Got 2 banners - Can't decide which one is best

[fryzie]

Hey lads

My website is http://www.whitersmile.com.au/ where I sell teeth whitening

Had some people design a 'birthday' banner for me which im going to wack above the 'It's not just a business'.

Im having troubles deciding on these two

Completely differently colors makes it stand out well - my friend doesn't like this one and said it doesn't fit in with the rest of the pages style.

and

Colors match the site, but I cant help think it just makes everything too repetitive on my page - colors/styles.



Any opinions please?

 

[nmr86]

I like the first one.. its way better and better looking

 

[BrewerFan]

I prefer the second one. It matches the site very well!

 

[Sameh]

I like the first one .. more catchy

 

[Albino]

i'd say the second one really. it stands out more, uses the space in the banner better as well.

the firs toe is nice, but the square bits almost cover the teeth, which is a bit pointless.

 

[Torquex]

I think the big 50% in the 2nd banner is more catchy, and it matches your site well.

 

[Mike]

Really what you needed is a merger of 1 & 2, the use of space is by far better in the second banner, however, the message of whiter teeth doesn't come through. The use of space and delivery of your message in #1 is not as good as in #2, but the girl with the white teeth represents your site better.

The merger should be, mainly use banner #2, leave colors and text the same, push it to the left and use the "white teeth girl" from #1 towards the right hand side, without the squares.

:imho:

 

[JoePool]

however, the message of whiter teeth doesn't come through.

Spot on. Hybrid of both.

The first one looks way more classy though.

 

[Tippy]

I prefer the second one, matches your site better, but dont like the " 50% " text color...

As mentioned those square thingys over the face makes that area too busy and theres alot of empty/wasted space below the text...

I was bored... added some shadow, fixed her make-up a bit... :hehe:

 

[Fewski]

I like the design of the first one, but the colors of the second one. More of a personal preference... the visitor will most likely see both of them and know what is going on - so go with what ever one you like the most.

 

[scopeweb]

Yep I agree the first one looks the best!!!

 

[leede]

First one seems better as I suppose

 

[bublebubbles]

i prefer the 2nd one actually.. poll?

 

[OctaneInv]

Second.

 

[fryzie]

look at my page lads
thats what one of them looks like

i like it a lot

 

[zielak]

First one looks more professional to me.

 

[Tippy]

look at my page lads
thats what one of them looks like

i like it a lot

I agree, looks good/better...

 

[Breakpoint]

i like the first one, but without the squares in the corner

 

[muttley]

I can't decide which I like best.

You have noticed the error on the second one though?

It should be "Brighten Your Smile Today", not "Brighten You're Smile Today"

 

[ApeXX]

I like the second one... It stands out more and matches the color scheme of the page better. :imho: