NameSilo

More .COM propoganda

SpaceshipSpaceship
SpaceshipSpaceship
Namecheap AuctionsNamecheap Auctions
Watch

Premium gTLD

Established Member
Impact
129
0
Close
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
GoDaddyGoDaddy
What in the world are you even talking about?
Domain names and markets.

Do you have some actual numbers to go with that? Because I just took a look at the top 6 selling new gtlds, using Namestat as a source:
I don't use Namestat as a source.

Most of the time Premium gTLD starts a thread on these, it has something to do with .com. Which will always result in a loss. None of these will touch .com.
So?

The other thread you started was about Verisign's budget, you were all excited until someone pointed out it's the same budget they had even before these came out.
Verisign's budget? Care to link that thread?

Regards...jmcc
 
0
Close
Domain names and markets.

I don't use Namestat as a source.

So?

Verisign's budget? Care to link that thread?

Regards...jmcc

You didn't post any numbers or sources or take mine apart. What you said, what I bolded, doesn't go along with the top selling new gtlds. The thread I was talking about - https://www.namepros.com/threads/verisigns-massive-com-net-marketing-effort.887608/#post-5070393

So with this:
"The problem for .COM in competition with the new gTLDs is that many of them are, at their core, US events in that the bulk of their registrations come from the US."

I don't know what you're taking about, that's why I want to see some actual stats, you might be right, just not with the top selling new gtlds.
 
Last edited:
0
Close
0
Close
And where am I posting in that thread?

Regards...jmcc

That was for the threadstarer, not you.

From you, I want to know more about:

"The problem for .COM in competition with the new gTLDs is that many of them are, at their core, US events in that the bulk of their registrations come from the US."

It's not from the top selling new gtlds, at least the top 6. So are you talking about something else? Overall? You could very well be right on that. And if so, can you drop some stats/sources on that. Because the top 6 are China, not U.S. I would be interested in some overall stats by country because I can't find those on the other sites, unless I'm missing it. Just breakdown with each individual new gtld.
 
Last edited:
0
Close
That was for the threadstarer, not you.
In future, please reply to whomever you are replying to rather than trying to reply to everyone on in a single post.

The subsidised and freebie new gTLD numbers are a distraction from the main market where the registration fee is higher. Much of .XYZ is heavily discounted, high churn registration volume. The competition to .COM is from the higher priced registrations in other new gTLDs where there is a kind of lock-in due to the registration fee. Some of these domain names will be renewed because of the registrant's investment. A $1 reg fee domain (or freebie) is a disposable domain for many people. However a >$20 reg fee may not be so disposable. Ordinary registrants don't think like domainers.

It's not from the top selling new gtlds, at least the top 6. So are you talking about something else? Overall? And if so, can you drop some stats/sources on that. Because the top 6 are China, not U.S.
There are more gTLDs than the heavily discounted and highly inflated ones. The Chinese market gTLDs are, not surprisingly, doing well in China.

Regards...jmcc
 
0
Close
Yes, I get all that. You're repeating stuff that has been talked to death on this forum. What I'm not getting are numbers/sources to what you said. Do you actually have any of that, or is what you posted just a feeling. Because I actually posted stats and links to those stats, at least for the top 6. Do you have some overall numbers?
 
0
Close
Yes, I get all that. You're repeating stuff that has been talked to death on this forum. What I'm not getting are numbers/sources to what you said. Do you actually have any of that, or is what you posted just a feeling.
The data is available in the ICANN registry reports and the zonefiles. It takes a lot of expensive work to crunch that data and more to analyse it properly. I'll explain it in simple terms for you.

The velocity of net growth (new registrations - deleted registrations) in .COM had been slowing for a number of years and the monthly net growth had become rather cyclical with large promotions leading to large drops the following year. The Chinese bubble changed things and a lot of the new registrations appeared on Chinese nameservers that have low one year renewal rates. When the historical renewal rates on these hosters' nameservers are checked, there are clear patterns of high non-renewal suggesting discounting/promotions and short-term and speculative registrations.

The .COM has become a legacy TLD in many country level markets. In some the new registrations are just ahead of deletions. This is because the local ccTLDs have overtaken .COM as the dominant TLD in those markets. This means, in simple terms, that .COM is not doing as well as it was in those countries. The one country where .COM completely dominates the market is the US. Got that? Good! This means that the US is the most important country market for the TLD. Any competition in that market is not a good thing for the .COM TLD. The .US ccTLD only has a minor share of the market and is so poorly marketed that it is not a major threat to .COM.

