discuss BIN vs Price request

SpaceshipSpaceship
Namecheap AuctionsNamecheap Auctions
Namecheap AuctionsNamecheap Auctions
Watch

GoodKindName

Established Member
Impact
400
Hello fellow domainers.
Lately I have a dilemma.
I've been selling domains to end-users since 2020.
And all this time I was using Price request/contact form for 99% of my domains.

I know there is kind of consensus that BIN yields more sales, especially impulse ones.
I've been having significant success with my approach but thinking whether I would have it better with BINs.

I'm targeting range from mid 4 to 5 figures though, I wonder if that's where BINs might be less effective due to price sensitivity.

My main concern is that I'm still not confident enough to set strict prices as I'm focused on ngTLDs, and sales data for them is still scarce.

One benefit of price request landers is that I can evaluate a name and a buyer at the moment of inquiry and determine what to quote, also you are getting data about interest for a given domain over time, while with BIN the only data is whether it's bought or not.
There are views for each domain but this seems to be an unreliable metric.

So, I would love to hear from you, experienced people, where my logic is flawed and whether you have some insight or advice on this specific topic. Would be grateful for all contributions.
 
Last edited:
2
Close
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
GoDaddyGoDaddy
Hi

not so much that your logic is flawed …
but if you’ve been “selling to endusers since 2020 using the price request/contact form”

then is there really a dilemma?

you can always set bin
or bin/with a make offer option
or provide lease to own options

those are choices, which are not that hard to make.
doing your own test, will give you the best, info, you’ll ever need

imo..,,
 
2
Close
Sizing up the buyer first definitely helps on ngTLDs where comp data is thin.

The catch is you only ever see the leads who bothered to fill out the form.. the buyers who hate "request price" landers just close the tab and you never know they were there.
 
Last edited:
0
Close
you could test it on your own names, put BIN with a make offer button on half of them and keep price request on the other half for a few months, then compare how many leads and sales each side gets.
 
3
Close
Hi

not so much that your logic is flawed …
but if you’ve been “selling to endusers since 2020 using the price request/contact form”

then is there really a dilemma?

you can always set bin
or bin/with a make offer option
or provide lease to own options

those are choices, which are not that hard to make.
doing your own test, will give you the best, info, you’ll ever need

imo..,,
thank you biggie
a proper test would definitely provide the best data
the issue is that i was trimming names to have a more quality portfolio over time, and now at around 400 names which seems like a pretty small sample size but guess i have to work with what i got
tbh mainly im just scared of commiting to bins after being on price request all this time
 
0
Close
Sizing up the buyer first definitely helps on ngTLDs where comp data is thin.

The catch is you only ever see the leads who bothered to fill out the form.. the buyers who hate "request price" landers just close the tab and you never know they were there.
indeed, i can imagine some buyers being hesitant to fill out the form, but the question is would they be the ones hitting bin given they are not serious enough about the domain to at least contact

yes, sizing up the buyer is what i appreciate the most about price request

on the other hand, there is Logan Flatt who is known for some killer new tld and alt extensions bin sales who said that he priced those names with the best case end-users in mind, which is why some see his pricing as overinflated yet it works

i think that requires deep understanding of the target buyer to pull it off which me and others might not posess
 
0
Close
you could test it on your own names, put BIN with a make offer button on half of them and keep price request on the other half for a few months, then compare how many leads and sales each side gets.
this seems like a good approach but there is an issue with sample size (in my case half would be just 200 names) and properly splitting the folio to have both part equal in quality which seems very hard
but perhaps this is something to try regardless
 
0
Close
Before switching I'd start tracking how many inquiries each name gets and what price you actually close at. Without that you have nothing to compare BIN against, especially on ngTLDs where there's barely any sales data. I'd put BIN first on names that already had a few inquiries and where you roughly know the price, and keep the most expensive ones on request
 
0
Close
thank you biggie

tbh mainly im just scared of commiting to bins after being on price request all this time
Hi

wtf are you scared of…
either you try or you don’t

imo…
 
1
Close
AIVikingsAIVikings

We're social

Escrow.com
Spaceship
Domain Recover
CryptoExchange.com

NamePros updates

Filters for activity feeds
Your news feed, Latest activity, and the activity tab on profiles now have filter buttons: All, Posts, Quick replies, and Other. Your...
AIVikings
Catchy
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back