Dynadot

discuss How ethical is it trying to sell a domain name portraying something it actually isn't?

Spaceship Spaceship
Watch
Okay, let's say we have two neighboring countries. Country A and Country B. They don't have a good relationship and has been in a few wars since the second world war. When social media like twitter came, the people/politicians from both the countries used them to troll each other. Let's assume politicians and the troll army from Country B uses a particular word to refer to Country A on twitter/facebook, which people from Country A finds demeaning. (And to be fair to Country B, the troll army from Country A also uses unparliamentary languages to describe Country B).
Now, a user here uses nice and flashy logos to sell the idea that how the domain with that exact term could be used to target users in Country A. You assume the seller might be uninformed and you point out the fact to him that how it actually is "demeaning" to the potential users of the site if it was to be developed. But the seller wants to sell the domain anyway, with the same marketing message(s).
Now my question is, is it ethical? Aren't you trying to fool people not from Country A and Country B into buying something they can never use it for the purpose the seller described?
By the way, you can't easily find the meaning of the word in the context of Country A/B so easily. Also, to be fair to the seller, the word is a health related acronym and could be developed for such purpose (and in fact there is an Australian site developed using the same term). But my question is related to how he is presenting his domain to the potential buyers.
 
0
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
Hi

But my question is related to how he is presenting his domain to the potential buyers.

no matter how it's presented, if it doesn't appeal to the audience..... then what?

there has to be a connection.

imo....
 
0
•••
Man, it's extremely hard to understand what you are talking about here. Just shoot the name and ask a specific question, related to this name.
You are trying to be super politically correct, but the whole message slips thru...
 
0
•••
The potential buyers nowadays are not stupid , if they dont like the domain and find useless for them , They will not buy it , no matter how the logo looks flashy or attractive etc.. , So it’s not related to ethical .
 
0
•••
This thread is over a year old..... btw
 
1
•••
This thread is over a year old..... btw
Well .. with this new design of namepros and the upgrade they decided to do , it’s expected more confusions to happen 🤨
 
2
•••
1
•••
A domain name doesn't have to have anything to do with what its real meaning is, but it certainly helps. I don't know about trickery or fooling anyone unless there is actual usage like a developed site. It would be the content that I would consider more unethical than anything, like if say someone owned "greenparty (dot com) and was promoting the domain along with its site as like having a political party with lots of climate-conscientious minded folks , except the site was actually geared towards a weekend weed-smoking party or something.

It's really up to the end user to decide what to do with the domain name, the seller just finds the best scenario that may initially connect/appeal to potential buyers for best prospects at selling it.

It would be easier to answer if the OP gave a more concrete example though, than hypothetical because we all know there are no blanket rules when it comes to domain names. There's always gray areas.
 
0
•••

How ethical is it trying to sell a domain name portraying something it actually isn't?​


I see this thread is old, nevermind. In the title it sounds like fraud. However, in a sense that @HotKey pointed out, the end user is the one that ultimately decides. If the domain d/o/g f/u/n is supposed to be sold as a dog training class or activities for dogs, according to your understanding, an end user may just think its a great name for an adult site. They decide, don't overthink. IMO
 
Last edited:
0
•••
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back