NameSilo

Egypt... copyrighting ancient ruins

Spaceship Spaceship
Watch

DNQuest.com

Established Member
Impact
65
Though not related to domains, this is still pretty sad. My favorite part is when they complain the Luxor (Vegas) get more visitors that Luxor (city). Money, the root of all happiness...


http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5hGhJUxebdPsEOUZ3O5S8f_6VhHww


Egypt to copyright pyramids

CAIRO (AFP) โ€” In a potential blow to themed resorts from Vegas to Tokyo, Egypt is to pass a law requiring payment of royalties whenever its ancient monuments, from the pyramids to the sphinx, are reproduced.

Zahi Hawass, the charismatic and controversial head of Egypt's Supreme Council of Antiquities, told AFP on Tuesday that the move was necessary to pay for the upkeep of the country's thousands of pharaonic sites.

"The new law will completely prohibit the duplication of historic Egyptian monuments which the Supreme Council of Antiquities considers 100-percent copies," he said.

"If the law is passed then it will be applied in all countries of the world so that we can protect our interests," Hawass said.

He said that a ministerial committee had already agreed on the law which should be passed in the next parliamentary session, while insisting the move would not hurt Egyptian artisans.

"It is Egypt's right to be the only copyright owner for these monuments in order to benefit financially so we can restore, preserve and protect Egyptian monuments."

However, the law "does not forbid local or international artists from profiting from drawings and other reproductions of pharaonic and Egyptian monuments from all eras -- as long as they don't make exact copies."

"Artists have the right to be inspired by everything that surrounds them, including monuments," he said.

Asked about the potential impact on the monumental Luxor Hotel in the US gambling capital of Las Vegas, Hawass insisted that particular resort was "not an exact copy of pharaonic monuments despite the fact it's in the shape of a pyramid."

On its website, the luxury hotel describes itself as "the only pyramid shaped building in the world," but Hawass said its interior was entirely different from an ancient Egyptian setting.

Hawass's declarations came after the opposition daily Al-Wafd published an article on Sunday called for the Las Vegas hotel to pay a slice of its lodging and gambling profits to the city of Luxor.

"Thirty-five million tourists visit Las Vegas to see the reproduction of Luxor city while only six million visit the real Egyptian city of Luxor," the paper lamented.

Samir Farag, head of Luxor town council in southern Egypt, home to the legendary Valley of the Kings, said that it would be difficult to prohibit use of pyramid shapes.

"We can't forbid people from using the name of Luxor and copying monuments from (Luxor) city, which is the world's richest city for monuments," he said, adding that "tourists going to Las Vegas doesn't affect our city's business."
 
0
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
.US domains.US domains
I think it`s pretty fair.

Would you like copies of the Statue of Liberty everywhere?
 
0
•••
italiandragon said:
I think it`s pretty fair.

Would you like copies of the Statue of Liberty everywhere?

Umm, it is. :)

Maybe New York will see this, pass a law and then sue New York New York in Las Vegas for royalties. Or maybe the Eiffel Tower, or any other landmark that is public domain. This is purely a greed move, they even admit to it.
 
0
•••
DNQuest.com said:
Umm, it is. :)

Maybe New York will see this, pass a law and then sue New York New York in Las Vegas for royalties. Or maybe the Eiffel Tower, or any other landmark that is public domain. This is purely a greed move, they even admit to it.

The world is becoming a huge whole globalised mess where cultures and ideas worth nothing anymore. All it matters is business , polluting us and the planet , killing eachother , eating poisoned food , living near nuclear waste.....nothing matter.

I`m personally disgusted on how stupid mankind is turning into.
 
0
•••
What about the pyramid on the $1 bill? So does egypt now want a percentage of every dollar printed?

Sillyness hidden behind politicians looking for profits......
 
0
•••
Vegas has a copy of the Statue of Liberty at the New York New York Hotel and Casino.

I want to know how they plan to file this copyright and enforce it. Seems like pure bullshit.

As Phil said...motivated by greed. I can almost entirely ensure you that this move targetted the Luxor hotel and it's billions in revenue. Jealousy has reared it's ugly head once more.
 
0
•••
It might be bs, but it makes good sense to the Egyptians. Its intellectual property, its assets, history, business. If it was owned by the US or UK, they probably would already have been copyrighted. THere's alot of abuse of world relics i've noticed too,m so they are probably just being a bit precautionary. I think they still want their artwork flowing around the world to some extent.
 
0
•••
imho, the last two sentences quite succinctly take the entire article/law apart:

DNQuest.com said:
Samir Farag, head of Luxor town council in southern Egypt, home to the legendary Valley of the Kings, said that it would be difficult to prohibit use of pyramid shapes.

"We can't forbid people from using the name of Luxor and copying monuments from (Luxor) city, which is the world's richest city for monuments," he said, adding that "tourists going to Las Vegas doesn't affect our city's business."
I bet that guy is getting some heated phone calls from the ministerial committee.
 
0
•••
I dont get it egypt is sueing las vegas
 
0
•••
kemjika11 said:
It might be bs, but it makes good sense to the Egyptians. Its intellectual property, its assets, history, business. If it was owned by the US or UK, they probably would already have been copyrighted. THere's alot of abuse of world relics i've noticed too,m so they are probably just being a bit precautionary. I think they still want their artwork flowing around the world to some extent.
Who are the Egyptians going to pay? They did not invent pyramids.

And what gives modern Egyptians any more right to copyright someone else's work than you or me?
 
0
•••
Diabro said:
Who are the Egyptians going to pay? They did not invent pyramids.
Take a look at Wikipedia.

Quoted from "Pyramid" page.

Wikipedia said:
The most famous pyramids are the Egyptian pyramids.

Quoted from "Great Pyramid of Giza" page.

Wikipedia said:
The tallest man-made structure in the world for over 3,800 years, it is sometimes called Khufu's Pyramid or the Pyramid of Khufu.
 
0
•••
Didn't know you could copyright a shape. Well while were at it we can let god copyright the sphere and every time someone uses a sphere they can pay royalties to the church.
 
0
•••
EG.domains said:
Take a look at Wikipedia.

Quoted from "Pyramid" page.



Quoted from "Great Pyramid of Giza" page.
Ummmm...this does not say they were the first...just that they were the biggest and most famous.
 
0
•••
labrocca said:
Vegas has a copy of the Statue of Liberty at the New York New York Hotel and Casino.
There is one in Paris, France too!

And since the original lady was gifted to Americans by the french (completely forgotten... freedom fries anyone?) maybe they should claim copyright.

labrocca said:
Seems like pure bullshit.
Exactly, if works of art come into public domain after xx number of years... I fail to see why ancient monuments need to be copyrighted. The amount of restaurants and hotels worldwide called Taj would make India a rich country if this was allowed.
 
Last edited:
0
•••
italiandragon said:
I think it`s pretty fair.

Would you like copies of the Statue of Liberty everywhere?

I agree!

This causes hatred.
 
0
•••
Appraise.net
Domain Recover
NameMaxi - Your Domain Has Buyers
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the pageโ€™s height.
Back