Is .TOP Going to be next gTLD Hit or Flop?

SpaceshipSpaceship
Watch

When .Top going to break 1 Million Registration Mark?


  • 23 votes
  • Ended 10 years ago
  • Final results

Nile Patel

IdealDomainEstablished Member
Impact
170
Is any one has any idea , why new investor love .top as investment tool , why not any other gtld.

Here what i see in this article is how Chinese new domineers following trend and math of investment.
https://www.yumi.com/news/xindingjiyu/newgtld-14982.shtml

I know top means best in china and everywhere , but is any other new gTLD going to follow this kind of marketing hype and do western investors going to follow this bandwagon.

Is .com going to loose power if few more gTLD hype get success in new investor after .xyz and .top???
 
2
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
Unstoppable Domains — AI StorefrontUnstoppable Domains — AI Storefront
that's right. it is undenied that the foreign transactions is not as much as chinese market.
But I'm still confident with .top.
If you doubt whether the .top be sold before expiring and don't mind chinese interface, you can take a look at the transactions in Chinese QQ auction group.:roll:

Chinese QQ auction group?
 
0
•••
0
•••
I have QQ app but how do I join the group?
 
1
•••
I have QQ app but how do I join the group?
You can use group ID 51448939 to search the .top auction group.
This group is only allowed to talk about .top and sell your .top domain name.
No other extentions. No promotion.
I was banned for a week last time due to publish some ads.
But in this group, you'll know the .top price and more about .top
 
4
•••
As a thought experiment, and echoing the comment above by Kate, if I wanted to create a web site / blog called TaiwanIsIndependentCountryDoesNotBelongToChina.Top would the domain be banned by the registry? And I start writing about how Taiwan is a country and does not belong to China.. I wonder what the Communist Party government would do or the registry.

Alright, alright, everybody knows you are a .top hater. Where there is a .top post, there is a Brandnow, attacking. But what's the meaning of dragging politics in? You can say Beijing and Shanghai don't belong to China either, and then what changes? Naive.

When you did build the site, wrote that and the government or registry did just what you "expected" to you, then come here and whine.
 
Last edited:
0
•••
nice domains
 
0
•••
0
•••
Alright, alright, everybody knows you are a .top hater. Where there is a .top post, there is a Brandnow, attacking. But what's the meaning of dragging politics in? You can say Beijing and Shanghai don't belong to China either, and then what changes? Naive.

When you did build the site, wrote that and the government or registry did just what you "expected" to you, then come here and whine.

No. Taiwan is a country.

Shanghai and Beijing are cities in China.

There's a BIG difference.

My concern is that because .Top is controlled under the Chinese Communist Party that freedom of speech would not be allowed and censorship will rule this extension.
 
0
•••
But why would they ? Apparently .top is an extension for Chinese, and endorsed by the communist party. Is this what I would want ? Nope.
In a few months, you will find a number of non-Chinese operated TLDs/registries and registrars run their businesses in China, given MIIT license, in your words "endorsed by the communist party".

A friend of mine works in the company that helps these registris and registrars to get the license to open their outlet in China. This is certain although he won't tell which TLDs and registrars as they have NDA. But we will see soon.

MIIT license is just a normal license for you to run IT business in China, not so different from that you will still need to open a business in most of any other countries anyway. Only being afraid that sth might be bad or evil without any previous records/experience is unnecessary.
 
0
•••
and politics have much ado with the .Top extension because it's owned by China and sanctioned by the Chinese Communist Party which currently rules China.

I know what Internet censorship is like in China, unfortunately most Chinese people in China do not, because they never experienced the Internet without censorship and blocked sites. It's a crappy version of the Internet where 40% or more of the web is blocked.. access to Facebook, Wikipedia, and other vital sites are blocked. Freedom of speech is not allowed. Only the government view is allowed on any topics of real importance.
 
0
•••
For example, I don't particularly like .XYZ but at least I'm not concerned about censorship with a .XYZ domain / web site. It is controlled by an American company / entrepreneur and not sanctioned by the Chinese government. Hope you can understand what I mean.
 
0
•••
No. Taiwan is a country.
Shanghai and Beijing are cities in China.
There's a BIG difference.
My concern is that because .Top is controlled under the Chinese Communist Party that freedom of speech would not be allowed and censorship will rule this extension.
and politics have much ado with the .Top extension because it's owned by China and sanctioned by the Chinese Communist Party which currently rules China.

I know what Internet censorship is like in China, unfortunately most Chinese people in China do not, because they never experienced the Internet without censorship and blocked sites. It's a crappy version of the Internet where 40% or more of the web is blocked.. access to Facebook, Wikipedia, and other vital sites are blocked. Freedom of speech is not allowed. Only the government view is allowed on any topics of real importance.

I really won't care if a region is a called country or not and I believe I'm not alone regardless of nationalities. The point remains, politics doesn't have anything to do with TLDs.

I don't think the .top registry is a state owned company, and even if the govn't can do something to influence it in a bad or good way, I don't think ICANN would allow that either. Any actual proof of any .top website or the TLD itself is under Chinese government censorship would really help. Otherwise, your concern is meaningless.
 
