For me the only issue I have is the theme and background colour, choices. Sport is a lively, energetic,vibrant activity, therefore I feel your choice of colours should really reflect this. Everything else works very well, I feel.
Nice and simple.
Suggestions:
1. Top 5 stats is better to be relocated to the upper half of the front page. (senior members would like to check that section for news and hot topics).
2. Top 5 stats contains too many columns. I suggest to take the 'Top posters' away, since not many member would have interests in that section.
3. the logo is a little bit colorful. Simple and handy is the best.