What is ethical to some is unethical to others, so discussions, particularly, amongst members in a large, diverse forum, will never resolve to an answer that everyone will agree upon or be happy w/. Whatever, faisj decides to do w/ the name is ultimately up to him and, IMHO, to judge him would be hypocritical, because there are probably very few among us who haven't played an angle. Ethics are grey. A more black and white issue and where I would draw the line would be if faisj sold the name to another forum, which would than make this, clearly, a legal matter.
PS That is if "cleary legal" isn't an oxymoron. :hehe: