This is exactly what happened to me, I regged a nice domain and put it in the appraisal section, here's the post:
https://www.namepros.com/threads/a.1242421/
they all said "it means nothing to nobody at face value"
"Its bad. Get your money back, if possible"
"i don't usually say this but zero value. read around the forum more before you register another name"
and I stopped domaining after one week lol, this was in June.
Last week, I got an email from Afternic it sold for $399 (my first ever sale, probably worth more IMO)
and after getting that email, I immediately came back to domaining and got some other domains, and started again.
I respect the opinions from the appraisals section but they don't know everything, and sometimes you need to trust your gut