REQ-LOGO 。

[omelet]

H

 

[bingbang]

Congrats.

I think you didn't have a clear idea about what type of logo you'd like to have, that's why you didn't get one that perfectly fits your needs. Your ideas changed from post to post. Once you wanted something simpler, then you wanted more accessories, then you wanted it to glow.
Most of the time you preferred Altruist Design's concepts, so I think it's just fair you chose them as a winner, so you can work on the design together, instead of getting more people involved in vain.

Totally agree!

I would like also to add the fact that you should give an update when you reach your deadline. If you would have requested an extension after your first 10 days deadline, I think the mods would have approved your request.
Time is important, for everyone. We take from our time to concept a design and to make all the requested modifications, so you should do the same and consider to give updates frequently, otherwise you will get the same situation as this one.

 

[omelet]

Congrats.

I think you didn't have a clear idea about what type of logo you'd like to have, that's why you didn't get one that perfectly fits your needs. Your ideas changed from post to post. Once you wanted something simpler, then you wanted more accessories, then you wanted it to glow.
Most of the time you preferred Altruist Design's concepts, so I think it's just fair you chose them as a winner, so you can work on the design together, instead of getting more people involved in vain.

You hv strong personable style in your designs, which is not bad thing for some types of project. But in open contest I was looking for more variations in the character design

You can see I care more about the character designs, then the style ( color, etc). Your logo issue is that the cow character kept almost the same in different versions.

I got quite clear image in my mind but didn’t see much work getting close to it. I try to offer more of my expectations to you guys to get inspired but didn’t see much changes

Altruist do offered more variations so I engaged more with him

 

[omelet]

Totally agree!

I would like also to add the fact that you should give an update when you reach your deadline. If you would have requested an extension after your first 10 days deadline, I think the mods would have approved your request.
Time is important, for everyone. We take from our time to concept a design and to make all the requested modifications, so you should do the same and consider to give updates frequently, otherwise you will get the same situation as this one.

I need time to think and taste your concept/ design

 

[DianaGyms]

You hv strong personable style in your designs, which is not bad thing for some types of project. But in open contest I was looking for more variations in the character design

You can see I care more about the character designs, then the style ( color, etc). Your logo issue is that the cow character kept almost the same in different versions.

I got quite clear image in my mind but didn’t see much work getting close to it. I try to offer more of my expectations to you guys to get inspired but didn’t see much changes

Altruist do offered more variations so I engaged more with him

Thank you.

I feel like my characters did change, but maybe I just didn't get your hints of not liking them at all.

Anyway, good luck with the project, hope it will be successful.