Which logo is more professional - please help settle a dispute...

[HeyGeek]

OK,
I'm having a friendly dispute with someone right now, I think one logo looks more professional than another and they disagree...

Which logo is the better, more professional logo out of the two below:

1.

2.

Please be as blunt as possible and make fun of the concept you don't like.

Also - I know alot of people won't like either one.... the question is which one of the two is the BETTER one.

Thanks!
George

 

[Nitro]

Personally, I like the second one. :imho:

 

[ChrisChris]

I like the first one because I cant really see whats on the 2nd one

 

[WiiSaid]

I like the second because the first one is way, way to plain the second has some nice red effect and has more to do with the site.

 

[DotWeekly]

# 2 is much more eye catching!

 

[rosh86]

none of the two to be honest so cant vote ...


Rosh

 

[Poison]

The second is the better of the two.

 

[zenlogo]

Neither of the two could be regarded as professional... they're both too busy and intricate. However, of the two, the second has greater impact because of the red 'star'. Personally I'd loose the stethescope/clipboard stuff.

 

[Broker]

Neither of the two could be regarded as professional... they're both too busy and intricate. However, of the two, the second has greater impact because of the red 'star'. Personally I'd loose the stethescope/clipboard stuff.

My thoughts exactly, loose the clutter and keep it simple.

 

[HeyGeek]

Thanks folks, I appreciate it. It looks like both actually got the same amount of votes... go figure...

Thanks again!

 

[Coolprogram]

IN My Honest Opinion, I like the first one the best. To me, it is a little more clear, and it is easier to be read than the second.
-CP

 

[HoodStar]

neither

 

[lpxxfaintxx]

Second one.

 

[featherblown]

the text for the first one is more professional-looking but the logo on the second one is better than the first.

 

[44pixels]

Number 1. It's cleaner & looks more professional.

 

[Gene]

The better of the two in my opinion is #1, but both are too confusing to be effective. When someone looks at a logo, they shouldn't have to 'think' about what the heck it is.

 

[metoni]

Logo 2

 

[Omnishare]

Logo 1 hands down. The second one is awful. I wouldn't classify either as "professional" but if we just need to decide which of the two is better...the first one beats out the second one any day of the week.

 

[johname]

the first is the best, its simpler, easyer to read. the second has that asterick that look like a bullet hole, and it has way to much red in one big spot.

 

[yandig]

I like the font on #1 better, but the design of #2.