BrandBucket v BrandRoot

[AndyM]

Hi, I'm not sure if there has been any similar thread on this topic but I couldn't find one!

Anyhow....

Who do you prefer? and why? BrandBucket or BrandRoot?
Are brand root accepted domains as valuable as brandbucket accepted names on the resellers market?
I've just read Brand Roots seller agreement.....WOW!!! What do you think of it? Too harsh? Fair?

Let's hear your thought and opinions.

 

[Wisename]

I prefer brandbucket as long they focus on their quality service like fast approval, traffic, support, etc ..

I dont want list my domain to other marketplace because brandable marketplace like brandroot, namerific is founded by DOMAINER.
I dont think they have better understanding in development or entrepreneur culture.

 

[Recons.Com]

The most important thing is sales, but so far have no data to compare personally.

I have added names to BB 3-4 months back, have brought my total with them to around 40, haven't had a sale yet, but still too early. Started adding names to BR about a months ago, also getting my total to around 40 with them.

I like BR's choice of names better though. BB focuses to much on patterns and misses on good names. BR asks you to fill out description for each submission, so they have chance to see value that they could have missed. Of course, because of this, BB submission process is easy.

BB also has buy 100 credits, get 110. Hopefully, BR implements similar.

BR also likes black background logos, while haven't seen them with BB. Not sure if it affects sales in any way. BR also collects feedback on each logo, although won't change them based on your vote. Hence you don't get lazy logos that you get with BB, as designers are worried about ratings.

Overall, I plan to have 200-500 names with each, but will channel better names based on sales/customer service/other.

 

[kaposzta]

Unfortunately, I haven't had the chance to compare them yet, as I haven't received any reply to my application to BR

 

[Wisename]

Unfortunately, I haven't had the chance to compare them yet, as I haven't received any reply to my application to BR

They didn't reply my application since last year.

 

[BrandClub.com]

Between BB & BR the best is to have your own marketplace ...