Good idea!
It might even be helpful to add some criteria that lays out what is expected from the feedback, just to dissuade less constructive comments.
I'll provide you my pros and cons with respect to your new name, and will conclude with a summary of my thoughts.
Name:
HomeRunAdvice.com
Pros
- Positive meaning.
- Passes the "radio test" (easy to spell/speak).
- Memorable, thanks to word association with a popular sports metaphor.
- "Advice" is a decent keyword, with 23 names containing it having been sold in 2020 so far.
- Potential double meaning (i.e. added versatility) - Either really good advice, or advice on how to hit home runs.
Cons
- While "hitting a home run" is a common metaphor for success, "home run advice" is not a commonly used term.
- No existing businesses seem to be branding or advertising using this term.
- Not registered in any other extensions.
- "Home Run" is not terribly popular as a term for past recorded sales on NameBio. In fact, only three similar sales have ever been recorded in the last 10 years:
- HomeRunDeliveries.com for $210 in 2019
- HomeRunDigital.com for $103 in 2016
- While "advice" is a decently popular keyword, most higher sales (i.e. four figure) are for names that allude to a specific type of advice, such as:
- Legal advice
- Career advice
- Dating advice
- A name with a similar feel, ProAdvice.com, was sold for $2,600 in January, however "pro" is a very popular keyword adjective, and many existing businesses are using that specific name to brand or advertise themselves.
Conclusion
While I like the sound of the name, the above factors force me to conclude that it does not make for a good investment name. I would not buy or hold it myself, as I believe it has a very low chance of selling, and if it does the sales price would not be substantial enough to make the purchase/hold worthwhile.
I do, however, like the name for development purposes. If I were starting a website centred around advising others, this would make for a memorable brand that could set you apart from other similar businesses. The metaphor could lend itself well to a very fun logo that would help engrain the brand into the minds of your customers.
So,
short answer - Buy and hold it? No. Use it yourself? Yes!