Dynadot

25 criteria to be a premium domain name in 2022

Spaceship Spaceship
Watch

redemo

Mug RuithTop Member
Impact
3,029
Ok so I hear a lot of domainers call their domain names " premium domain names " or " super premium domain names " or " ultra premium domain names " and I'd like to know what exactly that means in 2022? To me a premium domain name is one very popular English word with dot com at the end. That's my opinion and I'm not for one minute suggesting it's the same for anybody else. Maybe it's a purely subjective phrase without any established criteria? Below I have quoted several notable websites definition of what is a premium domain name, and then I've compiled a combined list of key features from them. Do you agree with the list? My objective here is to have a specific checklist to reference when a domainer calls their domain name a premium domain name, rather than just anyone being able to use this phrase without any criteria and I have to accept it as fact. Related question for @Alfa Mod Team are there any rules about using the phrase " premium domain name " in a sales thread or can anyone use this phrase without restriction? Can I say df345egrh-trg-ewfwef-qerg-4th4t.com is a premium domain name, for example? Also for the record I have 60 domain names in my portfolio and I don't consider any of them to be premium domain names. And before anyone asks yes I used Namepros search and found one old thread from 2017 started by @mirecart and the last comment was by @strugar on November 4th 2017, so yes I checked out previous Namepros threads, yes I looked through Namepros help section and yes I scoured all content by the legend @Bob Hawkes. Still very puzzled by this important topic.

Notable websites description of a premium domain name

1. Domain.com


" Premium domain names are high-quality domains that have been previously registered but are available for sale at today's market value. A domain is considered to be high quality if the name is shorter, regularly searched, closely associated to the actual service or industry, and typically uses a TLD such as .com, .net, or .org. Such domains are easier to spell, easier to remember, and more intuitive. " domain.com/domains/premium

2. Forbes.com

" Trustworthy TLD. The top-level domain (TLD) is the string of characters at the end of a domain. To be worth anything at all, a domain name needs to have a good TLD that doesn't compromise your ability to reach potential customers. In general, premium domain names will usually use the .com TLD or a relevant country code that suits the target audience. Brevity. Overly long domain names can be harder to remember. Likewise, domains with hyphens or other punctuation can be less successful due to this complexity. Any domain name needs to be concise in a practical sense that makes it more memorable. As a result, premium domain names usually consist of one to two words or two to four individual characters. Generic value. Many of the most valuable domain sales of all time dealt with domain names that had deeply generic names. For instance, consider CarInsurance.com, which sold for nearly $50 million. This sort of generic value dramatically increases demand thanks to industry-wide appeal, and it serves to amplify value in the process. Contains keywords and high domain authority. SEO is one of the keys to running a successful web presence in the modern day, and domain names can help. While Google has reported it does not weigh keywords in domain names, I've found it's generally true that domain names with keywords make up an outsized share of the first-page results. There are many potential reasons for this, but it is a trend worth keeping in mind. Two elements of a domain name that absolutely do affect SEO are age and domain authority. Domain authority is a value that shows the regard that Google holds a domain in, and purchasing an authoritative domain can save months or years on your SEO efforts. " forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2021/07/06/what-exactly-is-a-premium-domain-name

3. Godaddy.com

" Premium domain names are short, catchy, memorable names that are already registered to a person, entity or organization. The cost of a premium domain can range from a 3‐figure number to a 7‐figure number, depending on the demand. " godaddy.com/help/what-is-a-premium-domain-name-2878

4. Name.com

" A Premium Domain is a domain that already has an owner, but is being resold at a higher value to a potential end user. (Or, with the debut of New TLDs, a domain that the registry has reserved as Premium stock and thus priced higher than normal.) These domains tend to be short, keyword rich, and (in most cases) come with a hefty price tag. But despite the higher cost, they’re considered some of the most valuable domain names on the market. Just think of a few of the most expensive Premium Domains to ever sell: they included the likes of insurance.com, hotels.com, and casinos.com, all of which take advantage of relative, generic keywords that millions of people search for online on a regular basis. " name.com/blog/domains/premium-domains/2017/09/whats-a-premium-domain/

