.tv Valuation Exercise

SpaceshipSpaceship
Namecheap AuctionsNamecheap Auctions
Namecheap AuctionsNamecheap Auctions
Watch

localexperts

Established Member
Impact
50
Put your personal valuation on these GEO DOT TVs. What would you pay if these domains were put up for auction with a $0 reserve price. For this excerise, assume you just won the lottery

Raleigh.TV
StLouis.TV
Houston.TV
Seoul.TV
NewYork.TV
Tokyo.TV
 
0
Close
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
GoDaddyGoDaddy
Yes, assume money is no object. Even then I would only go after the cities I am familiar with (lived in Houston a year and a half, originally from Raleigh, NC). Are these regular or premium renewals? That would affect the price one would be willing to pay. Also, shouldn't we assume certain metrics as to the size of the market based on search volume, penetration due to competing perhaps more established sites, CTR for Adsense/affiliates and resulting revenue per click, product sales, lead generation assumptions. How much additional $$$ will it cost to develop and maintain this site? How quickly can this site organically get to the first page of Google so that it generates organic traffic? Or do you have to resort to Adwords or other traffic sources for an extended period of time because of the large number of competing sites? What other risk factors could alter these assumptions?

Google searches per Adwords keyword tool (Google is ~70%? of search volume)
Houston 30.4 million
Houston, Texas 3.4 million
Houston, TX 3.4 million
hotels houston 1.0 million
other Houston a few million more

Raleigh 7.5 million
Raleigh, NC 2.2 million
Raleigh, North Carolina 550K
Raleigh hotel/s ~670K
other Raleigh another million
 
0
Close
Raleigh.TV - Non Premium
StLouis.TV - Non Premium
Houston.TV - $500/yr
NewYork.TV - less than $200/yr

not sure about the internationals

I'm asking what would YOU pay. Everyone will have different valuations.
 
0
Close
Seoul was regged non premium on the drop and sold for $5000.
 
0
Close
Tokyo? For the fashion alone, several grand. That is one hot city in my opinion. NewYork, the same, it would be impossible to put a number on it. I'm sure you will surprise us with your offers though, looking forward to it, and hang in there until you get the prices you deserve.
 
0
Close
Raleigh & Houston

Given the search volume, if you believe you can get to the first page of Google (SEO superman) perhaps $100K+ for Raleigh and $300K+ for Houston. But given the millions of search results for those words I believe it is likely you will have to invest heavily in development and SEO efforts so you would have to cut those figures accordingly. But I wouldn't write a check without running some assumptions which had the buyoff of experienced individuals/consultants such as yourself.

The owner of MyrtleBeach.com makes a million dollars annually from his site so with the proper development, a decent-size city geo could generate annual revenue well into six figures. How much would you be willing to pay for that? Well, the domain is only one factor in the equation.
 
0
Close
:hi:

I agree with Garp regarding some of the assumptions and associated costs, risks and unknowns ... but with regard to the question; I'm asking what would YOU pay. Everyone will have different valuations ... if I had a specific need or was looking to otherwise potentially acquire Geo .TV's within the US (with definite and defined development objectives!), I would likely offer the following; :gl:

Raleigh.TV - Perhaps up to Low - Mid $Xxx (based on non premium rewewal fees).
StLouis.TV - Maybe in the vicinity of Mid - High $Xxx+ (based on non premium renewal fees).
Houston.TV - I might go to High $Xxx - Low $X,xxx+ (based on guaranteed max. $500/year annual renewal fees).
NewYork.TV - Probably Mid $X,xxx+/+ (based on guaranteed max. $200/year annual renewal fees).

Also, I did not assume I won any lottery ... because it's not realistic (plus it wouldn't change what I would pay for this hypothetical purpose), but I would have a reasonable budget for these that also included the TOTAL cumulative expense for their (four domains) proper development(s) and respective marketing(s) (including heavy SEO), IMHO. :talk:

Just my two sense.
-Jeff B-)
 
0
Close
I will add one note which I alluded to but would also affect the price one would be willing to pay for a domain. We see it all the time that many businesses will build their business or even invest considerable sums into developing reg fee domains. With enough content and backlinks even these reg fee domains can make their way up the search rankings. They may be long, hyphenated or not even real phrases. The domain likely hurts their cause somewhat but the domain doesn't make or break the website because I see PR2-PR4 sites with such domains.

