so far ? Could be a long time until you receive a better offer, if any. Which does not mean the other party is not prepared to go higher but it's easy to scare buyers away. Also, their initial excitement can wane pretty fast when they get a significantly higher counter-offer. Then they give up or look for something else.
I don't think there is a big gap between 1645 and 2000, especially after commission fees.
Generally speaking, there is little demand for 'skewed words'.

 

[E-Thunder]

I’d counter $2,999 but would sell even if they won’t come up from the $1,600.

 

[Bob Hawkes]

Actually I had a better look at broadly comparables which seem to suggest to me that this is a very good offer for your name. I would try to close it quickly at this price or very little above it (I know this is somewhat different from my earlier advice, but when I saw that the name refiller directly sold for less than this ($861), admittedly a few years ago (2013) leads me to believe this is a fine offer - seal it before they change their mind would be my advice).
Bob

 

[Satyajit Adhikary]

Give them a few examples of past similar sales and counter.

 

[1Darko]

I’d counter $2,999 but would sell even if they won’t come up from the $1,600.

Always counter!

 

[ak4586]

Definitely, you should counter higher we all know that Godaddy appraisal is meaningless.

 

[Dandelion]

Counter the offer. But have in mind your domain doesn't worth anything close to what they offered you. Or it may actually worth much more in their eyes and that's what matters.

 

[frank-germany]

I would prize it at $4.888 USD

 

[karmaco]

I would counter— always counter. My guess is Refiller listed on Uniregistry for sale was pursued first and the price was too high. I think you would be wise to ask for more but not too much more. $2K to $5K. Refill is pharma and that person selling refiller is not selling it cheap.