2
•••
For example, I don't particularly like .XYZ but at least I'm not concerned about censorship with a .XYZ domain / web site. It is controlled by an American company / entrepreneur and not sanctioned by the Chinese government. Hope you can understand what I mean.
Hope you provide solid convincing evidence that anyone's .top website will be censored by the cn govn't.
 
0
•••
Hope you provide solid convincing evidence that anyone's .top website will be censored by the cn govn't.

Go back to my post. I was asking a question for you and the other .Top employees regarding censorship of content and domain names for .Top. It's not "hate speech" to ask a fair question about censorship, though I know in China asking this question would probably have the citizen disappeared by the net police.
 
0
•••
and politics have much ado with the .Top extension because it's owned by China and sanctioned by the Chinese Communist Party which currently rules China.

I know what Internet censorship is like in China, unfortunately most Chinese people in China do not, because they never experienced the Internet without censorship and blocked sites. It's a crappy version of the Internet where 40% or more of the web is blocked.. access to Facebook, Wikipedia, and other vital sites are blocked. Freedom of speech is not allowed. Only the government view is allowed on any topics of real importance.

Ok, now we are talking Chinese censorship, good. First, I admit Chinese internet environment sucks. The speed is super slow and we can't visit some foreign websites without using VPN. A few years ago, when I was young :D, I still hated it. But now, I feel different, below are what I truly feel about Chinese internet censorship right now, and hope foreigners like you can understand more about it:

Because of 7 years’ two Opium Wars, 1 year first China-Japan War, 8 years’ Japan Invading China (during Second World War), 3 years’ Korean War, and 10 years’ Cultural Revolution. China’s development lags behind the western world for at least 30 years. So when you started to enjoy freedom of speech on the internet, a lot of Chinese didn’t know what is internet yet. Plus the rate of illiteracy and high academic degree, no government could not worry about how its citizens lacking knowledge and mature judgement would be influenced from a non-censored/protected environment when there are still forces trying to split China. Do you know how many spies (Chinese bought off by foreign government through means like internet) were captured a year there around Chinese military facilities? Well things between countries are usually like this I know, because it’s all about interests.

But in many developed countries, a majority of population are well educated, like you are, and you can protect yourselves from this unlimited internet. But I know I couldn’t have years back. If you keep reading Chinese news, you will see how often and how many people fell for lame tricks and lost money or lives sometimes.

Additionally, Chinese search engine doesn’t have filter search, movies don’t have ratings, and laws are far from sound let alone perfect. So not seeing the information that Chinese netizens can’t protect themselves from is good for them to some extent. Chinese govn’t leaders are not stupid, so they know prohibiting freedom of speech or website visiting is not right, but they do have to protect their people, therefore the stability of the country. And I also believe, when the rate of higher education increases to a certain level, and when people can protect themselves from the harsh (can’t say pleasant) internet environment, the situation will change. And it’s getting better already. I live here so I know.

In the end, I feel sorry for those of you that ever had bad experience in or with China. If you have any questions you would like to know about things here, please feel free to let me know, and I will try my best to give you facts and neutral opinions.
 
5
•••
Go back to my post. I was asking a question for you and the other .Top employees regarding censorship of content and domain names for .Top. It's not "hate speech" to ask a fair question about censorship, though I know in China asking this question would probably have the citizen disappeared by the net police.
Please read my reply at #55 and please stop saying "I know in China you will get *** and ***" without any real evidence" when you actually really don't.
I've been living in China for nearly 30 years and I've worked in and been to about 2/3 provinces here, so unless you are a Chinese native(apparently not), you are less likely to know more about China than I do.
 
2
•••
The fact is, regardless of where we are located, there are domain-names that could be registered (and sentiments expressed) that would attract the close scrutiny of the PTB (Powers-That-Be).

We all know that the extent of that scrutiny differs from nation to nation and jurisdiction to jurisdiction. As does local PTB responses to 'non-normative' behavior.

None of us want unnamed officials dropping in to 'check the water meter' ('查水表').

We're all fish in someone's net. Let's look out for each other.
 
3
•••
The fact is, regardless of where we are located, there are domain-names that could be registered (and sentiments expressed) that would attract the close scrutiny of the PTB (Powers-That-Be).

We all know that the extent of that scrutiny differs from nation to nation and jurisdiction to jurisdiction. As does local PTB responses to 'non-normative' behavior.

None of us want unnamed officials dropping in to 'check the water meter' ('查水表').

We're all fish in someone's net. Let's look out for each other.
You are right and there is no 100% freedom of speech in any country, remember PRISM. Governments are the same when it comes to national security. You all will do the same when you are in their position.
 
2
•••
None of us want unnamed officials dropping in to 'check the water meter' ('查水表').
I might probably not open the door but yell "I've paid the water bill online"
 
2
•••
Every system is a system in a bigger System.
 
2
•••
Appraise.net

We're social

Spaceship
Domain Recover
CatchDoms
NameMaxi - Your Domain Has Buyers
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back