Unstoppable Domains — AI Assistant

opinion Favorite Domain Appraisal Service

NamecheapNamecheap
Watch

DomainRex

domainrex.comEstablished Member
Impact
52
What are your favorite appraisal websites to use?

I been using Estibot & Godaddy for a while, started using Nameworth recently too

So far my favorite is probably Nameworth
 
Last edited:
5
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
AfternicAfternic
do you think your Nameworth evaulation would be the same before that sale happened?? I dont think so.

Absolutely! Look for yourself... The first time I ran the query was 5/16/2020. Other users ran it before that and sure enough, someone ran it at 11:58:53 on 5/20/2019, just 7 days after the date of the reported sale 5/20/2019. NameWorth doesn't use sales data in any form to inflate domain values. Never has and never will.

upload_2020-5-21_0-33-0.png


You keep using that one sale, this is an exception to the rule, sales like this are not the norm, yes someone wanted the name so they were prepared to pay big dollars for it. I can assure you they didnt go and put it in an appraisal tool and lift their budget accordingly.

I'm not focusing on any one sale. Run any of Mike Mann's sales the second they are reported. It will be about the same.

See the results for Aptum(dot)com in my post above. Same deal. It would completely amaze me if more than 5% of domain investors put a price of $94,000 or more on that domain. Saying people should just do their own research is like saying they'll fix a problem...that they don't realize they have...by doing research. The people that don't know, just don't know. No clue. They'll put a $5k price on that domain all day long.

It isn't that a buyer will put it in a tool to "fit their budget". Do we go buy a $50,000 car for only $5,000 because that "fits out budget". No, we go buy a $5,000 car.

If it is a domain worth $50k, the seller shouldn't be selling it for $5k. The buyer has the choice to either buy at $50k, settle for thiink.io for $20k, or save up their pennies for think.com.

You can give me a thousand more examples and screenshots and it wont convince me.

Like you said yourself, doesn't matter what I show you, it will never change your mind. But ego/stubbornness is sometimes the most expensive thing we'll ever own. Expensive, in the form of opportunity cost.

Its like saying look at this sale, ReverseTelephoneDirectory.com selling for 30,000 USD, let me get a 25 letter domain and sell it for 30K. Let me check the appraisal tool first, wow Estibot gives it $31K. I better check Godaddy as well, damn its only $1400. Where do you think Estibot got that figure from?

Probably by cheating, I would guess...

upload_2020-5-21_0-49-5.png

My advice is aimed to new domainers not falling intto the trap of buying a name based on an automated tool value.

I agree with this, you should definitely have a few months of experience before buying any domains (whether based on a tool, or advice in any form). Always buy with caution, and base your purchases off your own proven results.




Rule #1 of domaining:

Never use automated appraisal tools.

Seriously, they just pick random numbers. Dont waste your time with them. Email some end-users and thats how you'll find out how much its worth.

Nameworth? The valuer who gives you prices 10 time higher than everywhere else.

They're all majorly flawed.

Best one is GoDaddy's by far.


Since you, josh, and stub are my biggest critics on here, never used the tool, and are all at a pro level of verified sales, I invite you to try it at my expense. I'll extend a free Gold plan to all 3 of you for a month. ("Free" for you, but the data will actually cost me about $12-14 per account) So essentially, I'll pay $36-42 for all of you to use it for the month.

Run your domains through that you feel have value, and look at the results. If it tells you 40% of your domains are worth $20,000+, it doesn't mean that you need to price it at that level. Price them at $9,500, or double their current value and see if anything happens.

If it does, awesome. Everyone wins. If not, bump them back down later.

Just give it a fair shake. That's all I'm asking.

Even if you already have higher prices on your domains, still worth a try.

Worst case...it will save you hours of time identifying if you have the next thiink.com in your existing inventory (...and if you don't want the domain, I'll probably pay you $500 for it) ;)
 
Last edited:
0
•••
Absolutely! Look for yourself... The first time I ran the query was 5/16/2020. Other users ran it before that and sure enough, someone ran it at 11:58:53 on 5/20/2019, just 7 days after the date of the reported sale 5/20/2019. NameWorth doesn't use sales data in any form to inflate domain values. Never has and never will.

Show attachment 155126



I'm not focusing on any one sale. Run any of Mike Mann's sales the second they are reported. It will be about the same.

See the results for Aptum(dot)com in my post above. Same deal. It would completely amaze me if more than 5% of domain investors put a price of $94,000 or more on that domain. Saying people should just do their own research is like saying they'll fix a problem...that they don't realize they have...by doing research. The people that don't know, just don't know. No clue. They'll put a $5k price on that domain all day long.

It isn't that a buyer will put it in a tool to "fit their budget". Do we go buy a $50,000 car for only $5,000 because that "fits out budget". No, we go buy a $5,000 car.

If it is a domain worth $50k, the seller shouldn't be selling it for $5k. The buyer has the choice to either buy at $50k, settle for thiink.io for $20k, or save up their pennies for think.com.



