Hey, I'm sorry to join in the argument here, but the whole point of an appraisal is to seek the opinions of those you perceive are in a better position to offer one.
You are gaining the benefit of their experience.
If you don't respect their judgement, why are you bothering with this discussion. It's not constructive.
There'll always be somebody prepared to pay silly numbers, but an appraisal will never be exact. Just a rough guide from those with experience.
To me, 40k is a small fortune. I could buy nearly 10,000 domains with that here in the uk. Are you seriously suggesting this is a 1 in 10,000 domain name ? ?
You must be very rich or very confident.
Now will somebody please tell me how much isupplements is worth
Good luck !
Steve.