The new gTLDs have a novelty factor. And there are also some US city gTLDs that are getting registrations. At the moment, they are low numbers and they are, based on web usage patterns, (Yes. I have the web usage and development percentages for the new gTLDs.) developing slowly. Other new gTLDs are also getting US registrations. The development of these new gTLDs will be, for most, a slow process but they are part of a switch from the generic to the specific. The generic being the .COM extension and the specific being the niche extension of many of these new gTLDs. Taking these new gTLDs as specific, niche extensions in the ccTLD pattern rather than generic TLDs, means that they will develop as such. They have the capability to focus a lot of specific registrations from .COM. Initially the registrants will have their .COM (or .ccTLD) registration and will point the new gTLD registration to their existing site. But if any of these new gTLDs build serious momentum, that will change and the .COM (or .ccTLD) registrations of the registrants will be pointed to the new gTLD as the primary brand. This is what happens in ccTLD when a country level market moves from the early phase (where .COM dominates) to the ccTLD dominant phase (mature market). It can take years for a market to mature and all new gTLDs are in their early phase. It can take anything from five to twenty years for a market to mature. Some new gTLDs may never break 100K registrations. Others have, despite people thinking that they would not. The advent of the new gTLDs has made the market more complex and has introduced competition for .COM in its "home" market in a way it has not had previously. The .US ccTLD was so poorly marketed that it was never any threat. What has happened with the new gTLDs is that it isn't just a single TLD launch every few years as per BIZ/INFO/MOBI etc but rather competition in from a large number of niche TLDs.

That should be a simple enough explanation for you.

Regards...jmcc
 
1
Close
Nope, still posted no numbers. You either have them or you don't. If you did, I figured you would have posted them by now. Very simple. Overall new gtlds reg numbers, broken down by country.
 
Last edited:
0
Close
Not all brands want to be called Soft.Play

I am sure they would prefer to be called SoftPlay.

Problem with these new gtlds is, they are trying to force another language, when I think english is doing quite well the world over.
 
0
Close
Nope, still posted no numbers. You either have them or you don't. If you did, I figured you would have posted them by now.
The reason I haven't posted them is because there is so much data involved. Excel spreadsheets don't really paste well into forums. Now you are free to go off and throw a few numbers you found on the web into your posts without ever understanding the context of those numbers. It doesn't particularly bother me what you think.

Regards...jmcc
 
1
Close
The reason I haven't posted them is because there is so much data involved. Excel spreadsheets don't really paste well into forums. Now you are free to go off and throw a few numbers you found on the web into your posts without ever understanding the context of those numbers. It doesn't particularly bother me what you think.

Regards...jmcc

I throw around stuff back by data. You posted something where you provided none.

This is very simple, you said:

"The problem for .COM in competition with the new gTLDs is that many of them are, at their core, US events in that the bulk of their registrations come from the US."

That is false if you look at the top selling 6 new gtlds. That's China.

So, I asked if you meant overall. Then you went on and on not actually answering the question. If you don't have the data to back your post up, then you don't have it, so be it. It's just some data I would actually like to see.
 
Last edited:
0
Close
Not all brands want to be called Soft.Play

I am sure they would prefer to be called SoftPlay.
Some of the large brands have applied for their own new gTLDs.

Problem with these new gtlds is, they are trying to force another language, when I think english is doing quite well the world over.
Some do develop their sites in English for a global market but more develop their websites in the local language for the local market. Not all new gTLDs are primarily English language TLDs. (Berlin, Paris, Tokyo, Moscow, the IDN gTLDs etc.)

Regards...jmcc
 
0
Close
.COM propaganda? Please.

How many "news" stories are on popular domain blogs related to new gTLD that are meaningless.
Oh, some tiny company with a crappy .COM switched to a crappy new gTLD.

Who.cares

Brad
 
0
Close
I throw around stuff back by data.
No. You merely engage in Numerology.

That is false if you look at the top selling 6 new gtlds. That's China.
I am not talking about Chinese gTLDs. I am not talking about freebie and $1 reg fee domains. I am talking about full registration fee domains in the US market. These have the capability to change the market for .COM and it is something that formed part of Verisign's testimony in the recently dismissed case against the .XYZ registry.

So, I asked if you meant overall.
I explained the importance of competition to .COM in the US market in simple terms. Do you understand this?

Then you went on and on not actually answering the question. If you don't have the date, then you don't have it, so be it. Not a big deal.
I have the data. As I said, there's rather a lot of it. Would registration volumes and renewal rates mean anything to you?

Regards...jmcc
 
0
Close
Numerology? Those aren't real numbers?

I have the data. As I said, there's rather a lot of it. Would registration volumes and renewal rates mean anything to you?

Yes, post it. When you post about registrations and what country they're attributed to, I want to see numbers.
 
0
Close
.COM propaganda? Please.

How many "news" stories are on popular domain blogs related to new gTLD that are meaningless.
Oh, some tiny company with a crappy .COM switched to a crappy new gTLD.
Gets a bit tedious after a while. There is a blatent marketing angle in that many of these companies think that they can get a PR boost from these press releases. It happens with every new TLD launched.

Regards...jmcc
 
1
Close
0
Close
0
Close
You just said you had the data but then post links elsewhere. Post the date here, so everybody can see. Data backing up your post.
Obviously not familiar with ICANN or its monthly registry reports. That's the raw data on registrations that I mentioned along with the zonefile data. Or didn't you realise that the registries submit their transaction data to ICANN and ICANN publishes it?

Regards...jmcc
 
0
Close
This is just noise.

You're providing no value.
 
0
Close
AIVikingsAIVikings

We're social

Escrow.com
Spaceship
Domain Recover
CryptoExchange.com

NamePros updates

Search: choose where to search from the All tab
Open the search at the top of any page. On the All tab, the list next to the search box lets you choose where to search: everything, all...
AIVikings
Catchy
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back