A solid keyword domain helps considerably for branding purposes and SEO efforts though so the price one should be willing to pay for a domain will reflect the branding and SEO value of entering a particular market. The business and the domain are separate. I am seeing companies which are branding .TV domains for their businesses and I would rather have WorkoutRoutines, WeightTraining, VestidosdeNovia, Sprinters, etc as a .TV brand than a lot of the .COM domains I see many sites using in the same space.
 
0
Close
Again, good point(s) Garp ... solid keywords are definitely more brandable & marketable, and can very much assist with critical SEO but those domains - especially in light of the annual renewal fees for premium .TV's - will likely have higher associated costs that must be factored in by the BUSINESS; another thought or concern for the business would have to be what these ongoing costs might be, as well as their potential inefficencies and dilutive effects on existing TLD's such as the ".TV", by up-and-coming new gTLD's (the highly brandable .WEB, for instance), IMHO. :yell:
If there is a new gTLD marketed specifically for video-centric platform, this must be a consideration insofar as .TV valuations ... so it's hard for me to separate the domain name from the buisness, in this context. :gl: :imho:

Best regards,
-Jeff B-)
 
0
Close
For branding purposes I would prefer a .COM domain over a .TV and due to the renewal cost would have a slight preference for a .NET over a .TV. Any other extension doesn't come close to interesting me for branding purposes. Yes, a $1000 annual renewal would be a huge hurdle for a minisite to overcome but a company planning to develop a megasite will just consider the renewals a cost of doing business. Candy.com was recently sold for $3 million and while I'm sure there is direct navigation traffic to go along with that, how much of a hurdle is the acquisition price (if financed at 8-12% interest, implied $240K-$360K in annual interest charges)? Even a modest $5000 .COM purchase which is financed has an implied opportunity cost of several hundred dollars (capital is not free). OK .TVs do have a pricetag but the difference in acquisition price will normally offset any premium renewals. And again, what percentage of .TVs domains held by forum members are premium renewals? In my case less than 1%.
 
0
Close
Geez - what a load of crapa$$ talk and not a single person did the simple thing that George asked... simply name your frikkin purchase price for the names. Like this:

Raleigh.TV - $3000
StLouis.TV - $5000
Houston.TV - $10000
Seoul.TV - $10000
NewYork.TV - $25000
Tokyo.TV -$20000

Those are speculative prices. Whats so hard? Is it that some people feel such a need to shovel $#I+ against .tv they see every single thread as a chance to shovel more? WTF is up with that?!? I'd hate to be you guys. Probably never accomplish a single real and substantial good work in your lives since you'll spend all of your precious time here on Earth denigrating the work of others. I've know a lot of people like that in real life (some I made the mistake of hiring and discovered too late what they were really about) and they are all less than worthless - genuine liabilities to whatever organization they belong to.

If you feel that strongly against it then the proper thing in this thread would have been to do something like

Raleigh.TV $-500
etc, etc

thereby implying that someone would need to PAY you to take it off their hands. Not only would that have been a little bit funny it would also have been respectful to the thread starter while at the same time maintaing you personal s***-shovling quota.

So can y'all do the valuation excercise for real?? I'd really like to see it. Not only that but I'd like to throw a twist in the game and ask what would your SELLING price be if you owned those very same names. I can tell you mine easily - across the board f I owned any of these I would NEVER sell!
 
0
Close
Geez - what a load of crapa$$ talk and not a single person did the simple thing that George asked... simply name your frikkin purchase price for the names.

:hi:

I can't speak for others, but I did specifically & personally answer the question (with an acknowledgement, as Garp mentions, that there are likely many other factors and costs to be fully considered when arriving at these individual ranges); :gl:
Raleigh.TV - Perhaps up to Low - Mid $Xxx (based on non premium rewewal fees).
StLouis.TV - Maybe in the vicinity of Mid - High $Xxx+ (based on non premium renewal fees).
Houston.TV - I might go to High $Xxx - Low $X,xxx+ (based on guaranteed max. $500/year annual renewal fees).
NewYork.TV - Probably Mid $X,xxx+/+ (based on guaranteed max. $200/year annual renewal fees).


crapa$$ talk
frikkin
shovel $#I
WTF
less than worthless
personal s***-shovling


^ No need for rudeness, angst and hostilities, please.

Kind regards,
-Jeff B-)
 
0
Close
:hi:

I can't speak for others, but I did specifically & personally answer the question (with an acknowledgement, as Garp mentions, that there are likely many other factors and costs to be fully considered when arriving at these individual ranges); :gl:



[/B]

^ No need for rudeness, angst and hostilities, please.

