domain Domain Feedback Game: your thoughts on previously posted domain name?

[GoodKindName]

Hey everyone!

What if we could play a game where you post your domain name and someone in the next post will give you quick feedback on it?

I find this idea exciting. That way we can have fun and hopefully learn together!

How to play:

1. Share your thoughts on 1 domain name from the latest post:
   pros, cons & (optionally) appraisal (at least 1 medium-size sentence, of course, you can do longer)
2. Post your domain name you want to get feedback on.

Post example:

Your domain is short and sounds nice but I'm not sure if these 2 words go well together, each of them seems to be related to a different industry, I would price it at $1500​

My domain: D i g i H u b (dot) com​

The Rules:

• You can post up to 3 domains per post for extra choice (but only 1 will be reviewed)
• Only give feedback on the latest posted name (this will ensure everyone gets feedback)
• Every post should contain feedback (use DM, chat & other site functions for other things)
• Convert domains into Google-proof format (example.com >>> e x a m p l e (dot) com)
• If someone's post is strongly breaking the rules feel free to ignore it or report.

If you feel that some rules need to be adjusted please send me a DM (to keep the thread clean and on-point).

A domain you post must be yours or clearly unregistered (owned by others are not allowed). Use anti-Google formatting for unregistered names.

Please, respect others and be nice, give the kind of feedback you would like to receive yourself

So let's go then!

 

[Bob Hawkes]

Thanks for initiative, @GoodKindName! Although I agree with @sircc that perhaps appraisal thread better place, even while understanding that you are trying to do something better. BTW I really like the format of your example, @GoodKindName.

1. So re L e a f y C i t y (.com). I like the positive modern feel of the name, and it could apply to many things (urban gardens, canna, city tree campaigns, tree/shrub service, tree planting service, gardening store, etc.). The two words nicely fit together, and of course passes podcast test and visual appearance memorability test.

When I Google exact term (in quotes) I get 59k results which is pretty decent. Many of them are related to cities that have re-tree programs. While that might well represent a sizeable market for the domain name, odds are that they might instead go for .org (available to hand reg) or even if wanted .com probably have a budget in $$$ range for a domain name, if that. I think canna or gardening service / shop best prospects for selling it in the low /mid $$$$ range.

The fact only one active business on Open Corporates with two-word name somewhat surprising, and that when I checked Dofo not other TLDs in exact term reg. I think the status of exact new extension, i.e. leafy with .city TLD of interest. I see it is registered but not obviously for sale or used. I would probably price low $$$$ but set the minimum offer quite low, and use offers and visits to help determine if a long hold is worthwhile. BTW the term leafy by itself is heavily registered, which is a positive.

2. OK by the rules as I understand them, I will now post one of my names for comment:
L o w C o n t a c t (.com)
I saw it as either consulting/services for low contact retail, etc., or low contact sports expertise re safety, gear like helmets, etc. Other possibilities perhaps in mediation or legal fields, but a definite stretch there. Welcome opinions!

Bob

PS As one clarification to rules, @GoodKindName I think you should explicitly state that people should only ask for feedback on names they currently own. I think most would just assume this, but clearly it is unfair to list for feedback someone else's name.

 

[GoodKindName]

Thanks to everyone who joined this thread. It looks like we see a lot of great feedback here!
At the same time, I want to emphasize the importance of playing by the rules. Without them this thread can quickly become a pointless mess. Please, follow the rules, there are not many of them

My Domain names:
U P R U (dot) com
T e c h n o z i n e (dot) com
U J L E (dot) com

Thank you for your post, Haroon.
I would like to gently ask you to reread the rules. Any post in this thread should contain feedback on the name from the previous post. Your post is breaking this rule as you ignored the previous person's domains and just posted yours. I hope we can all respect each other here and treat fairly by following a few rules. Thank you!

"One more likely fair and beneficial rule is added: give feedback only on the latest posted name (not on any from the thread). This will ensure that everyone gets feedback and is not ignored. Hope it helps to make things more fair!"

You quoted this but didn't read it apparently.

Thank you for noting this, KingZee, you are totally right. Thank you very much for your feedback, Domain Services Corp. But it's important to understand that we will build a fair and useful thread only if everyone follows the rules. Besides, there are just a few of them and they are simple.

Uk (link)
Great name for a logistics company, warehouse, drop shipping,travel company providing Uk oriented services.

Not sure of value.

My domains
Pioneerism (king) startup related?
ChargingEasy (king)
Typifies (King)

Your names were ignored, James, sorry about that. I will try to provide some feedback.
I'd pick P i o n e e r i s m for review.

