I will do a review for both.
First, your site:
The Bad
- You should have a link overlay color on your buttons.
- You should highlight the selected button for the appropriate page.
- The forum search does not work.
- The forum search should not differ in color from the other buttons.
- The bar at the bottom (above the links) should be one color.
- In firefox the bottom piece is over 1px to the right and does not fit.
- You should take away the 1px line in the footer that goes up and down.
- If you go from home to free templates the site shifts down a bit.
- Sometimes the input area seems small and announcements should only be on main page.
The Good
- The page loads fast.
- The design is hot (I love it).
- Easy name to remember.
- Color scheme is wonderful.
- Navigation is easy.
For the forum:
The Bad
- Same things about search and highlight color on navbar.
- The blue and orange diagonal lines seem too dark or not glossy enough to match current theme.
- The light blue links are hard to read on that dark of a grey.
- The icons should match your site (I am not seeing any current icons for stats and stuff).
The Good
- You are using IPB which is not free, but looks great.
- You have implemented your overall theme to the forum.
- The design is nice and clean.
- It loads fast.
If you stick to the suggestions about the overall nit picky things I think this site can become amazing. I am not trying to give you a hard time. The hardest thing is getting a good design and you have one! Now you just have to work out the minor flaws.
Good luck and keep up the good work.