In the LLLL.com world, Is "Y" a vowel? VOTE NOW

[GreenGambler]

I've noticed alot of arguments latley about if a Y is a vowel or a consonant.

I know that in English there are certain rules that apply when trying to decide if a Y is a vowel or not but those rules are hard to work with in the LLLL.com world.

So basically I want to see what the majority of us domainers think a Y is, when considering LLLL.coms?


Consonant or Vowel?

 

[GreenGambler]

I have the following on the 3rd position, and they are used as vowels in English
http://Oryd.com
http://Ovyd.com

I agree that they are pronouncable and that you can call the y's a vowel.

Sound like Orid and Ovid, IMHO!

I dont know why anyone has problems pronouncing that?

Just like my DN Ogyr.com, I call it Ogre or ( Ohh-Gerr)

 

[SJM211]

Y is never a vowel - simple as. At least not in the modern day English which we all speak.

Well said - I hate it when people advertise CVCV.coms only to find they contain y's where the vowels should be. Y isn't a vowel!

 

[italiandragon]

so we are not going to agree on anything here , are we?