JasMate said:
Could not agree with you more, it has always perplexed me also.
Let me know when (if) you get the forum finished, I would LOVE to beta test it :D
I would love to have another beta tester. Email me, tekime on gmail so I remember.
Seems the other solutions are lackluster because they go in there with the goal of cloning vBulletin, and vBulletin is pretty simple from a user perspective. Okay, we have a forums view, forum view, topic view, private messages, oh yes a calendar some icons and a few other "details". No problem, I can whip that up in a weekend.
But then developers get their hands dirty and realize vBulletin combines many components which
demand a solid common architecture, and which have astute attention to detail. Unless the team (or more likely, individual) has a real solid architecture to work from (interfaces, templates, rendering, validation, database, authentication, permissions, users, etc.), it becomes a serious task to code up a real contender. So the project makes concessions along the way, and even with grandiose plans will at best go the way of phpBB and the fifty year release cycle.
Anyway, I'm just ranting now. I'm sort of fired up as I just finished a new script similar to dollarlinking, and am finally finishing 2.0 for my CMS. Code on the brain. :D