James Rodman
Established Member
- Impact
- 163
EDIT POST: not sure who the scammer is. looks like NS might be
Last edited:
Completely forgot that was our transaction!true i even offered this to you forge for that deal we made recently lol. But forge called the registrar and he was able to push afterwards
Completely forgot that was our transaction!
You had great patience while I sorted out our "problem" and you are a trusted member in my book.
Although the issue seems to be resolved on surface, I would still request from the second party (Chetan) to poke Network Solutions and not let them get away this easily. If there was a chargeback, they should clearly mention it. What they are mentioning, is no chargeback but just that the domain was never renewed. In this case just a simple question: "How the hell domain got pushed to another netsol account(s) if it was expired as netsol doesn't allow the push of any domain even after just 1 day of expiry?"
Chetan, you should either call them as they suggested. If you can't call, re-open the support ticket and demand them they clarify this issue via the support ticket itself as you are unable to make a call.
With link to this thread of course so their bottom moves.Although the issue seems to be resolved on surface, I would still request from the second party (Chetan) to poke Network Solutions and not let them get away this easily. If there was a chargeback, they should clearly mention it. What they are mentioning, is no chargeback but just that the domain was never renewed. In this case just a simple question: "How the hell domain got pushed to another netsol account(s) if it was expired as netsol doesn't allow the push of any domain even after just 1 day of expiry?"
Chetan, you should either call them as they suggested. If you can't call, re-open the support ticket and demand them they clarify this issue via the support ticket itself as you are unable to make a call.
I've learn 2 things in 2013.
1.Stay away from NetworkSolutions (even for free and cheap domains!)
2.Stay away from 1and1 (even for free and cheap hosting and domains!)
Total loss of $250
But you can find worst stories on google
I think its time to give chetan his refund.
Well, do we have the FULL STORY?
You seem to keep withholding pieces of information that keep slowly coming out.
Chetan's beef is with you. I think he should get his money back.
Your beef is with the seller on Flippa. You should be after Flippa to get the information of the person they dispersed the money to and get them to do whatever they can in their power to recover the money.
Unless there is more to this story?
I think its time to give chetan his refund.
I don't think you have intentionally set out to scam, but I'd say that there is a good chance that chetan doesn't have his domain as a result of your actions, and that he doesn't have what he paid for.
Do you think you should be $1000+ in profit from this transaction?
Do you still have access to this account? Because you see that link right there in the email? The one where the original account holder can claim the account right back?
How do you know that the login details were from an account which was owned by that seller? They could have been obtain from phishing or keylogging.
I'm sure I'm not the only domainer who has just read that chat transcript and observed the fact that you are happy to be sitting on $1000+ of chetan's money and decided that they'd simply never, ever, do business with you.
Do I think you are a scammer? No, a liability perhaps.
Do I think you should have $1000+ of chetan's money in your paypal account? No, I don't.
I think you should at the bare minimum have offered him the profit back as a starting point (sale price minus $440, until you resolve with flippa if possible).
yes i have emailed them with what Kevin said. waiting for reply still. yes i agree his ban is a red flag which might indicate he was the problem in this in which case i will refund chetan his money and take the loss on my side
refund issued to chetan. Now hopefully the scammer "Jack" is discovered and gets banned from every auction platform so noone has to go through him. and also move out all your domains from NetworkSolutions is my advice as you see what can happen.
Also apologies to Chetan for calling him the scammer and hopefully he can do the same as im not a scammer either and we can find the real culprit in this one which looks like "Jack"
i will make sure that Net Sol does not run away with it so easily.Although the issue seems to be resolved on surface, I would still request from the second party (Chetan) to poke Network Solutions and not let them get away this easily. If there was a chargeback, they should clearly mention it. What they are mentioning, is no chargeback but just that the domain was never renewed. In this case just a simple question: "How the hell domain got pushed to another netsol account(s) if it was expired as netsol doesn't allow the push of any domain even after just 1 day of expiry?"
Chetan, you should either call them as they suggested. If you can't call, re-open the support ticket and demand them they clarify this issue via the support ticket itself as you are unable to make a call.
Nice to see a happy ending. Congrats to both of you for seeing it through!
not really a happy ending for me but im glad chetan is happy.....
Has Flippa shined any light on the seller yet? What about the mods on namepros regarding that user account?
