Search with/without Extension - Value

[Charley]

How would you value domains that have search with extension and without extension ?

For e.g xxxxx.com [with extension] shows 15 results and without extension 1500 searches each day. Another domain xxxx.com, there is no search with extension but recieve 5000 search each day. The search results are according to wordtracker.

1. Which would have more value?

2. What would be the difference in value[indicative figure] between both the domains i.e. with extension & search, with search only?

 

[likepeas]

those without extensions ofcourse go for more than those with etensions
you dont go into google and search : sex.com but you search sex. thats one example.

 

[Charley]

those without extensions ofcourse go for more than those with etensions

Sounds interesting, I was thinking on the contrary.

Need more comments to resolve my confusion.

 

[Devil_Dog]

those without extensions ofcourse go for more than those with etensions
you dont go into google and search : sex.com but you search sex. thats one example.

I disagree. If someone is searching for your site and your site only, then that makes it more valuable.

Search sex and you get billions of results, search sex.com and you have a better chance of that individual finding your site.

 

[Charley]

search sex.com and you have a better chance of that individual finding your site.

I am trying to compare 2 different domains not the same name with/without extension!

 

[Charley]

Anyone care to add more info here. It will help me with my analysis.

 

[John Doe]

those without extensions ofcourse go for more than those with etensions
you dont go into google and search : sex.com but you search sex. thats one example.

I have an opposite opinion. Search without extension values keyword. There can be still huge value difference comparing same keyword domains with different extensions - sex.com vs sex.ws for instance. So, if keyword has a lot of searches, it`s great. But search with extension gives extra boost to value of particular domain.

 

[Charley]

But search with extension gives extra boost to value of particular domain.

How much in numbers or percent? This is for analysis.