Kind regards,
-Jeff B-)

Taken out of context any words or letter can be made to seem like anything else. If I was rude I sincerely apologize but I'm just talking straight up. Lots of BS been slung in this forum lately.

Yep, you gave a range. At least we know that there is a price at which you'd buy, even if it is ridiculous. No offense intended. Really.
Now how about a price you'd sell for if you were already the owner? If you owned newyork.tv would you sell it to me for 10k?
 
Last edited:
0
Close
Taken out of context any words or letter can be made to seem like anything else. If I was rude I sincerely apologize but I'm just talking straight up.

Fair enough, thanks for the professional discussion. :talk:

Yep, you gave a range. At least we know that there is a price at which you'd buy, even if it is ridiculous. No offense intended. Really.
Now how about a price you'd sell for if you were already the owner? If you owned newyork.tv would you sell it to me for 10k?

My personal "range" will admittedly likely be different than the next person's, as we all have different price points, expectations, resources (including reserved expenses for critical developments and marketings), as well as perceptions of costs and other risk factors (as discussed above) ... if I actually owned NewYork.TV, I'd plan for developing it properly (and, thus, it wouldn't be for sale)! :gl: :imho:

Thanks again, onward and upward.
-Jeff B-)
 
0
Close
Fair enough, thanks for the professional discussion. :talk:



My personal "range" will admittedly likely be different than the next person's, as we all have different price points, expectations, resources (including reserved expenses for critical developments and marketings), as well as perceptions of costs and other risk factors (as discussed above) ... if I actually owned NewYork.TV, I'd plan for developing it properly (and, thus, it wouldn't be for sale)! :gl: :imho:

Thanks again, onward and upward.
-Jeff B-)

NFS?? What about for $500,000?
 
0
Close
I actually owned NewYork.TV, I'd plan for developing it properly (and, thus, it wouldn't be for sale)! :gl: :imho:

Sounds like a man coming out of the closet.
 
0
Close
Raleigh.TV
StLouis.TV
Houston.TV
Seoul.TV
NewYork.TV
Tokyo.TV

If sufficiently bankrolled, I would pay 40-75k for New York
Houston 10k-20k
Tokyo 5-10k. Its a great city, but not English language which would make development much more challenging.
Seoul, St. Louis, Raleigh are harder calls, unless I lived in those regions I would shop around similar sized cities and see where I could get the best deal. There are a fair number of mid-size US cities floating around, and if it wasn't a question of easy access to local development resources I wouldn't be as particular, as there would be many suitable options.

Resell, I would be looking for at least 5x purchase, I would expect the value (and resell price) to rise significantly within 3 years. If I only had one, and had the bankroll it would probably not be resold unless an absolutely fantastic offer came in. Would definitely be worth developing. I've seen some really good opportunities on this forum which I would have jumped on very quickly if I had been in a position to do so.

Given that the question is about being financially bankrolled to make this kind of move, and presumably follow up with development, I would consider the premium fee X10 as part of the price factor. So if I have 500/yr renewals, then I'm adding 5k and calling it the purchase price. If I can't do anything with it in ten years to make it worth much more than the initial investment cost, then it would be clear that I was doing it wrong, and I'd have to look for a buyer that was competent enough to do something with that type of asset. I would be extremely surprised if in 5 years a developed Geo.tv is not a featured option in the local market from a TV console, and isn't listed in the world city directory listings on the same device.

Geo.tv is not the only place I'd be looking, but the potentials are obviously quite large in that area for serving local markets, and I would buy at least one if the opportunity and the capital coincided.
 
0
Close
Sounds like a man coming out of the closet.

Maybe I am warming up a bit on these Geo .TV's (for development purposes); especially if I've also set some necessary funds aside for their proper development and marketings, and at reasonable acquisition costs and ongoing price structure IMHO. :gl:

See you soon (speaking of Geo's, I'm off this week for golf & summer travels)! :music:
-Jeff B-)
 
0
Close
especially if I've also set some necessary funds aside for their proper development and marketings, and at reasonable acquisition costs and ongoing price structure IMHO. :gl:

good luck with that...
 
0
Close
see you soon (speaking of Geo's, I'm off this week for golf & summer travels)! :music:
-Jeff B-)

Don't be gone for too long...not sure how we'll cope without you...
 
0
Close
Appraise.net

We're social

Escrow.com
Spaceship
Domain Recover
CryptoExchange.com

NamePros updates

Filters for activity feeds
Your news feed, Latest activity, and the activity tab on profiles now have filter buttons: All, Posts, Quick replies, and Other. Your...
AIVikings
Catchy
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back