I think it's an interesting name. The good: the word has a positive meaning. Also, the dot net version in active use by an Arabic conference. They can be potential end-user. On the downside, the word is a bit too long, not so easy to pronounce, and is rarely used. There are just 2 extensions taken which is typical for rare words. I would price it low-mid XXXX.

^ CupidForum is great, I see it work as a nice love related social forum. Since other domains like petsforum metalforum and musicforum sold for low xxxx$, it could fetch that price for the end user.

My domains :

niink
nameCM

both dot coms.

I will try to provide some feedback on your name since your domains were ignored.
I'm choosing N i i n k
This name is pronounceable, it contains only western premium letters, it's got some meaning although it's quite neutral (means "so" in Estonian according to Google), there is a music artist who might be interested in this domain but he doesn't seem to be very active recently. On the downside, this domain is taken only in 1 extension which suggests there is not a lot of value, also it's not very clear how to pronounce it, niin construction looks overloaded. I would price it like a regular made-up brandable, somewhere from 500$ to 3K$.

Okay, looks like we have 1 name left and I would like to paste it here instead of mine.
I know it breaks the rule "A domain you post must be yours" but I think this is a fair exception since the person himself posted this domain for feedback in this thread. I'm just repeating it to make this thread more fair.

It's from Domain Services Corp:
V i r t u a l P a y m e n t (dot) org

 

[Way3]

2. OK by the rules as I understand them, I will now post one of my names for comment:
L o w C o n t a c t (.com)
I saw it as either consulting/services for low contact retail, etc., or low contact sports expertise re safety, gear like helmets, etc. Other possibilities perhaps in mediation or legal fields, but a definite stretch there. Welcome opinions!

L o w C o n t a c t (.com) Could see that having excellent potential in a 2020 (and beyond) social distancing world. A low contact device? A municipal or regional plan for lowering close contact when social distance rules are in place. A low contact workplace. Travel plans. Other seating arrangement. The possibilities are boundless. Great domain.

My long shot, could use feedback domain is: U n f i a t e d (.com) - hand reg earlier this year, needless to say, have been market obsessed these past few months. See it as being tied to digital/crypto push.

To help the next poster stay within the nice rules (and you think my other domain name is cr@p, don't sweat it, lol), I also recently reg'd G o Y o l k (.com/.net). There's the obvious food use, but also thought of the yolk of a nest egg, as in a strong retirement plan... Dunno may be a stretch, Mind of a Domainer (could be a sitcom).

Thanks for the thread.

 

[GoodKindName]

Thanks for initiative, @GoodKindName! Although I agree with @sircc that perhaps appraisal thread better place, even while understanding that you are trying to do something better. BTW I really like the format of your example, @GoodKindName.

1. So re L e a f y C i t y (.com). I like the positive modern feel of the name, and it could apply to many things (urban gardens, canna, city tree campaigns, tree/shrub service, tree planting service, gardening store, etc.). The two words nicely fit together, and of course passes podcast test and visual appearance memorability test.

When I Google exact term (in quotes) I get 59k results which is pretty decent. Many of them are related to cities that have re-tree programs. While that might well represent a sizeable market for the domain name, odds are that they might instead go for .org (available to hand reg) or even if wanted .com probably have a budget in $$$ range for a domain name, if that. I think canna or gardening service / shop best prospects for selling it in the low /mid $$$$ range.

The fact only one active business on Open Corporates with two-word name somewhat surprising, and that when I checked Dofo not other TLDs in exact term reg. I think the status of exact new extension, i.e. leafy with .city TLD of interest. I see it is registered but not obviously for sale or used. I would probably price low $$$$ but set the minimum offer quite low, and use offers and visits to help determine if a long hold is worthwhile. BTW the term leafy by itself is heavily registered, which is a positive.

2. OK by the rules as I understand them, I will now post one of my names for comment:
L o w C o n t a c t (.com)
I saw it as either consulting/services for low contact retail, etc., or low contact sports expertise re safety, gear like helmets, etc. Other possibilities perhaps in mediation or legal fields, but a definite stretch there. Welcome opinions!

Bob

PS As one clarification to rules, @GoodKindName I think you should explicitly state that people should only ask for feedback on names they currently own. I think most would just assume this, but clearly it is unfair to list for feedback someone else's name.

I highly appreciate your feedback here, Bob, it's glorious!
Agreed with you on the rules, it surely can do more harm than good to review names by others.

Now rules state that only member-owned and clearly unregistered names are allowed. Owned by someone else are not allowed.

