Please attach a screenshot of the organic search traffic you are claiming. As per section rules, ALL traffic and or revenue claims MUST have supporting screenshots.
That's actually because search engines store your most visited sites and give them preference when you search. Those are not the true rankings of the site. Your actual rankings are no. 7 in google , #4 in AOL, >100 for yahoo n bing for cheap car seats.
See this for your actual rankings: http://www.mikes-marketing-tools.com/ranking-reports/
There are a lot of sites like siteometrics and software like Market Samurai and SEO PowerSuite that will give different ranking but ALL will confirm that the site is on #1 Page Ranking On Google