Steve said:
Not true, unless we as domainers start positively promoting the extension by developing instead of parking the names and taking the good ones from actual professionals.
Think about it. People would normally move to .pro because the keyword they want in .com is taken. If domainers take those keywords in .pro because they're greedy and they think it will make them a quick buck, they're mistaken. It may pay in the short term to flip some of these names to other speculators, but there won't be many end users buying .pro unless the extension gains mainstream popularity.
Plenty of excellent keywords were available years after .pro launched, I regged Gadget.pro, Pension.pro, Piano.pro and alot of other strong keywords 3-4 years after .pro was launched. .pro's problem has always been that RegistryPro are selling a substitute product to .com at a premium price with awkward restrictions and virtually no sales channel or promotion.
There are hundreds of thousands of lawyers, dentists and doctors and only one person can own Lawyer.pro, Dentist.pro, and Doctor.pro. RegistryPro own all of those and is not a lawyer, dentist, or doctor. From an SEO angle, it makes more sense for a kidney specialist in Houston to register something keyword dense like HoustonKidneyDoctor.pro than Doctor.pro and I doubt there are more than 4-5 .pros regged with the keyword Doctor in.
The sort of developer who complains that alternative extensions don't get developed because keywords aren't available will most likely be developing multiple low rent SEO optimised PPC ad supported templates running on third party code that add little value. All they are doing is parking with a few more bells and whistles on. If you are serious about developing, you are going to start with an idea and buy the best .com you can afford for the job.
Not being able to register single word generic .coms didn't stop YouTube, MySpace, FaceBook, Yahoo, eBay or Google becoming successful and it wouldn't stop anybody from making it with a 2 word .pro if they had the skills.
At least 95% of .pros are held by speculators of some kind, either people speculating on resale or future development potential. That is nothing to be ashamed of. Domainers are the only people marketing .pro, they contact businesses and make them aware of .pro, that's more than RegistryPro has ever done.
.pro doesn't get developed because RegistryPro continue to exploit registrants with unjustifiably inflated reg fees, they block typically unlicensed web developers and designers from owning a .pro, and they don't promote the extension so hardly anybody outside of domaining circles has heard of it, that makes it difficult for a business to use it.