Like you said yourself, doesn't matter what I show you, it will never change your mind. But ego/stubbornness is sometimes the most expensive thing we'll ever own. Expensive, in the form of opportunity cost.



Probably by cheating, I would guess...

Show attachment 155131



I agree with this, you should definitely have a few months of experience before buying any domains (whether based on a tool, or advice in any form). Always buy with caution, and base your purchases off your own proven results.











Since you, josh, and stub are my biggest critics on here, never used the tool, and are all at a pro level of verified sales, I invite you to try it at my expense. I'll extend a free Gold plan to all 3 of you for a month. ("Free" for you, but the data will actually cost me about $12-14 per account) So essentially, I'll pay $36-42 for all of you to use it for the month.

Run your domains through that you feel have value, and look at the results. If it tells you 40% of your domains are worth $20,000+, it doesn't mean that you need to price it at that level. Price them at $9,500, or double their current value and see if anything happens.

If it does, awesome. Everyone wins. If not, bump them back down later.

Just give it a fair shake. That's all I'm asking.

Even if you already have higher prices on your domains, still worth a try.

Worst case...it will save you hours of time identifying if you have the next thiink.com in your existing inventory (...and if you don't want the domain, I'll probably pay you $500 for it) ;)


Good luck man. You keep using it my friend. :xf.smile:
 
0
•••
I'm relatively fresh, but in terms of appraisals I (as many others) use GoDaddy, Epik (free esti without extra flavor, which is the key, I admit) and NameWorth (paid version).

GoDaddy shows similar sales which is very helpful (even though without dates, but if you really interested - namebio particular sale)

Nameworth shows taken extension plus similarly named running businesses/websites. Even though I find prices heavily inflated for most domains, I like tiered structure and at least I can get an idea for how much I can dump this domain

Estibot (which is Epik+extra features) shows some traffic stats I believe, which very valuable as well.

Combining these three helps to at least get an idea if this particular domain is worth handregging or buying at auction/catching.


If Nameworth could only show traffic/seo stats it become the goto place, I love the job they are doing and I don't understand the negativity towards it. If you don't like valuation - use own head, or other services to get median appraisal from all tools, their most values comes from features it provides, at least for now.
 
Last edited:
3
•••
I'm relatively fresh, but in terms of appraisals I (as many others) use GoDaddy, Epik (free esti without extra flavor, which is the key, I admit) and NameWorth (paid version).

GoDaddy shows similar sales which is very helpful (even though without dates, but if you really interested - namebio particular sale)

Nameworth shows taken extension plus similarly named running businesses/websites. Even though I find prices heavily inflated for most domains, I like tiered structure and at least I can get an idea for how much I can dump this domain

Estibot (which is Epik+extra features) shows some traffic stats I believe, which very valuable as well.

Combining these three helps to at least get an idea if this particular domain is worth handregging or buying at auction/catching.


If Nameworth could only show traffic/seo stats it become the goto place, I love the job they are doing and I don't understand the negativity towards it. If you don't like valuation - use own head, or other services to get median appraisal from all tools, their most values comes from features it provides, at least for now.
Like you I take them all into consideration. Nameworth is up and coming, and I especially like their owners responsiveness. As much as anything i use Nameworth for confirmation. For example, i recently registered GourmetSin, a name I'd call my restaurant if my cuisine was so damn good it's sinful. GD appraises the name for $1,447, Free Valuator at $260, the fools at Estibot "O" and Nameworth at $9,450.

Most really good gourmet chef's believe their food is sinful, and as such my outbound strategy is to get GourmetSin in front of some of the top chefs in the industry. Pretty much I'm asking them to put their money where their mouth is:xf.wink:

Also, I use the paid version of Nameworth. I pay $10 a month, but it's worth every penny(y)
 
0
•••
I like Godaddy's appraisal tool as I think that is the only one available with some genuine stats, as of now. I have also been a paying member of Estibot in the past, although the reasoning of their valuation was unreasonable at times. But overall, I believe its the need of the buyer that decides the value of your domain, no bot can evenly justify that.
 
0
•••
Last edited:
0
•••
My favorite are Nameworth and Godaddy. Thanks
 
0
•••
Auctions are the most accurate imo
 
1
•••
Put it on auction and you come to know real value!
 
0
•••
0
•••
0
•••
Yes...they're the ones you want appraising your home "if" you want to get top dollar.
For most hand reg names, I agree that their values certainly represent the most hopeful top dollar value.

For many names purchased of the aftermarket, GD has a tendency to vastly undervalue names.

Nameworth estimates much higher a lot of the time, which is nice, but I find their numbers to be pretty wild for some names.

Best barometer is still your own experience. Develop it.
 
0
•••
0
•••
epik
 
2
•••
Appraise.net

We're social

Spaceship
Domain Recover
NameMaxi - Your Domain Has Buyers
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back