No, poorly-targeted emails do quite obviously have a negative effect... again:
- So much untargeted email causes people to assume other emails are junk, and they tune-out all emails like that... even legitimate ones.
- It causes email filters to think similar emails are spam, so legitimate emails sometimes don't even get through to the end-user.
- It may also cause people to assume there's a scam involved, because of the low-quality of the email text in many cases. He at least writes well, but many outbounders don't.
Those issues are already problems, because of outbounders - that's simply a fact.
Just because you get some responses from people doesn't change that fact.
And regarding spam, I already wrote about that in detail in my next post (above). It is a fact that many outbounders are spamming.
Even if it's sent manually, it can still be spam if each message is pretty much the same.
You need to read the question and answer accordingly
My response was fine. Most outbounders are quite frankly causing problems.
I receive unsolicited "outbound" emails almost every day or maybe more, so I see plenty of them.
Basically, his question is like "Is it worth it to do X in the summer", and my response is that people shouldn't do X
in a bad way at any time of year... because most outbounders do it in a bad way, and his responses and lack of summer sales frankly also suggest he's in that category.
I also don't think outbounders should be encouraging each other (
and worse, creating more outbounders) without anyone pointing out the problems they cause... so that some of them at least re-think doing it.
And again:
My first post was 2 lines and a link/quote to an earlier post, and
he could have simply replied with something like "I do targeted outbound emails, but yes, bulk-unsolicited outbound emails are a problem, and hurt legitimate outbound emails"... but his actual response was to be defensive about outbounding in general, and
not say anything about targeting. He mentioned something about "automated", but it can be sent manually and still be spam if it's poorly-targeted.
And in response to my first post, he threw out some nonsensical insults, along with foolishness like "This industry would be absolutely nothing without outbound sales."
And AGAIN, like I said, if he actually was sending targeted emails, it would be almost impossible to not get at least ONE sale in the summer for so many years.
And even if executives are on vacation in the summer,
targeted emails would still be useful, because it at least plants the seed for them to think about it and buy later, if not in the summer. But if they're just emailing 100 different people (who don't know them) because those people are in the general industry of the domain, obviously the emails are pointless (which would lead to no sales in the summer), and then cause the problems I mentioned.
So as I said, the question itself suggests problems within it.
You saying this is incorrect:
Even after the OP explained that wasnt what he was doing, you still replied with this below??
His first response said nothing about his emails being targeted, even though he easily could have said that.
Once again:
My first post was 2 lines and a link/quote to an earlier post, and he could have simply replied with something like "I do targeted outbound emails, but yes, untargeted emails are a problem"
--- And then we could have left it at that... but his actual response was to be defensive about outbounding in general, and
he did not say anything about targeting in that reply.
i.e. I wrote:
No, it does concern me (and everyone here), because people sending untargeted outbound hurts my sales (and sales in general), as I explained above.
...before he said anything about targeting. And he threw out his insults before he said anything about targeting.
Anyway, I've wasted far too much time on this stupidity now.
Outbounders reading this page need to realize the problems they cause, plain and simple.
Like my video games analogy (above), even if it's not technically unlawful (in the case of video games, or illegal spam in the case of emails), flooding the market (or inboxes) with junk causes problems for the overall market.
Just google this term to better understand how actions can cause negative effects in other ways:
negative externalities