Difference between 2 sites!

[ecampsite.co.uk]

Hi guys!!
I wondered whether you'd be able to compare 2 different sites that are similar to each other and comment on which has the better features, usability, layout and the overall feel of the sites.
=================
www.ecampsite.co.uk
=================
=================
www.ukcampsite.com
=================
All of your comments are much appreciated!
Cheers,

Craig

 

[tzmartin]

Similar in function, not design or structure. The best feature for both is the "drill down" search map. Of the two, I initially liked ukcampsite.com, but after using both sites for several searches, I was more pleased with depth of content ecampsite.co.uk has. So, my pick is ecampsite.co.uk.

 

[Keral_Patel]

The first one. I liked the clear layout of it and color choice.

Best of luck for the second one. I know you will figure a way our for making it more beautiful.

Thanks.

 

[peter phillips]

I like the first one. Looks better in terms of colors, images and layout. The second one is simple but plain white background and green text color is not looking very attractive.

 

[ecampsite.co.uk]

Hey guys, just want to show you my new design for the homepage, i think its a lot cleaner than the original. It is only an image at the moment, just click on the thumbnail.

New Design

If you like this please can you say and I will change the page on the site!!
Thank you all,
Craig

 

[ecampsite.co.uk]

Here's a slight tweak on my previous design that I showed you, is it better???
EVEN NEWER DESIGN

 

[ecampsite.co.uk]

Just to throw the spanner in the works....
What do you think of this layout, click the link below!

http://img390.imageshack.us/img390/8738/screenshot4lx.png

I really, really like this one, and it is a lot more stable.
Do you like it, (sorry to keep pestering, but I am trying to get this spot on, and only you guys can help me!!) So keep the comments coming!!!
Cheers,
Craig

 

[ecampsite.co.uk]

Ok gone with what I think is a lot better design, it is also more accesible, i.e, can change all the font size, incorporates Access Keys etc.

GREAT DESIGN

Do you prefer???
Let me know!!
Cheers Craig