2015-01-28: Last WHOIS update before 2015 expiration date; owner is Long Island Online Services, Inc
2015-07-21: Domain expired with registrar (NETWORK SOLUTIONS, LLC; IANA ID 2)
2015-08-25: Dropcatchers were reporting that Lio.net had expired and was pending drop the same day
2015-08-25: Lio.net dropped; picked up by NameJet
2015-08-29: Lio.net picked up and sold by NameJet for $1,800, allegedly to New Ventures LLC
2015-09-02: Lio.net parked with Sedo
The domain was not renewed in July. Part of NameJet's deal with Network Solutions is that they agree to back-pay the renewal costs. The domain was renewed on 8/25 by NameJet.
Without taking into account either of the stories written here, the history of these domain seems pretty clear: an end-user owned it, it expired, NameJet got it, high bidder was New Ventures LLC. I don't see how anyone else mentioned--James or chetan--ever had their hands on this domain in this timeframe.
I'm not going to read all 15 pages of speculation, but I noticed mention of Flippa while skimming through. It looks like this auction probably took place shortly after New Ventures LLC acquired the domain. It's a possibility that Danny ort = New Ventures LLC--of course, someone probably already pointed this out. At first, this leads me to believe that chetan bought the domain from Danny ort privately, resulting in the auction being cancelled shortly after its creation. But this doesn't quite make sense: if I understand correctly, chetan bought it for $440, but New Ventures LLC bought it only days prior for $1,800. That math doesn't quite add up. Nevertheless, we'll ignore that for now, because...
2015-09-11: (+/- 2 days) Nameservers for Lio.net now point to ns1/ns2.cyanhost.com. WHOIS for cyanhost.com has Chetan's name.
So, without doubt, by 2015-09-11, Chetan was the rightful owner of the domain.
Then we have this curious event:
2015-09-15: (+/- 2 days) Nameservers for Lio.net now point to ns2626/ns1626.ztomy.com
ztomy's server hosts a malware distribution site. So, here's how it works:
- You go to one of ztomy's websites
- You get a virus
- ztomy gets your usernames, passwords, credit cards, and (evil laugh) domains.
@chetan9693, @James Rodman, one of you got hacked. If that domain ever made it into your account, James, it was you. Otherwise, it was Chetan.
My secret sources lead me to believe that James was the unfortunate victim. That's not definitive, though.
tl;dr: One of you needs to change your passwords. Probably both of you just to be safe.
To everyone else who reads this and feels the need to investigate ZTOMY: Don't. You'll end up in the same mess.
New Ventures LLC is a division of Network Solutions, btw. You can look up their 570 number it resolves to several Network Solutions departments.
I think this is the whois they use when sending domains to auction at Namejet (please someone correct me if I'm wrong).
I'm not going to read all 15 pages of speculation, but I noticed mention of Flippa while skimming through. It looks like this auction probably took place shortly after New Ventures LLC acquired the domain. It's a possibility that Danny ort = New Ventures LLC--of course, someone probably already pointed this out. At first, this leads me to believe that chetan bought the domain from Danny ort privately, resulting in the auction being cancelled shortly after its creation. But this doesn't quite make sense: if I understand correctly, chetan bought it for $440, but New Ventures LLC bought it only days prior for $1,800. That math doesn't quite add up. Nevertheless, we'll ignore that for now, because...
Makes sense. I'll update the post; thanks.
wowww. i think chetan got hacked by ztomy then or i understood it wrong. just to clear up i was the one who bought this on flippa (i m not ventures llc or whoever they are) for 440 and chetan bought from me on here as private deal for 1000 and yesterday it was gone from his account. so were we all wrong that thisguy named "Jack" wasnt the scammer?
Bah, I can't keep track of who did what. Point is, somebody who doesn't care about your security/privacy/sanity now has the domain.
chetan had the domain in his account last and it was gone yesterday. so he was hacked?
Maybe, maybe not. Hard to say which one of you for sure. You should both change your passwords, just to be safe--though that won't fix the problem if you still have malware. (Or maybe it was just a successful phishing attack; could've been a million things.) This ztomy guy has the domain now, and I doubt he's going to be interested in parting ways with it. Of course, if Network Solutions and Public Domain Registry both cooperate, you may be able to get it back, but that's always a matter of luck. Whoever had the domain last would have to contact them about that. (Chetan, in this case?)
Or ztomy could be Chetan's. Or yours. Who knows
Registration Service Provided By: SKENZO FZE