5. Networksolutions.com

" Not all domain names are created equal. Some are inherently worth more than others, especially to the right buyer. A premium domain name purchase is an investment in your business and your brand. Despite the heftier price tag, premium names pay off in the long run. Below, we'll look at various qualities characteristic of these domain names to help us understand why they're so desirable and commandeer a premium price. Qualities of a Premium Domain Name Short and to the point Brevity isn't just the soul of wit; it's at the heart of a great premium domain name. Short domain names are more memorable than longer names, and it pays to be the brand that people easily recall when in need of your goods or services. So, when selecting a premium domain name, don't get lost in too much text or "clever" usage of numbers and symbols. Contains relevant keywords A keyword-rich domain name lends itself well to your SEO efforts. Many websites that appear on the first page of search results have keywords in the domain name or are single-word domains. Widely-recognized TLD There's a reason why people say .com is king — it's widely recognizable and trusted. However, most .com domain names are already registered (at least the good ones, anyway.) If you want to purchase a one-word, keyword-specific domain name or a domain name that's an exact match for your business or brand name, you're going to pay a premium. You can also find premium names that utilize other trusted TLDs, like .org. Older domain and high authority Two SEO ranking factors that involve your domain are age and authority. Premium domain names are often older domain names seeing as they've been registered previously. And authority, a ranking factor developed by Moz, refers to how likely a domain is to appear in SERPs. Traffic history A premium domain name used in the past can have decent traffic history. And some traffic may still attempt to visit the domain and related site. Think of that traffic as potentially qualified prospects you didn't have to pay to attract to your site. Brandable Building a brand is easier when your domain name is memorable and recognizable. A brandable domain name demands a higher price because it's a great advantage to have in a competitive and crowded market. " networksolutions.com/blog/establish/domains/guide-to-premium-domain-names

6. Ionos.com

" Due to the large number of websites on the internet, it's not always easy to secure the most attractive domain for your project. Fortunately, when a high value domain expires it becomes available for re-registration, which is known as a premium domain. However, not all expired domains automatically become premium – an expired domain is simply one that has been previously used but not re-registered by the original domain owner. Premium names, on the other hand, are those that have retained their high marketing value to you as a business or individual. Premium domain names differ from ordinary ones because they often contain important keywords, are short and snappy, and have a proven track record of driving web traffic. For example, 'bestcars.com', 'discountgas.com', and 'luxuryholidays.com' are all memorable and clearly display the purpose of the site. Because of these qualities, they are highly sought after and can also be identified by their relatively high price compared to other domains. " ionos.com/domains/premium-domains

7. Wordpress.com

" Premium domains have a higher perceived value because they are short and memorable. Therefore, they are more expensive than a standard domain. Premium pricing can vary from being slightly higher than the standard price or up to ten, a hundred, or a thousand times more! The price of a premium domain is largely determined by the registry for each TLD. TLD stands for “top-level domain”, sometimes referred to as an extension. These are the characters to the right of the dot – for example .com or .blog. Since registrars (that’s us) must pay the registry for each domain, registrars must factor in the registry’s pricing model to determine how much to charge customers. At a high level, registries assign one of two main pricing models to domains – standard and premium. The prices of standard domain TLDs are listed on our Domain Pricing page. To view the price of a standard or premium domain, go to My Site → Domains → Add domain to this site and search for the domain you’re interested in. " wordpress.com/support/premium-domains/

8. Namebright.com

" The right domain name is one of the most important business decisions you will make. That is why NameBright offers you the option to purchase a Premium Domain name. A premium domain name is domain that can better convey your business to the world. They are pre-owned domains originally purchased years ago, but available to you now, on a premium basis. A premium domain can set your business apart and give the impression of a much longer online business history. Try our Premium Domain search and open up a whole new world of valuable domain name options! " namebright.com/PremiumDomains

List of 25 criteria to be a premium domain name
  1. Previously registered or
  2. already registered
  3. Short
  4. Catchy
  5. Snappy
  6. Highly brandable
  7. Older than most domain names
  8. Previously developed with traffic history
  9. Regularly searched key words by millions of people
  10. Generic key words
  11. Service or industry related
  12. Uses the top level domain .com, .net or .org ( or other trustworthy T.L.D. ) or
  13. uses a relevant country code top level domain or
  14. uses a new top level domain and has been reserved as premium stock by the registry
  15. Easy to spell
  16. Easy to remember
  17. Doesn't include hyphens
  18. Doesn't include numbers
  19. Doesn't attempt to be clever
  20. One or two words
  21. Two to four characters ( if not a word )
  22. Large price tag
  23. High marketing value
  24. Clearly displays website's purpose
  25. Sets your business apart from others
Do you agree or disagree with this list of premium domain name features?
 
