What would you do with a domain thats not yours?

[lpstong]

Ok, So if you saw in the free resource area here at namepros, free domain giveaway. You were one of the lucky ones and got a domain. But the OP not only sent your domain but another one as well. The OP realized what they did and sent you a pm requesting the domain back. You replied back saying your internet is slow and will send back asap. The OP waits 24 hours for the push. In the mean time during the 24 hours you have posted several times and have conducted business as well at NP. The OP sends you a pm again, yet you do not reply or push the domain.


Would you do the honorable thing and push the domain back? Or to continue to ignore the OP's request of sending the domain back that originally is not yours.

Or would you say the OP should be more careful and oh well. The OP should be more careful next time and the domain is rightfully the user who got 2 domains instead of one.

 

[Achaias]

Man this sounds too real to be hypothetical hehe. I'd push it back, no need in ruining your name when thats one of the most important things in business.

 

[hanz]

Well, OP should be more careful, but I would push it back. It might be on my account, but that doesn't mean it is mine.

 

[Peter]

Certainly I would contact the person and send it back. The op made an innocent mistake in sending the domain. You have no proper right to the domain other than it being in your account due to an accident.

 

[ApeXX]

I would send it back immediately. Knowing very well that the domain was sent accidentally and not sending it back is immoral, unethical, and also stealing.

 

[lpstong]

Man this sounds too real to be hypothetical hehe.

Yup hypothetical or not. Yeah I was the giver.....

Well, OP should be more careful, but I would push it back. It might be on my account, but that doesn't mean it is mine.

Agreed and my point of view

Knowing very well that the domain was sent accidentally and not sending it back is immoral, unethical, and also stealing.

Agreed as well.

I feel I made an innocent mistake and that I need to be more careful. As well as the person who got the 2 domains needs to be honorable and honest and send the domain back.

Just would like to hear more from others and what they think...

I guess in a way I am just venting for the most part.

 

[dgridley]

Definitely send it back.. otherwise, as others have pointed out, it's tantamount to stealing if you keep the domain.

 

[Smiler]

I will give it back.

 

[Achaias]

I have a sinking suspiscion of what might have happened.[/sarcasm]

 

[BoutiqueMusic]

Is this a test? Of course you would send it back. It's the right thing to do.

Also, I would have pushed it back right away.

 

[Peter]

I have a sinking suspiscion of what might have happened.[/sarcasm]

Lol looking at Smiler's response I think I agree.

 

[zand_stein]

This sounds too real,....
but definetely I wont do anything on that .....
in the first place I already knew that its not mine so why sould I do anything with its....