At first I was thinking $1k - $3k:
- Godaddy appraisal is $1,274 (not very accurate tool, but something to work from)
- brooklynathletics.com sold for $2,388 (don't know date)
- jerseysports.com sold for $3,500 (don't know date)
When checking namebio:
- superiorathletics.com sold on 10/1/2019 for $283 (arguably better name, broader, can be used for more purposes)
- eliteathletics.com sold on 5/26/2018 for $337 (probably better name, same as above)
So could try to price it up to $3k, if you want, but it might not sell and could be waiting for quite a while. Or could price it for ~$1k and it might sell sooner. List on afternic and dan lander.