One more likely fair and beneficial rule is added: give feedback only on the latest posted name (not on any from the thread). This will ensure that everyone gets feedback and is not ignored. Hope it helps to make things more fair!

L o w C o n t a c t (.com) Could see that having excellent potential in a 2020 (and beyond) social distancing world. A low contact device? A municipal or regional plan for lowering close contact when social distance rules are in place. A low contact workplace. Travel plans. Other seating arrangement. The possibilities are boundless. Great domain.

My long shot, could use feedback domain is: U n f i a t e d (.com) - hand reg earlier this year, needless to say, have been market obsessed these past few months. See it as being tied to digital/crypto push.

To help the next poster stay within the nice rules (and you think my other domain name is cr@p, don't sweat it, lol), I also recently reg'd G o Y o l k (.com/.net). There's the obvious food use, but also thought of the yolk of a nest egg, as in a strong retirement plan... Dunno may be a stretch, Mind of a Domainer (could be a sitcom).

Thanks for the thread.

Thank you for your contribution, Way3. Really good feedback!

I like your idea to allow the next person some choice if he's not sure what to say about a certain name. I think it would be a good idea to bring in this change to the rules: 3 domain names are allowed per post but feedback will be given only to one of them. Not sure what is downside of this rule yet but so far sounds useful. Everyone, please send me your suggestions & criticism regarding the rules via DM or incorporate them into your feedback post. Thank you!

FEEDBACK:
For my feedback, I've chosen G o Y o l k.
I think this name is a really interesting one. After some quick research of most used extensions, I can tell that many companies are happily using "Yolk" as their brand. I don't see any specific industry among them, it's quite universal which is great. Prefix "Go" is often preferred when one-word option is unreachable. So I believe this name has good potential! It's cool you were able to hand-reg it, congrats.

MY NAMES:
L o a d F l y (dot) com
G i k l a (dot) com
W e (dot) P h o t o s

Choose just one for feedback

 

[NameWell]

My Domain names:
U P R U (dot) com
T e c h n o z i n e (dot) com
U J L E (dot) com

U P R U (dot) com - That's a strong pronounceable four letter domain name. I love that it starts with a real dictionary word "up". It's a strong, positive and popular keyword that can be suitable for various businesses. I agree with your decision to list this name on a brandable marketplace because it definitely is brandable. I visited the landing page and the price seems relevant. One thing I didn't like is the logo. I think it's really weak and may repel potential buyers. If there is such an option I suggest asking for logo redesign.


Mine: DoctorInstantly dot com

 

[nameCM]

^ CupidForum is great, I see it work as a nice love related social forum. Since other domains like petsforum metalforum and musicforum sold for low xxxx$, it could fetch that price for the end user.

My domains :

niink
nameCM

both dot coms.

 

[iKhalyfah]

Cheap On Web.com

Cheap On Web.com definitely from the name, it invokes eCommerce, and it seems unique, you know, getting it cheaper than anywhere else (both on/off web). I like it

My domains

*Hey Bre wery .com
* Te le Gra duation .com (with all the online graduations due to the pandemic
* Box e sy .com

 

[ivey]

CupidForum.... when i think of cupid i naturally think of love or dating. But i rarely ever hear about forums for this. Dating sites seems more common. But it's anywhere from xxx to low xxx imo

 

[Andry ramadhan]

I like this domain name because it includes relevant words and follows the current era of virtual payments that can be a problem of credit cards, debit, and financial matters that add a high level of trust for banking sites, payment instruments, and business of course.

V i r t u a l P a y m e n t (dot) org is very suitable price $$$$, my opinion hopefully means. thank you

My domain :
A D L K(dot)us
X X I K U(dot)com
F I L M H D 2 1(dot)com

 

[GoodKindName]

I like this domain name because it includes relevant words and follows the current era of virtual payments that can be a problem of credit cards, debit, and financial matters that add a high level of trust for banking sites, payment instruments, and business of course.

V i r t u a l P a y m e n t (dot) org is very suitable price $$$$, my opinion hopefully means. thank you

My domain :
A D L K(dot)us
X X I K U(dot)com
F I L M H D 2 1(dot)com

Looks like all these domains are leading to the same ongoing business, an ad-driven movie streaming site. Personally I don't see much value in the domains themselves. I wouldn't price them higher than mid - high XXX. But you can try to sell these developed sites for some good money. Flippa may work for you. Since we are doing domain feedback here, there is really nothing else I can say. Wish you the best of luck!

My domains:
M e d i o H u b
W h e y H u b
V e s t a C i t y
(all in .com)
Pick just 1 for feedback

 

[bomb2060]

@GoodKindName (this can be a good $xxxx name!!)

