Review needed for 3 forum skins

[Pixel-Industry]

I recently created 3 forum skins and cant decide which one is best. Which shall i use?

Forum Skin 1
(Suns and Globe image will be changed to our logo in the future)

Forum Skin 2 (navigation is temporary)

Forum Skin 3

Keep in mind this is for (yet another) web development community. Which one would people like to see best?

 

[JuggernautH]

All three are quite nice, but the color choices on this one is very nice and i think that layout with the "Site of the week" part on the left could prove to be a very nice layout that's easy navigateable as well as pleasant for the eyes.

If you dont intend to use that one i'd be happy to buy it if you dont want to much for it

 

[Pixel-Industry]

hmm thanks for the review would you want it skinned or just the psd?

 

[JuggernautH]

Just the psd in that case

 

[Pixel-Industry]

hmmm not sure if we are gonna use or not it all depends on what people think but if we dont ill give you the .psd for 400 NP$

 

[JuggernautH]

Well okay, i'm 100% sure i want the layout in that case. Pm me directly if you dont intend to use it

 

[Pixel-Industry]

oK NP thanks for your interest

 

[dojo]

The third is better. Don't use the lemon .. it's on e107 default skin

 

[Pixel-Industry]

You mean the lime? haha Thanks for the input.

 

[Mike]

1 and 3 are the best. 3 is more dynamic while 1 is more compact. I'd go for more dynamic, but that may just be my personal preference.

 

[Brandon Sheley]

3 is the best, but it's the only one that looks finished.
400 for just a psd ? Ouch

 

[JuggernautH]

Loco that was NP$ he said

 

[BrewerFan]

All of them are quite good but I prefer number two. The first one's header is a bit bland and the top buttons don't quite match the overall theme. The thing I liked about the second one was it's simplicity, much like NamePros. The last one wasn't bad but I have seen that stock photo from SXC quite a bit. Also, the color scheme clashed a bit.

 

[mknapper1]

i really like the third one... although i have seen the stock photo quite a bit as well but that shouldn't be too hard to change... the first one was good. it was simple and very bold... second one was just way too simple for my tastes but ... i would say that the third one is your best bet if you change the lime

 

[mav]

The third is the best, very nice!

 

[JuggernautH]

If you dont intend to use one of them i'd like to buy the one for thesame price as for the other one i bought from you If possible