Just curious...

Namecheap AuctionsNamecheap Auctions
SpaceshipSpaceship
Namecheap AuctionsNamecheap Auctions
Watch

How many domains would you keep if renewal cost was $100?

  • This poll is still running and the standings may change.
  • Less than 10 - most of mine is junk but i'll keep a handful of great ones I own

    5 
    votes
    27.8%
  • Less than 100 but more than 10 for sure - I have a decent number of high-value names

    8 
    votes
    44.4%
  • I'll keep most of mine and that's definitely more than 100 - I own tons of premium domains

    2 
    votes
    11.1%
  • I'll drop all, quit business and will never vote for Obama again

    3 
    votes
    16.7%
  • This poll is still running and the standings may change.

4pm

userTop Member
Impact
2,291
Imagine for a second that ICANN decides to change the game. No matter why, let it be US budget deficit or China bought ICANN, whatever..

Starting tomorrow all TLDs (including ccTLDs, all countries except North Korea followed the trend for some unknown but probably political reasons - we dont really care) will cost you $100 to reg or renew any name.

Effective immediately and you need to pay the difference for current year as well.

Assume no upfront cash needed - there's 0% loan facility in place so you may pay all fees at the end of your registration period, lets call it postpaid pricing plan.

You must drop names you dont want to pay for by tomorrow morning by visiting your registrar account and doing some clicking around voodoo as usual

I'm curious to know how many of your domains you would keep then?
How would $500 per name impact your answer ?



Important: developed/parked domains making $100 or more in a year do not count. Only bare old good plain domains with few occasional dollars in parking revs is what of interest :)





thanks in advance for your input



*
 
Last edited:
1
Close
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
GoDaddyGoDaddy
sdsinc - thanks, that what i was most interested in - your "half of the inventory" tells me a lot.
At $100/year, even decent domains that could sell for mid- or high-$$$ become too risky :)
Remember that turnover is very low, I am happy if I move 5% of inventory every year. The rest has to be renewed, that hurts :guilty:

any non-coms among them if i may ask?
Yes, quite a few ccTLDs.
 
1
Close
assuming you've got cash to keep all but you can do the math and are being rational) vs all you currently have
if money is not an issue, then everyone would have kept their domains. The only reason why people drop their domains, is because it's bleeding money every year when it doesn't sell.

The answers you are getting from this poll, are very misleading. Anyone could say they would keep 10 domains for $1,000. But again, you are referring to "average domainer" like you said. This means, our premium domains are still speculative with no guarantee to sell in a year. Every year it doesn't sell, you have to recover the loss to break even. Even if money is not an issue, you still need to catch up with the yearly losses by adding them to your asking price until your domains get so expensive, nobody wants to buy them anymore.

And you end up bankrupt. Which means, whatever you said in this poll in the beginning (like i would keep 10 domains because they are premium, and so on), actually doesn't make any sense in reality.
 
1
Close
You need to factor in the obvious.

The lowball end user offer now has to start at $100 and not $10.

That said I'm not interested in this business now - I just hang out here to be a pain.
 
1
Close
lets define a rational market strategy first. there can be different ones but we take one that would probably apply to most domainers with mid-size average quality portfolio.

if i have say 100 domains i would probably keep renewing all that i consider sellable for at least mid $xxx in a reasonable (lets take 5 years) period of time with reasonable probability of 50%. meaning i expect to sell 50 names over 5 years for average $500 each. which yields 10 names per year that would result in $5,000 yearly sales. after paying 100 x $10 = $1,000 in renewals i pocket $4,000 in profit which is fine ROI
now factor in our $100 fee - that's 100 x $100 = $10,000 making the whole thing a money-losing business burning cash at $5,000 a year rate. to keep us alive and profitable (we are still rational right?) we need to sell every name for at least $1,000 on average. we know that not all our names would ever sell that high so we need to drop those that we would not expect to sell higher than $1,000 in the same reasonable time frame..