VestaCity

• Vesta is easy to remember.
• Easy to pronounce.
• Highly brandable.
• Obviously short
• Am seeing it being picked by a movie or series production. Where the characters live in vesta city.
• Consider developing and flipping as a website.
• I would hold on to it and only give out at $xxxxx or thereabouts.

What do you say about My domains (newly acquired here)

LaptopsGuide.com
CheapOnWeb.com​

 

[GoodKindName]

I like vesta city domain because of its a relevant and core keyword of Vesta City in the US. I think its valuable domains to Vesta Business who would try to promote his or her business in a specific city.
Tough I m new to NamePros and domain flipping.

My domains:
S i t e r a z o r [DOT] Com
T r a d i n g P i t c h [DOT] Com
O u r L i f e C l a s s [DOT] Com

Thanks for your feedback but I'd like to point out that according to rules, members should provide feedback only on domain name from the latest post. In your case, names from iKhalyfah.

S i t e r a z o r [DOT] Com
This name sounds good, clearly pronounceable. The number of taken extensions is just 1 which shows this name is an average brandable and not something many people interested in. Also, according to Namebio, domain with Razor as a 2nd word sell very rarely. The meaning of the name is not too clear to me but I would imagine it would work well for anything related to web-development. I can see it's now actively used as a blog with development-related downloads. You might want to try to sell the site as a whole, not just domain. When it comes to a pure name value, I would price it somewhere from 1K to 4K.

I think VestaCity .com will be highly valuable. It is a solid 2 words name related to a city name. I like it. Hope the name will be sold to end user.

My domains:
ExpertPocket .com
HongkongDeal .com
KoreanEnergy .com

(Pick just one for feedback)
Thank You All

Hey I appreciate your feedback. But also would like to remind that we should do feedback only on the latest name posted, not on any name from the thread. In your case, it's names from Simanta Saha. This rule ensures that everyone gets feedback and no one is ignored.

E x p e r t P o c k e t (dot) com
This name is easily pronounceable and the words are commonly used. But the combination is a bit odd to me. The meaning is hard to find. I would prefer it to be P o c k e t E x p e r t instead. That would work for a blog or service related to Money management or maybe to various compact gadgets. Pocket is rarely used as a 2nd word. Maybe your name could mean that the Expert's name is Pocket. Anyways, I would price it from 1K to 3K. I might be wrong and maybe missing something.
Your other 2 names, by the way, are better imo

Since iKhalyfah was ignored I will post his domains for review instead of mine:
*Hey Bre wery .com
* Te le Gra duation .com (with all the online graduations due to the pandemic
* Box e sy .com

 

[sircc]

There's already an appraisal thread that's a mile and a half long. You can do everything you mention over there.

 

[Way3]

FEEDBACK:
For my feedback, I've chosen G o Y o l k.
I think this name is a really interesting one. After some quick research of most used extensions, I can tell that many companies are happily using "Yolk" as their brand. I don't see any specific industry among them, it's quite universal which is great. Prefix "Go" is often preferred when one-word option is unreachable. So I believe this name has good potential! It's cool you were able to hand-reg it, congrats.

MY NAMES:
L o a d F l y (dot) com
G i k l a (dot) com
W e (dot) P h o t o s

Thanks for that note and the feedback. Much appreciated!

I really like W e (dot) P h o t o s. I see so much upside in registering non-traditional domains right now (whether other tlds or ngtlds, not everything will be able to be dot com in a burgeoning digital future). Also, and again related in part to our new world in 2020, I think photo sharing will only grow as grandparents are unable to visit with family in a distanced world. Nice one!

(edit - forgot to add three domains)

A few I recently have acquired:

O p t i m a l (.link) Self explanatory I guess

G o t i n E a r l y (.com) Early adoptor investors

P r o f i t i n g (.us) Moving into .us domains lately

 

[thedomainpromoter]

So we restarting? ok, I will just post one of my domains - buymycreativity.com

 

[linuxfreak]

So we restarting? ok, I will just post one of my domains - buymycreativity.com

in first place it looks a great name for all kind of designer people but providing your service rather than selling is more suitable. I mean it's kinda rude. may be buy my shoes would be more preferred on this type domains. Appraisal? I'm not qualify to state an opinion on that matter.

My domain is: m y d o m a i n (dot) biz

 

[jim h]

m y d o m a i n (dot) biz

I think the prefix of this domain name is very good. It is very attractive to many people in the domain name industry, but the suffix quality of this domain name is just average level. The trading volume and price of. Biz do not perform well in all the suffix. All in all, I think the domain name is worth $1000.

