Which one?

[0Degree]

Hey guys my friend and I are having a dispute. HE never likes any design I do. I am starting to do websites for a job now. I have several contracts now. But I finally started to work on my website... and yet again he thought it was crap. This guy has absolutely no taste.... and he’s lazy when it comes to websites. He has been using templates his whole life.....



Here are both revisions:

http://fattyslims.com/clients/0degree/ my revision (Louis)


http://needcgi.com/0degree/ His revision (Andrew)



Here is some of the websites he has designed in the past:

http://www.servicebrostransport.com/
http://www.idslv.com



Here is some of the website I designed in the past:

http://www.fattyslims.com/2/
http://www.fattyslims.com/lsuite
http://fattyslims.com/clients/efficientelectric.com/
http://fattyslims.com/old2/old/
http://fattyslims.com/clients/lvc.net/ (design soon to drastically change)
http://fattyslims.com/ol2/index2.shtml


So far on what you seen who is the best designer? And based on both the revisions for the 0 Degree website, which one is better?


Thanks guys....

-Louis

 

[SB_GEMINI]

Tough decision, id probably go for Andrews version because it's less cluttred,

their is still a lot of work to be done on them both but his looks like a good start.

 

[0Degree]

Fact of the matter is: He used photoshop to create that. And it was version 7.0. That is a pathetic attempt with photoshop. And this is a professional company... It isn't supposed to be a personal site like his. I can't believe you just said that..... Out of all the sites in your SIG that you designed....
http://www.robertdeniroonline.tk/ that was the only good one. The rest reminded me of this page: http://www.motorcyclefun.org/ and this page: http://www.surecann.com/

 

[.X.]

I like your friends better,The fonts are clearer,the design is just better IMO

 

[0Degree]

Its really funny, I thought this forum would be a good place for critque.... but so far I ahve gottne bad comments from people who have shitty design skills. All the website(s) in your signatures suck....... They are horrible. Once again thye remind me of www.motorcyclefun.org and www.surecann.com See the problem is if I was lookign for a pizaz web designer and I found this: http://fattyslims.com/clients/0degree/ and this:
http://needcgi.com/0degree/ I would pick http://fattyslims.com/clients/0degree/ His graphix have no cool out standing fonts, he has no roll overs, he made photoshop look like banner maker pro, or button studio..... Its rediculous. You guys need some pointers on your sites, before you give anyone any critque... so please leave the web design to someone who knows about it.....

 

[.X.]

Its really funny, I thought this forum would be a good place for critque.... but so far I ahve gottne bad comments from people who have shitty design skills. All the website(s) in your signatures suck....... They are horrible. Once again thye remind me of www.motorcyclefun.org and www.surecann.com See the problem is if I was lookign for a pizaz web designer and I found this: http://fattyslims.com/clients/0degree/ and this:
http://needcgi.com/0degree/ I would pick http://fattyslims.com/clients/0degree/ His graphix have no cool out standing fonts, he has no roll overs, he made photoshop look like banner maker pro, or button studio..... Its rediculous. You guys need some pointers on your sites, before you give anyone any critque... so please leave the web design to someone who knows about it.....

Uhhhh,I guess your a little upset,Well you are asking for opinions here,Take them as opinions,No reason to get all upset,Iam no pro webdesigner,But i do know quite a few things about websites,I own a few.I can just give you my honest opinion,That's all i did.

 

[SB_GEMINI]

You asked for our personal opinions by posting here, and i gave you may opinion in a fair way. I am not trying to offend you, none of us here are claming to know everything about web site designing we are just trying to help out other people.

 

[OZarts]

True, if you can't take other's opinions, don't ask for them.

I too agree with SB GEMINI, it is tough choosing from the two. And they both definitely need more work. In fact, they don't seem to far from www.motorcyclefun.org . A site you seem to hate yourself!!

I know this is harsh, but you asked for opinions, this is mine.

 

[GJ]

I like your one better without that odd logo in the nav bar.

 

[nicedomain4sale]

I like the Andrew's one, because it is not too big compare to yours.
Consider using smaller font.

 

[ArgieD]

Jeez; nobody hates or dislikes you or your products. Please calm down

Personally I preferred yours by far, but the way you try to bring your mate's work down grooms everybody's answers to be slightly negative..

PS Good job though

 

[6Webs]

Yours is a decent start but go a little smaller on the buttons and graphics. Smaller tight graphics would work well. I think you have a better hold on the design aspect of things. Your friends looks a little cleaner but it looks like a hokey site.

Your's is better if you take my suggestions. Good job!