.... I did not see the point in listing on Afternic if they don’t get really listed on Godaddy auctions.
I'm naive about Godaddy... Why care about Godaddy auctions. Do you put domains in auction to sell them (instead of using buy now or make offer)?
Normally I don't use auctions. I use make offer and BIN method (without fast transfer, usually make offer). Auction method is complicated, it has a start time, end time, needs a reserve, what to do if there are no bids, what to do after auctions expire, why should more than one (or zero) person bid etc. It is a complicated time wasting method. We don't know when a potential buyer will be an active buyer, and inviting doesn't help, so starting an auction which will last, say, 1 week, will bring no bids even if there 1000 potential buyers (all inactive and can't be activated). Sedo auctions bring no new bidders even if I invite perfectly matching companies .
..........
I think Godaddy has two faces. Godaddy for endusers, Afternic for domainers. If you want to sell to endusers, you need to make sure people using Godaddy see your domains/prices. This doesn't happen always. and I can't even check if this is the case, because when I search for any domain I see a man consisting of two legs and one arm walking while holding
WWW , it is like showing midfinger... What if domain is listed on Afternic but doesn't appear on Godaddy, Godaddy , probably (I suspect) plays middleman role, by making price request at Afternic , or bidding at Sedo, or Dan; whenever there is an inquiry. When I respond to price request, the buyer is informed, but the buyer is Godaddy itself, so it doesn't help much.
I suspect most of my sales are to flippers.. I asked a flipper here a question, he couldn't answer, almost confirming my suspicions. Flippers get a list of active buyers from somehwhere and start lowballing elsewhere, sweet spot is 200 USD. Above 200 is no-no. Something between 20-150 will probably work and only for a limited time, because then actual buyers will disappear. Also these midbuyers always request invoice (for legal protection, just in case their scam is detected?), while actual buyers never do. To me this is the single most important problem in domaining.
(it can work in reverse, I mean, to our advantage as well (happened once), I told them (AN) my asking price, they took it as floor instead of BIN, and sold for a higher price..)
Marketplaces seem to be trying to minimize selling price on seller side, and who knows maybe increase selling price on the buyer side, otherwise minimizing selling price doesn't make any sense.