I have read this thread with great interest and have tried to apply what I have learned to my own sales.
Yesterday, I tried to pitch the domain AffordableSchoolUniforms[.]com to end users in that industry. I made sure to send emails to owners of active websites, not to other domainers or owners of parked domains. I know that AffordableSchoolUniforms[.]com is not a premium domain, but I was pitching it to owners of domains such as girls-school-uniforms[.]info, halfpriceschooluniforms[.]com, etc. My domain is a definite upgrade over those names.
My asking price was $300, but I also made it clear that I was willing to negotiate. I must have emailed 100 owners, and as of this posting, NOT ONE REPLY! I don't know what I am doing wrong. Was the price too high? Was my letter too long? Did the email go to the recipient's spam folder? I don't know.
If someone would be so kind as to help point me in the right direction, I would be most appreciative.
Also, I am willing to pay a commission to someone willing to pitch my domains to end users. I am looking for someone who had multiple successful sales to end users in the past. Please PM me if interested.
Thanks for your time.