Have you ever been to a website that gives you the meaning of your name? This domain would be perfect for such a thing.
Now one thing I'd like to point out is that for "What" domain name names, the comps are all the sales starting with WHAT...because each phrase is unique, you can't search for the full domain string and expect to see a sale, unless it's sold in the past because the domain IS ASKING A QUESTION, this is if you only look for comps in .com, you could search it an all extensions and try and use a multiplier to account for the liquidity difference i.e .net is 1-10% of the .com etc.
4 Words isn't ideal, but this phrase is searched 246,000/mo | CPC: $0.24. There is moderate TLD demand, it's taken in 10 extensions. Searching the term shows multiple websites all related to name meaning....so there is very, very clear build out potential. I would never, ever drop this name. It's a highly searched phrase and the domain itself has been registered since 2003.
Comps:
whatismyip.com
⇒
info similar sales visit backorder brokerage
July 2005 $ 386,100.00 USD
eBay
whatshot.com
July 2006 $ 26,150.00 USD SnapNames
whatsthescore.com
June 2012 $ 17,000.00 USD AfterNIC
whatthe.com
April 2011 $ 15,088.00 USD AfterNIC
whatmatters.com
July 2014 $ 15,000.00 USD
Uniregistry
whatsnext.com
May 2014 $ 12,500.00 USD AfterNIC/
GoDaddy
whatsgoingon.com
February 2014 $ 10,000.00 USD
Uniregistry
whatsgood.com
September 2013 $ 5,000.00 USD
whatareyouinto.com
Valuation:
Retail $5.5k to $20k+ or more it depends on how motivated the buyer is to own this name as there is clear build out potential.
Wholesale: $500 to $1150 ( I wouldn't sell it to another investor for less than $500.)