I guess RL's domain prices in his newsletter just reflect one enduring truth about domain prices:
Domain prices are only ever in the eye of the beholder.
There's no such thing as a verifiable 'fair', 'high', or 'low' price for any domain, imo - at best, only educated guesswork...based on experience, comparisons, maybe a few metrics - and, most of all, what someone will pay for it.
I love it when I read domainers saying '$xxx,xxx for abcde domain? - A STEAL!'......Or, they say: '$xxxx for THAT domain? Paid far too much!'
Truth is, no one can ever tell if it was a steal of a buy for the buyer - or, a fantastically high price for the seller - until, sometime in the future, the buyer makes a decent ROI, or doesn't. That's the only measure, in the end....Same goes for a $xxx domain, or a hand reg, you might have bought.
So, Rick's asking prices aren't high - or low. They're just what he hopes to get. The market will either agree - and buy at the price - or it won't agree, and they go unsold.
It was ever thus.
.