Please explain what makes a failure. I'd agree more with you if the registrants were declining., but this extension is slowly growing its registrant body each month.
Yes you are right. Slowly. That's the problem.
To begin with, there is hardly any extension that is not growing. The 'popular' extensions are growing at a much faster pace, so the gap is widening. The result is that .pro is not catching up, it's becoming more marginal every day. Honestly, do you think the .pro TLD is significantly more famous or established than it was 10 years ago. Let me put it bluntly, it is sinking
The .pro stats are also warped by the fact that half of the registrations are in the hand of a single entity. I don't know of any other such example in another extension. It's not that important actually, 50K or 100K is still a very low number.
I'm going to agree with webdomain here, among all the gTLDs that are not 'mainstream' yet, I think .PRO has the best chance of growth.
Give me one reason, because the 10 past years have not been encouraging at all and it's not like anything has changed in the meantime:
- nobody has ever heard about .pro
- the registry doesn't seem to be doing anything to promote it
- it's not carried by the mainstream registrars
- zero mindshare
- no notable development
Yet other extensions like .me .co .mobi have outperformed .pro very quickly so it's not like the climate is unfit for new extensions. .pro just doesn't fit in.
Perhaps it is a fetish thing among domainers. Personally I like .us but I'm not kidding myself about its value as an investment.
Being pro-.pro is okay but that shouldn't be at the expense of rational thinking.
Yes it's been slow and steady, but even .com took 15 years to really take off.
No, 1985 is not the baseline. The growth really started circa 1993 with the WWW and .com established itself very quickly.
It didn't take 15 years for .com to 'take off'.
Plus when these 'new' extensions are at domain 0, .pro is already at 100k.
100K is nothing. That number can easily be attained in a landrush. Even an utter 'failure' like .tel is triple of that.
Clever marketing can make the difference too.
We have the proof with .co that is already past 1M in a year. .mobi too.
The reason why I'm posting this is, I really think domainers need a reality check.