When gift sites were new and exciting, i.e. about 16 years ago, you might have made a good sale on this. Nowadays, the novelty has worn off and the market has changed. It is a nice name, although giveagift.com would be better. However, it is simple and brandable to some extent. If you are going to sell it, then don't sell low. I think $2,000 would not be an unreasonable ask but you might take a very long time to find a buyer (if ever).