It was already discussed on the forum;
But here are the main points to remember :
An aged domain that never dropped doesn't have more value than a new one
Except if :
- The domain in question has backlinks, domain authority
- Chances of the domain being better than a new reg (due to the domain market, there was more "high quality" domains available back then, and so these might be better than the average hand reg nowadays)
Gube