Last edited:
24
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
@Bob Hawkes do you have a comment or thread about this? Cheers.
I think it is almost impossible to define premium in a way that encompasses all possibilities.

Your list includes many general rules that are accepted by many, not all, as representing higher quality names. Thank you for creating it.

A few things confuse me. You say that a new extension name can only be premium if the registry designate it as premium price. But some registries designate many more names as premium than others. Does that make the same word premium in those TLDs, but not in another, even if the other TLD has wider use and higher aftermarket sales? If we look at the top 15 sales in .xyz from last year, I think only 1 was designated registry premium. I don't think this should be a factor.

You say in 4 that it should be catchy, but in 19 it should not attempt to be clever. In my mind many catchy names are in fact successful attempts to be clever, like slight alterations to a common phrase.

Is snappy different from short? Perhaps. The word snappy did sell as one of top 100 sales of last year.

It seems to me the best way to validate such a list, is to apply it to a list of names that have sold for good prices, such as the NameBio Top 100 Sales of 2021, and see how the different rules hold up.

When I go through that sales list it is easy to find exceptions to many of the rules. For example, you said no numbers, but surely BTC365 is a strong name, and sold for over $130,000.

21 says 2 to 4L if not a word, but surely Z.org that sold for a strong price is premium?

Rule 20 says only 1 or 2 words, but RVsForSale sold for $194,000 last year.

Does 23, high marketing value, mean that the name has a solid search volume and cost per click? At least 5 of the top sales of last year have 0 search volume, and numerous others very modest search volumes.

Does 24 'clearly display a website's purpose' mean that premium names are exact or suggestive product or service names? Because it seems many big sales are not in recent years, and many branding exercises go to a name not specifically related.

When 6 says highly brandable, it seems logical, but the more I think about it, what does that mean exactly? Like if you mean get a TM on the word, if the word is generic and you are in that sector (like word boot and you have a company that manufactures boots) in most cases that generic word can not be TMed as I understand it (you could TM it for something that has nothing to do with footwear). Made up terms that no one currently uses can be TM, but are they premium? Maybe.

8 says previously developed with history. But many names that sell for a lot were never previously significantly developed. Some regard that as a positive. They prefer a name with no history. A clean slate. A great name that has been registered for ages, but not used. Of course some names do sell for their link history which the buyer hopes to repurpose for a similar website.

15 says easy to spell, and in general agree that is highly desired, but there are many names that sell that would be a challenge to spell.

Please don't take this as a criticism of what you have done, but rather my view that what you set out to do is impossible for anyone to do precisely. That is partly why domain investing is so challenging, and interesting!

I would say a premium name is one that the majority of a representative group of successful business owners would regard as valuable, and that a majority of experienced domain investors would regard as of high quality. While accepting that neither group would be unanimous on any particular name.

Thank you for your contributions.

Bob
 
Last edited:
19
•••
I wouldn't consider Godaddy, NetworkSolutions or Wordpress to be premium. I think of these more of brandable type domains.

To me premium would be one word, that's commonly used.

Or 2 words that are exact match for a popular service or generic product: CarWash, SepticTank, GarageSale...

Or CITYNAME+SERVICE of a big city and popular service: DenverRoofing, HoustonPlumbing, SeattleConstruction, PortlandHomes...
 
Last edited:
18
•••
I have a definition of Premium, that I just invented and that no one can beat :) :

If 10 out of 10 domainers are willing to pay $1000 right away for a domain name with a clear resale purpose - that's a Premium name.
 
Last edited:
13
•••
I think words that we see with hyphens will sell better than the words we don't and example be

X-ray.com might sell better than xray.com
 
Last edited:
12
•••
Just because a premium domain name doesn't sell it doesn't mean it isn't a premium domain name. All combinations of single letter dot com are premium domain names. a.com, b.com, c.com. Pretty much general consensus on that I will assume. None of them sold between 2020 and 2022. play-poker.com, sci-fi.com, wi-fi.com, buy-cars.com are all premium domain names according to most of the rules shared so far. You cannot exclude hyphens just because they are hyphens. There has to be a logical reason. Who would say sci-fi.com is not worth $20k?
What I usually ask myself is, "Is there a better version?" If there's something better, then it's not really premium then.