the math is simple and that is not what it's all about. interesting part (to me) is how many of your domains you'd keep based on the above as this would tell a lot about your own subjective self-appraisal ... thats what i meant. plus what tlds besides com is a technical question indeed

you can tweak numbers as you like - some have 10 vs 1 year investment horizon, some have 10,000 vs 10 domains etc. ..does not matter much, all assunptions are subjective and are only estimations like sale probability or reasonable price.

but if you were to decide what to keep and what to drop by tomorrow you'd have to come up with a real numbered list of names ..how many names would you have in your list (in percents of your total current holdings) ?







on a side note, that would be a long-awaited death of "mini-sites", automated wordpress blogs, "i have a site too" pages - all that spammy stuff littering the net... how cool that'd be mmmm - clear and bright adsense-less internet full of relevant fast clean sites serving no 100Kb buggy jquery plugins and myriads "Like it fast", "Subscribe to my farts", "Follow me deep inside", "Love me gently", "Take me in the fridge" buttons on every page top, bottom, left and right that are the only elements to utilize those scripts... just dreaming but nice side effect anyways
 
Last edited:
0
Close
how many names would you have in your list (in percents of your total current holdings)

top of my head, excluding all developed names? 10%
 
1
Close
I have more than 100 names, but i couldn't afford to keep them if the reg. and renewal will at high of $100. In that case i will only keep 5-10 names which i treassured most, my twins twinsers, and my name .com. Then domaining will become a hobby and just a simple past time. I may relocate myself to a remote area where internet connection does not exist, where life is simpler. But the good thing is, one of my domain may become too popular (Ass-Holes (dot) com!!! Just Kidding.
 
1
Close
I have more than 100 names, but i couldn't afford to keep them if the reg. and renewal will at high of $100. In that case i will only keep 5-10 names

..that does not answer the question - if you could afford to keep all 100 would you still keep them assuming you behave rationally and only buy/reg domains for profit?

if you say yes that would mean your own assessment of your portfolio is quite high and you probably consider all your names premium class $x,xxx items... modern physics does not forbid that, no problem :)


*
 
0
Close
I think that it's hard enough to get an accurate assessment from a 3rd party looking in (everyone has a different evaluation method), let alone asking someone to appraise their own names (with sentimental value now in play - E.G. my names are better than everyone elses and I can't believe blah blah got offered xxx when mine only got offered x persona).

To put it in perspective, take a look at the appraisal forum. I'm sure you'll find an ample amount of threads where members disagreed with veterans on value for names that may be similar to: TwistedMetalsAreCold.info (veteran = Sorry $0 value, get your money back Vs. Poster: What? you're crazy man, this is worth at least $1k, learn how to appraise!).. lol :P - {Insert laughter here}

Just saying, It's hard to get any accurate statistics asking people to appraise their own domains. ;)

Eric Lyon
 
1
Close
Just saying, It's hard to get any accurate statistics asking people to appraise their own domains
Eric Lyon

that's the purpose - how high peope value their own domains, not how good they are in the eyes of estibots or other domainers or in terms of "real market value" (still not sure if it even exists)



*
 
0
Close
That's a tough one. I can remember being a teen and my brother wanting to register coupons.com and not being able to afford the $89 a year it cost back then.

It would certainly make for a very different domain market.
 
1
Close
please vote while passing by - it's free and only takes 1 click ($0.00 CPC thou)... and is anonymous!



*
 
0
Close
I'll just keep a handful of great ones. That would be less than 10 names.
 
1
Close
DomainEasy: white label portfolios are live. Enable yours.

We're social

Escrow.com
Spaceship
Domain Recover
CryptoExchange.com

NamePros updates

Filters for activity feeds
Your news feed, Latest activity, and the activity tab on profiles now have filter buttons: All, Posts, Quick replies, and Other. Your...
AIVikings
Catchy
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back