Buying domains at spaceship.com is an violation of your Marketplace agreement?
After reading your posts, I think I understand what happened.
1. You bought some domains from DropCatch
2. You tried to add them to your Spaceship account
3. Spaceship's verification process failed preventing you from listing the domains
4. You found the current listings for the domains via Spaceship
and bought them via Spaceship
So, you knew that the domains could not be delivered by the person who had previously listed them (because you already own them) but you bought them anyway.
What's funny is, as I was writing this post out, I realised, this sounds a lot like the scam someone has been trying to run on me. I'm not a dumbass so I didn't fall for it but maybe it's you? I'd even considered writing a post about it just in case other people would be interested to learn about it.
The scam is quite simple:
1. An investor (victim) owns a domain name and has it listed with Spaceship
2. The victim allows the domain name to expire
3. The domain goes to auction and a scammer purchases the domain name
4. The scammer lists the domain name with GoDaddy or Sedo or ... with a Buy It Now price less than the previous listing
5. The scammer purchases the domain via the victim's old Spaceship listing
6. The victim now feels they have an arbitrage opportunity, they can buy back their domain from the new owner and sell it to the scammer for profit
e.g:
1. I own example.com and have it listed with Spaceship for sale at $12k
2. I let example.com expire
3. The scammer buys example.com at auction
4. The scammer lists the domain for sale at GoDaddy for $2,500 Buy It Now
5. The scammer goes to Spaceship and buys the domain for $12k
At this point, the victim receives an email that they have sold a domain for for $12k! Yay! And then, oh no, they realise that the domain has expired and left the redemption period. But, they're in luck! The new owner has listed it for sale for $2,500 via GoDaddy. Sure, $2,500 is
a lot more than it is worth but a lot less than $12,000! And so the victim buys back their own domain to sell to the scammer for $12k... and then the scammers payment to Spaceship fails, leaving the victim with a $2,500 domain they bought via GoDaddy.
(A variant of the scam involves lease-to-own, i.e: if the old Spaceship listing has an LTO option, the scammer can buy the domain by paying for one month
and let the payment succeed so long as their Buy It Now price via GoDaddy is less than the one month LTO price.)
Now, I wouldn't accuse you personally of doing this to me, heaven forbid, but I have 3 failed Spaceship purchases for the same domain from the same person on June 29th trying to run this scam. Fortunately for me, I'm a cynic who always wants to understand
why something is happening, and it didn't pass the sniff test that suddenly someone would want to buy the domain from me the day after I no longer had access to it. Remember the mantra, you can't con an honest man. The registrar was GoDaddy not DropCatch so the facts don't match exactly... maybe you're just one of many running the scam.
Regardless of whether you are my scammer or not, I'm glad Spaceship bans people who buy listings they know cannot be delivered. Obviously it is nefarious behaviour and the TXT verification excuse is hilariously bad.
Thanks Spaceship, I appreciate you.
edit: haha, wait, I think it might
actually be you. Your name is Jack and you're Chinese. My buyer was Jack and Chinese. I guess it makes sense that you'd be doing it to other people too, hence the DropCatch discrepancy. Small world, nice to see you here.