In terms of premium, I consider

Poker.com > PlayPoker com > Play-Poker.com

Wifi.com > Wi-fi.com

Cars.com > BuyCars.com > Buy-Cars.com

That a domain is not premium doesn't mean it's a bad domain. It just means it's not top of the line. Just like in premium cars
 
Last edited:
8
•••
what you set out to do is impossible for anyone to do precisely. That is partly why domain investing is so challenging, and interesting!
Hi

totally agree!

there are hundreds of previous threads on the subject, and the consensus is that:
"premium domains, speak for themselves"


imo..
 
7
•••
This phrase " premium domain name " is proving far more challenging to define than I had originally imagined.
Hi

the quote above, was something most of us already knew.
mainly because we came in the game before "premium" was an adjective attachment, to try and sell domain names.

also, most of the high dollar sales you may be amazed with now, were not valued as high in the past

for instance:
when i started domaining, on average, LLL.com prices were $$$/ LL.com low to mid 5 figures / NNNN.com $$$/ 3 char.com and LLLL.com reg fee / LL.org $$$/ LLL.org $$

so, time is a variable that applies to established names, and time affects recent hand regs, in that in time, they too may become "premium" in it's category.

like how "crypto", became premium only after blockchain and that relation to the word "coin" elevated it above definition to "hard coins" like gold/silver to that of bitcoin.
so, today, you have new categories of premium keywords under that umbrella of terms.

same speculation before iphone came out.
everyone betting on .mobi names, then the rush was on and some made profits.
but when iphone didn't have .mobi as default, wasn't no more premiums.

same speculation with CHIPS
premium chips down the line from .com to .info
the run lasted prolly a couple of years,
and who got the premium chips now?

time, is a variable and factor... and many times, it's part of criteria.

imo...
 
7
•••
in high demand. A new word or expression could become premium in a matter of hours if not seconds.
 
6
•••
In other words, Premium=Subjective, for most part.
 
6
•••
The term "premium" is grossly overused by domain investors. I think everyone can agree on that.

I think everyone can also agree on a domain like Gold.com, RealEstate.com, Cars.com, etc. being premium.

The list is a good starting point, but not all-inclusive in every situation.

I would say you know a premium domain when you see it, though sometimes even that is not clear.

Not every premium domain will stand out right away. Some might be more technical in a field you are just not familiar with. If people dismiss a domain without knowing about the field, that is just personal incredulity.

The nuance of domain valuation is really something you only learn via experience. You don't need "premium" domains to build a business. In fact the vast majority of sales are more decent domains.

Brad
 
Last edited:
6
•••
I'd take out #18. I'd consider these premium.

100.com
22.com
888.com
 
5
•••
I couldn't find one decent Namepros about what is a premium domain name let alone hundreds of threads about premium domain names. Sure you're not just making this up bro?
Hi

here are a few threads on the topic, where i put my user-name and entered "premium domains" as keyword in search function

https://www.namepros.com/threads/wh...e-a-premium-domain-name.1212931/#post-8044175

https://www.namepros.com/threads/how-to-value-llll-com-help-plz.1213303/

https://www.namepros.com/threads/a-tool-to-check-if-a-domain-is-premium.1131813/#post-7189169

https://www.namepros.com/threads/ho...premium-or-high-quality.1117096/#post-7047130

https://www.namepros.com/threads/who-consider-a-domain-as-premium.1092643/#post-6822785

redemo said:
I'm looking for a specific set of criteria rather than a general consensus. For example all LL.com are premium domain names. All LLL.com are premium domain names. Those are specific not subjective. So far the only premium thing about most " premium " domains is the premium price tag. Why use a word which has no meaning?

Hi,
within those categories, some LL.com or LLL.com are considered top-tier above others, thereby commanding higher prices.
those priced or sold on lower end within that category, may not be considered premium,
but their price ranges may be higher than one's budget.
so, the "subjectivity" remains, even at that level

that "top-tier" level and "category killers" exists down the line and across the board for a variety of keywords and domain categories.

imo..
 