Mine: OL.App
USE.tv
UK.link

 

[BrandEntrance.com]

Uk (link)
Great name for a logistics company, warehouse, drop shipping,travel company providing Uk oriented services.

Not sure of value.

My domains
Pioneerism (king) startup related?
ChargingEasy (king)
Typifies (King)

 

[Haroon Basha]

U P R U (dot) com - That's a strong pronounceable four letter domain name. I love that it starts with a real dictionary word "up". It's a strong, positive and popular keyword that can be suitable for various businesses. I agree with your decision to list this name on a brandable marketplace because it definitely is brandable. I visited the landing page and the price seems relevant. One thing I didn't like is the logo. I think it's really weak and may repel potential buyers. If there is such an option I suggest asking for logo redesign.


Mine: DoctorInstantly dot com

Thank you very much @NameWell , I will try to order another Logo design. Thank you for the nice words with regard to UPRU.com

Your domain name DoctorInstantly dot com is more relevant these days than before. Nice choice.

 

[bomb2060]

My Domain names:
U P R U (dot) com
T e c h n o z i n e (dot) com
U J L E (dot) com

T e c h n o z i n e (dot) com

• Short, brandable easy to remember.
• Good for a Technology Magazine.
• High value, technology is a hot niche.
• Grab the .net and .org if they are available.
• I value it at $XXX

My Domains (bought them here recently):

CupidForum.com
ForumNova.com​

*Am ok with Google checking them out

 

[Domain Services Corp]

I highly appreciate your feedback here, Bob, it's glorious!
Agreed with you on the rules, it surely can do more harm than good to review names by others.

Now rules state that only member-owned and clearly unregistered names are allowed. Owned by someone else are not allowed.

One more likely fair and beneficial rule is added: give feedback only on the latest posted name (not on any from the thread). This will ensure that everyone gets feedback and is not ignored. Hope it helps to make things more fair!



Thank you for your contribution, Way3. Really good feedback!

I like your idea to allow the next person some choice if he's not sure what to say about a certain name. I think it would be a good idea to bring in this change to the rules: 3 domain names are allowed per post but feedback will be given only to one of them. Not sure what is downside of this rule yet but so far sounds useful. Everyone, please send me your suggestions & criticism regarding the rules via DM or incorporate them into your feedback post. Thank you!

FEEDBACK:
For my feedback, I've chosen G o Y o l k.
I think this name is a really interesting one. After some quick research of most used extensions, I can tell that many companies are happily using "Yolk" as their brand. I don't see any specific industry among them, it's quite universal which is great. Prefix "Go" is often preferred when one-word option is unreachable. So I believe this name has good potential! It's cool you were able to hand-reg it, congrats.

MY NAMES:
L o a d F l y (dot) com
G i k l a (dot) com
W e (dot) P h o t o s

Choose just one for feedback

We DOT Photos looks like a powerful Brandable domain name to me. As WE can unify lot of family related emotions. You better outbound to the newborn photography startups. Or wedding photography niche. Though it's difficult to appraisal. Fantastic name though.

My domain:
VirtualPayment (dot) org

 

[nameCM]

We DOT Photos looks like a powerful Brandable domain name to me. As WE can unify lot of family related emotions. You better outbound to the newborn photography startups. Or wedding photography niche. Though it's difficult to appraisal. Fantastic name though.

My domain:
VirtualPayment (dot) org

"One more likely fair and beneficial rule is added: give feedback only on the latest posted name (not on any from the thread). This will ensure that everyone gets feedback and is not ignored. Hope it helps to make things more fair!"

You quoted this but didn't read it apparently.

 

[Simanta Saha]

Looks like all these domains are leading to the same ongoing business, an ad-driven movie streaming site. Personally I don't see much value in the domains themselves. I wouldn't price them higher than mid - high XXX. But you can try to sell these developed sites for some good money. Flippa may work for you. Since we are doing domain feedback here, there is really nothing else I can say. Wish you the best of luck!

My domains:
M e d i o H u b
W h e y H u b
V e s t a C i t y
(all in .com)
Pick just 1 for feedback

I like vesta city domain because of its a relevant and core keyword of Vesta City in the US. I think its valuable domains to Vesta Business who would try to promote his or her business in a specific city.
Tough I m new to NamePros and domain flipping.

My domains:
S i t e r a z o r [DOT] Com
T r a d i n g P i t c h [DOT] Com
O u r L i f e C l a s s [DOT] Com

 

[GoodKindName]

Since there are no domains yet, allow me to start

L e a f y C i t y (dot) com