It is the million dollar question, everyone at all levels of experience and sales savvy has a different thought.
Whether someone replies how much, or they find your name on a parked page or through whois and you get the I am interested in ******** How much ?
I had a bunch of them last year that all resulted in no sale, my strategy was giving a price, these were not premium names and nothing was priced outrageous, I believe I actually get the real student or person with no money, not the corporation or celebrity playing games. But anyhow...
Years ago I did not give a price and had more success, so I asked a few people, or went back and reread some other domain investors.
Morgan Linton has always said never be the first one to name a price and when I asked Michael Berkens from Most Wanted Domains, he said he always gives a price by email, he did note that he never gives it if someone calls, he tells them let me check our pricing and email you. That way you have it documented, no " I thought you said $60,000 on the phone not $100,000."
So you really have to think about how much data you can gather on a prospect and then go with either a price or we are looking for offers in the **** range.
Now there is a difference in emailing someone and they reply how much ? As opposed to getting an email through a landing page, I think if I emailed someone I have to have a price because I contacted them first.
It is the tricky part and sometimes lucky part of domain sales.