5
•••
In other words, Premium=Subjective, for most part.
I completely agree what is premium is subjective even going off the op’s list many of those points are subjective.

The word is overused and therefore meaningless. People can’t even agree what “brandable” means let alone premium.
 
4
•••
When I go through that sales list it is easy to find exceptions to many of the rules. For example, you said no numbers, but surely BTC365 is a strong name, and sold for over $130,000.

21 says 2 to 4L if not a word, but surely Z.org that sold for a strong price is premium?

Rule 20 says only 1 or 2 words, but RVsForSale sold for $194,000 last year.
In my opinion, that a domain sells for some substantial money or at all doesn't necessarily mean premium. It might just simply mean that the domain is nice, has a use-case and someone had the money to pay for it.

In your example, I will consider Z.org as a premium domain but not BTC365 and RVsForSale. Now BTC.com or RV.com, I will consider premium.
 
4
•••
In my opinion

1. A premium name cannot be a made up word or a brandable name that is a mix of words.

2. A premium name is an EMD .com domain with no hyphens or numbers. Usually one or two words, rarely three.

3. The more searches the EMD gets and the higher the CPC the more premium.

4. Every industry has many keywords associated with it. If you have the keyword that is most used with the most searches, you are gold as long as you have time to wait.

5. One word names that are easy to spell and pass the radio test and are real words and under 9 letters are premium.

6. Popular phrases like SeeYou WelcomeHome DinnerTime LetsGo are all premium.

There are always new industries popping up. This gives people opportunities in domains. New keywords etc. New premium opportunities exist in those industries if you can find names early. It's a lot of gambling because most of the names domainers will get for those new industries will never sell and in many cases, you have to be so early that most of these new trends will never even take off.

Retail buyers of domains are very lucky. Most domainers don't know how to price, negotiate and generally are bad at sales.

When you own a domain it will be many years without nobody even contacting you about it even if it's the best domain name possible. Afternic would need to have a sales team of 50,000 people if domains would have the interest like many of you think they do.
 
4
•••
If you took the time to type this out, I've got some respect for that

Regarding the 25 criteria: Yes, a lot of it sounds fair. IMO
 
Last edited:
3
•••
I have a definition of Premium, that I just invented and that no one can beat :) :

If 10 out of 10 domainers are willing to pay $1000 right away for a domain name with a clear resale purpose - that's a Premium name.
Actually they still try a $100 as everyone is looking for the flip.
 
Last edited:
3
•••
Actually they still try a $100 as everyone is looking for the flip.

Except the sellers. They usually are not looking for a flip for their premium domains, because they have their opinion what "premium" means :)
 
3
•••
I couldn't find one decent Namepros about what is a premium domain name let alone hundreds of threads about premium domain names. Sure you're not just making this up bro?

I'm looking for a specific set of criteria rather than a general consensus. For example all LL.com are premium domain names. All LLL.com are premium domain names. Those are specific not subjective. So far the only premium thing about most " premium " domains is the premium price tag. Why use a word which has no meaning?
Even that is still subjective. I will consider Ai.com as premium but ZQ.com not as much even though some will consider it premium simply because it's a 2L.

It think the word premium is stratified when it comes to domains. Some 2Ls are just more of a premium than others. Same can be said of one word domains. So, while all 2Ls are equal, some are more equal than others.
 
Last edited:
3
•••
This phrase " premium domain name " is proving far more challenging to define than I had originally imagined.
Many have tried, all have failed.

:xf.smile:
 
3
•••
As many have said, I think it is subjective. One of the definitions of the word 'premium' is scarce and in demand. New tech names like p2egames can be considered premium in this regard.
 
3
•••
Generally, a name is considered premium when it has strategic branding/marketing value to multiple entities. Value is then subjective and dependent on several variables, such as industry, need, desire, circumstance, demand, risk, timing, etc. etc. Sometimes, the value is not immediately apparent as seen in this very interesting thread: https://www.namepros.com/threads/longest-running-drop-auction-five-nines.1126088/

imo..
 
3
•••
3
•••
Do you consider it to be a premium domain name? Based on the comments in this discussion, I would say yes.
Hi

for the auto industry, cars.xyz, would be the premium, compared to car.xyz

imo...
 
Last edited:
3
•••
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back